Middletown Roofing, Windows, & Siding

I had Middletown Roofing replace my roof in 2009. In December of 2014 the roof started leaking in multiple places. I called Middletown Roofing and they said it was probably a defective shingle and it was strictly between me and the shingle manufacturer. Rather than removing shingles form my own roof and mailing them into the lab for testing, I sought out guidance from other area roofers. I had three roofing contractors and a mechanical engineer inspect the leaks. Each one told me my shingles were not defective. It was a workmanship issue that took this many years to present itself and that Midddletown Roofing should correct the problem. A rep from Middletown inspected the roof and «didn’t know why the roof was leaking,» but left me with an estimate for repairs. I appealed to the president of the company. After inspection of my roof he said there was one decking nail pop causing the leaking over the entire expanse of the master bedroom. According to the president of Middletown Roofing the milky discoloration in the area (that I can also see leaking into the attic) above the master was from painters spilling paint on top of the roof (they used scaffolding and were never on top of my roof). The other roofers said it was physically impossible for water to spread over such a large area over one deck pop because of the rafter bays in the roof. Water could not jump in the attic from one bay to another. Middletown Roofing refused to make any repairs and said he was not liable for the poor workmanship because he purchased Middletown Roofing after my roof was installed. I am stuck with a five-​year-​old $ 7,000 roofing job that is leaking like a sieve.

Beware of Middletown Roofing! Unprofessional management, poor workmanship, and NO WARRANTY.
We had them out to repair some flashing and caulk a window and the workmanship was very sloppy. They used much larger pieces than we had elsewhere because he was just covering up the old work. When I questioned it, the only response I received was «is more better». 6 months later it started leaking, damaging our newly repaired ceiling. I called them back and they found that the caulking had failed at the top of the flashing leaving a gap. When quoting the job they stated they would grind out the mortar of the brick joints and tuck the flashing in, apparently that had not happened. I asked that they redo the job and they said the receipt I signed stated NO WARRANTY. I pushed the issue and they then stated they couldn’t redo it because they no longer work with the person who did the install. What? Are they just sub-​contracting out the work and keeping the profit? I pushed some more and they must have found their man because he was back out to try again, more sloppy work, nails left behind for my kids to find, and 3 months later leaking again! This time they said it may be the window above with no caulking. You mean the one that we paid to have caulked on the original work order? Apparently it never happened! I was fed up and asked for a refund, they again said I signed a contract that said NO WARRANTY. I pushed some more and they finally offered to refund the cost of the caulking that never got put on, ten whole bucks. Thanks but no thanks.