Pretty Joe Rock Island

Cost is WAY too much for what you get.
Back deck is falling apart and steps to the water boarded up. No easy or safe way to get in and out of the water from the Island. Most of the shower in master bedroom is rotted.
Outside door in second bedroom does not lock (yes, we were told we didn’t need to lock doors, but you should be able to if you aren’t comfortable leaving your belongings and sleeping with doors unlocked!). It was just my husband and I staying here for 2 weeks, and before half of the first week went by we ran out of toilet paper and paper towels. We were treated like we were really imposing on them to request enough for our stay.
We also requested the linens be changed and the cottage cleaned after one week which created a complete uproar. Were told we would need to have the «dog» sheets put on the bed if we wanted them changed. These are sheets used by people who rent with dogs.
The boat does not have a bimini top as pictured, or a ladder to get in and out. We had to purchase an umbrella and ladder.
Kitchen is not even stocked with basics such as wraps and foils etc. First Aid kit is stocked with items that expired in 2005, or earlier.
Plan on doing alot of shopping for items you would expect to be there
There are lots of really nice places for rent in Marathon. Don’t waste your money.
Look around!

This is a gem!!! I am a Floridian native and my husband as well. We have traveled to the keys all of our life. We have stayed in the most upscale places such as Cheeca Lodge, Pines & Palm Resort, Pelican Cove just to name a few. I found this place with short notice (two days) before check in date. I called the number listed and spoke to «Mark», what a delightful man. I indicated to him I was celebrating my husbands 40^th bday, he was very helpful with planning my husbands special day. And to top it off, he gave me a discount! Un– heard of during «summer season» in the keys. Once we arrived, we were greeted by John, who was just as friendly and helpful as Mark. The home was better than I expected, everything at hands reach to keep the family busy. Boat, Kayaks, Snorkeling gear etc. The home is situated on a private island on the gulf side… AMAZING sunset views! I read one negative review on Pretty Joe Rock, the person complained about bugs and huge insects. This is on an island with nature surroundings, expect bugs, insects etc!!! The experience and memories built, were Priceless!