Gara’s Pizza

Great food, great service. Love their Mediterranean salad and margarita pizza.

The pizza there is pretty good, but if you want hot pizza in a timely matter, don’t order for delivery. The first time took almost an hour and the pizza was cold. We figured we would give them a second chance … an hour and a half after ordering, 90 minutes, and we still hadn’t received our pizza. We live about a mile away … 90 minutes? We called and cancelled. We are going to try Frank’s.

Pretty good pizza. Call ahead, they tend to be busy. Good staff and the food is good. Try the calamari, its not overcooked like most I had in the area and the little addition of banana peppers makes it awesome. And be sure to bring cash, they add some credit card fee to your bill.

Their food is ok but the service is utterly horrible! They really need to train their staff better. You call and and say you would like to order for delivery and the teen on the phone says ok. Dead silence after that, so I wait then say — would you like the order or the address first? Another OK from the teen. OK, what I ask? — the order or address? Really frustrating — It’s like talking to a wall. Next try, went in to pick up a couple slices, that didn’t go any better since the counter girl forgot to put the slices in the oven. Done with this place. With so many other places in the area why bother when they don’t?!!

Gara’s has awful food, nothing good about it… just over priced disgusting tasteless food! Their pizza crust is very flat, the sauce has no taste since they add no seasoning to it, just take it right out of the can and dump it right on. The dinners are horrible, I will never order anything from them again. My lasagna looked like it was frozen prepackaged crap out of a box with nasty tasteless sauce thrown on top of it. Nothing appealing about the look or taste of their dinners. I’m telling all my friends to not waste your time with this place. Also I found a hair in my pizza yesterday that my coworkers had ordered, ewww so gross! STAY AWAY from this place you will be disappointed not worth the money and the staff and owner are very rude to the customers! If anyone thinks this place is good then you really don’t know what good food is! Save your money don’t spend it on this garbage!

Great pizza. Definitely some high quality cheese going into their pies.
The homestyle «Jersey» fries are addictive.
I wasn’t crazy about their standard cheesesteak. I haven’t tried it yet, but I would guess it’s more than worth it to upgrade to the Ribeye.
Bring cash unless you get bonus rewards for restaurants on your credit card. They add 3% for credit card transactions.

Every time I am in town, got to have a Gara’s pizza. My favorite now is the Margaretta pizza. This is good. A word to the wise for any of you with warrants out or for those of you driving with suspended licenses, this place is frequented by Lopatcong police and it is often you will find one or two of them sitting in this place and eating dinner. So, make sure if you show up and park in the parking garage your car is tagged, your license is up to date and no warrants out for you!
Great pizza.

Order from here all the time, a family favorite, delivery is fast and the food is cooked right.

Above average pizza for this neck of the woods. I order pizza n subs from them about once a month. Its the only pizza place in the area i can tolerate

It’s Ok

I order lunch from here all the time, usually a Grilled Chicken Salad and it’s the best I can find in the area.