Kohr Family Frozen Custard

This place is literally the worst. DO NOT COME HERE. I paid $ 8.55 for an custard with waffle cone. I honestly feel like I got robbed. They did not have any pricing listed in the store. (Probably for the reason that it’s outrageously overpriced-​they don’t want to scare people away until it’s too late and the cone is already made).
The taste:
Super average. Nothing special.
Not worth it. Don’t waste your money.

I wish I read the reviews on this place before I ordered. I noticed they have no prices posted, so I asked. I did realize their prices are above what I expected but we ordered a waffle cone anyway. When I asked about the prices, the girls at the counter said they can tell me the prices. I even wondered if they made up these prices, but after seeing the other reviews I realized this is what they charge. The ice cream wasn’t very good, we’ve had much creamier ice cream elsewhere. We paid less even at Universal Studios/​Harry Potter — where you would expect to pay a premium. And the ice cream at Universal was really good. And for this price I would expect a large serving — nope, it wasn’t very big at all.
To the owners — put up a price list and reconsider your exorbitant prices. I do not recommend anyone to have ice cream here. Sub par quality, poor quantity and over priced.

Mediocre custard.
No prices listed (they are double every other place in Johns Pass)
Served by bitter staff.
AVOID AVOID AVOID

Two single waffle cones for $ 14.88! Not even good. They don’t post their prices, and when they rang up the purchase, my husband gave the cashier $ 10 and he had to ask for more money! Rip off. I should have had a clue when we were the only customers! Ouch

This was a terrible experience! What a rip off. Over $ 6 for a ice cream cone. The prices aren’t advertised, of course. Ice cream was below average at best, but had to finish the whole thing since it was $.50 a lick.

I usually come to Unilocal to see reviews and missed the negative reviews of this place. ALL TRUE. There is a reason they don’t post the prices: 2 cones (there is only one size-​mediumish) $ 12.29. We were floored. Sad. The custard was good, but the entire time you’re eating it, you can’t help but feel ripped off.

The reviews are right. This place sucks. You guys can read the other reviews, but I’ll still give my take.
The dude at the counter is nice. He’s helpful. That’s about the only positive of this place.
The place is expensive. They take cash only. And the custards are about $ 7 each. $ 7! I don’t know why it’s so expensive. Maybe the rent is super high. They only have one size. It’s kinda small for $ 7.
The Custard was custardy. It was rich and creamy. But it wasn’t $ 7 good. We got the strawberry custard. It was rich and creamy, like I said, but the flavor wasn’t any different from Publix strawberry ice cream. The only difference was the texture.
At our hotel, 2 scoops of Haagen Daz, which is about the same size as what Kohr gives you, is about half the price of Kohr’s. And that’s at a hotel where they overcharge everything. And the Haagen Daz tastes much better.
Not only that, they don’t even post the prices. You don’t realize what you got until it’s too late. It’s almost scammy.
So I would avoid this place. There’s probably better dessert places in this area.

Why 3 stars? Because it was delicious, but pricey.
— — —
After a meal at John’s Pass, our sweet teeth had been kicked into high gear. We noticed Kohr before dinner, and definitely knew we’d be circling back on our way out.
Apparently they have ice cream and custard, and each type has its own set of flavors. I opted for strawberry banana in a cone, which is odd for me. But they offered us a sample piece of cone, and I knew that I had to go that route. That may have been my favorite part of the experience. My fiancé went with chocolate chip in a cup because she’s a silly goose.
So, as everyone else has mentioned — what’s up with the price? $ 13.58 for two ice creams? You can buy 3 half gallon tubs for that price. Kohr Family: please be open to suggestions from the masses. Almost every review cites the price as a huge negative. I don’t think I’d return, and it looks like many others feel the same.

warning!!! over $ 7 for ice cream. prices not posted so they can keep fooling the tourists. do not support their slimey business

I totally agree with some of the other reviewers. We were in line and ordered three large size portions in cones. I was absolutely shocked at the prices but by then the kids had of course started to eat theirs. The custard was tasty enough but the prices were absurd, even for a tourist trap. We won’t be back.

