«Never again«after waiting 30 mins the waitress came out and brought the pizzaand said» the cook forgot rest of the order, that it will take another 15 minutes. well any orders were still messed up. After complaining to the waitress she said there’s nothing she can do about it. Oh by the way the pizza was burnt. Very poor attitude on the waitresses Part, when she brought the bill she had the gall to ask if we wanted any change back. That’s why I left her a penny. Very unprofessional on June 14th2016. I will never walk in that place again or recommend it to anybody
Nunya B.
Rating des Ortes: 2 York, PA
March 2016. Now that this place is all remodeled and fancy everyone there got stupid and slow. The last time we were there we were not given straws with our drinks until I noticed everyone else in the place had them. I like some of their food but I learned long ago to avoid their«hamburg» because it is cheap garbage. A friend of mine said today that it is a cheap place to eat(?). He must get some sort of discount! They also don’t believe in putting onion on some sandwiches but will as long as you pay extra. The old place might have been a lot less fancy but it sure moved faster! I’ll eat there when invited but only trust various steak and tuna sandwiches. 05/26/2016. We go here every now and then but on this day the inner door for the dining room was locked but we could see four people at a table eating. We tried the other door right next to it for lunch and carry out and it was open so we went in that way. The doors are stupid.
Armando R.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Howard County, MD
First time and the service was excellent very friendly staff, but the best part was the meat lovers pizza OHMY sooooo goooood!!! Will definitely be coming back
Suzannah C.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Seven Valleys, PA
First restaurant I tried moving into Loganville unfortunately a disappointing experience. Service was slow and understaffed I ordered the sausage Parmesan sub and got pizza fixings on a sub roll who in the world serves sausage bologna that’s the only way I can describe it my husband cheesesteak was mediocre at best he didn’t even finish half of it I cannot recommend this establishment at all.
Megan B.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Towson, MD
I’m so excited to find this place since we’re new to the area. I’ve visited a few times — take out and sit down, and every experience was delicious. I’ve had the chicken parm subs, cheesesteak Stromboli, and a pasta dish. SOGOOD. I want to try the pizza but with all the good food I’ve had already, it’ll be hard to branch out. Highly recommend.
Mark S.
Rating des Ortes: 2 York, PA
Another lousy meal at Mamma’s, the Gnocchi was so overcooked it was rubbery. The sauce is ok and the sausage had that funky«going bad» taste. On the plus side the salad was good and the garlic bread was also good, the service. Not so much. This used to be a really good place, before Pete passed away, it’s been all downhill since. Mamma’s makes Olive Garden seem gourmet, it didn’t use to be like that.
Kari K.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Seven Valleys, PA
My friend and I try to get it once a month. My husband is not a fan but he is weird lol
Mapinpa P.
Rating des Ortes: 1 New Freedom, PA
I tried getting served on June 30 only to sit for over 15 minutes before I gave up and left! The irony of it all was there were 3 workers on the lunch side of the restaurant bullshitting with each other, only to tell me that I had wait to be served on the«dinner» side of the restaurant! These people truly don’t have a clue about serving the customer. Another great example of lousy customer service in York County! I will never go back to this place.
Annabella W.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Cockeysville, MD
My family and I tried this place for the first time being new to the area. We are from Chicago therefore we love pizza! Very disappointed!!! The food was overall BLAHBLAHBLAH! The fries, onion rings, appetizers all tasted like dirty grease! Blackened in Color, like they needed to chg the oil in their fryers. Or something, very disgusting. We got a veggie n a meat lovers pizza, cheese was cheap n fake tasting! Way overpriced!!! AVOIDTHISPLACE!!!
Tim H.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Columbia, MD
This place has good pizza with fresh toppings and tasty meats. It’s a hearty slice if you are into pizza, give this place a try. The only thing I would caution you about is the amount of grease since it is loaded with cheese and meats, if you get meats, and it can be overwhelming at times. Just make sure to dab a paper towel over your slice to get the excess grease off. Over all, my pizza and side salad were great. Thanks for reading my review. This review is based off of my personal experience and point of view.
J T.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Carlsbad, CA
Authentic Italian food. Great place in a small town. The place expanded since my last visit in the late 90s. Family owned and operated business! The bread is home made and the pizza is awesome. Try some pizza fries.
Cody S.
Rating des Ortes: 4 York, PA
I live right by Mama’s so we eat there a lot. The food is pretty good. Pizza is better than average. The bread is amazing. My only complaint is the dinners are a bit expensive for what you get.
Mike L.
Rating des Ortes: 5 York, PA
Mama’s Pizza went through a full renovation a few years back. There is a full dining room on one side and carry out on the other. They have everything from hot and cold subs to pizza and full Italian meals. I usually get pizza or subs for carry out, so I cannot comment much on the dining room other than it seems nice and can get busy. Food is always hot and prepared perfectly. I frequent this establishment at least once a week and have never been disappointed.