Had Kohrs ice cream in Cape May, NJ last summer so I thought it would be good. My vanilla orange twist was soft but otherwise tasted OK, not as good as Cape May. But as others have written, they don’t post their prices and therefore shock you with what they charge. 4 small cones over $ 24! Will not return. If this were NY it would be illegal to not post prices. Meyers down the road charged $ 3.25 for a small ice cream. I expect to pay tourist prices on vacation but not get robbed.

The frozen custard was good, but as almost every review stated, the prices are higher-​than-​the-​usual-​vacation-​place-​ripoff.
To the owners; do the right thing and post your prices. The place is always so busy that by the time you make it to the front of the line, you just want your ice cream… that’s why people order without asking the prices (you probably figured that out, right?).

Waffle cone being freshly made attracted us… I love waffle cones. Didn’t even ask price. Almost 8 $ for a cone is a bit much, then I tasted it. Not good. Had wife try it, same result. Had the ice cream/​yogurt been good I would have given 4 stars. The cone was excellent. However the custard/​ice cream wasn’t. Will try other places, won’t go back there!

Total rip off! 7.95 for a small ice cream cone. They conveniently don’t post prices. Go to shake shop. Much better and prices right. I would give it zero stars if possible.

I agree with most of the other comments, no prices posted. I was shocked when they charged me 25 bucks for 4 cones. What!

This isn’t the same outfit as Kohr Brothers frozen custard; don’t even know if they are connected. The name was familiar so my son and I got in line, after I told him how good real frozen custard was.
This was decent, but maybe not as good as I remember frozen custard being. Any «ice cream» is at least ok, so of course we ate it. What I couldn’t get over was the price!!! Two small cups, no extras — over $ 12. I thought they had made a mistake. No prices posted anywhere. Isn’t there a consumer law that covers that?
Lots of other ice cream shops at John’s Pass. Save your money and try them.

$ 27 for two adults and two kids to have ice cream?! The ice cream was good, but not that good. Should have walked away when the drunk kids in front of us balked at their total. No prices posted anywhere. Don’t go here on purpose. There are tons of ice cream shops on the boardwalk.

MANDATORY!!! This place knocks the socks off of any competition! Don’t even bother going any place else — this family custard shop is the place to go!
With only a serving window and a handful of staple flavors, Kohr’s conjures up the wry fabric of America — simplicity and the spectacular all rolled into one! Kohr’s makes their own waffle cones on the spot, but cake cones are also available. Whether you pick ice cream or custard, chocolate or vanilla, you will be left craving more!

Well, I can’t tell you happy I was to see a Kohrs Bros custard shop! I have enjoyed their custard since the 80’s.
It was good but not great! I has the vanilla & chocolate swirl and while the vanilla was good an creamy the chocolate did not have the same consistency. My girlfriends had their actual ice cream and loved it.
My biggest complaint is that they DO NOT have their prices posted and I was shocked that the regular swirl cone was $ 6.79! That is just crazy. I thought he made a mistake, but unfortunately he had not. I would have never expected that from them. Has the prices been posted I could have made a decision as to whether or not I wanted to pay that price.
PLEASE POST YOUR PRICES! Because of how much I love your custard, I still would have paid it, it just would have been nice to know.

Definitely not the frozen custard that i am used to. If you have never had frozen custard, this is an OK alternative to frozen yogurt, but it does not compare to much better places that i have been to in the Midwest that sell frozen custard.
The other downsides to this place are: kids running the stand, poor customer service, price, no credit cards accepted and the flavors do not taste like what they are supposed to be. Do I need to go on? I had a peanut butter custard that tasted like rotten nuts! Pretty gross. Save your money and get an Italian ice or frozen yogurt somewhere else.
#Yelp100