Bagel Pantry

Not sure what is so great about this place. This was my second time here. Ordered sandwiches both times, and was disappointed both times. Pork roll and egg sandwich had almost no egg on it. The sandwich was more bread than anything else. The coffee was OK.

3.75 stars.
I was craving a bagel with pumpkin cream cheese and they had it! We went during a quieter time so there wasn’t a crazy rush. My bagel was nicely toasted and cream cheese on point. I didn’t finish all of my bagel so I brought it home and snacked on it later. Hubby enjoyed his bagel too. Friendly staff with good bagels. Will probably be back!

This is my go to place whenever I want a bagel or a bacon and egg sandwich. I’ve never had anything to complain about whenever I go here. If you’re looking for somewhere in town to get a bagel or a breakfast sandwich, I highly recommend coming here. They even make bagels fresh everyday.

Great bagels! Service is fast and very friendly. One thing I miss here is the variety. They have about 8 – 10 of the more popular ones but not things like blueberry or jalapeño.

No complaints about the food. Bagels are great. One word of caution — It really grinds my gears when you watch the staff spread butter on a plain bagel w/​scallion cream cheese order, then without hesitation to fix his mistake, scrape the butter off and add the scallion cream cheese on the same bagel. I mean, who likes plain bagels with light butter and scallion cream cheese???
Plus they have issues with handling food and money at the same time but to each their own.

My favorite NJ bagel spot. Always fresh and tasty and fast service. Bagels are chewy and crisp on the outside with just the right flavor. The flavored cream cheeses are really great too– vegetable and blueberry being probably the best. Sandwiches are great and they are generous with portions. An easy choice.

This is the greatest bagel place on earth! The coffee is ok, the specialty cream cheeses are ok, but you don’t come here for that! You come here for an everything with scallion cream cheese or plain wit bacon egg and cheese. F the specialty shit! If you like the «unique» choices you are barking up the wrong tree. This place does the classics and does them well! Egg, everything, garlic, plain! Their Scallion cream cheese deserves rewards! Bagel Pantry is the God of bagels!

I dig bagel pantry a lot, it’s not the best bagel I’ve ever had in my life but it comes pretty close. Service is always fast and the guys are friendly. Their olive cream cheese is extremely tasty and their breakfast sandwiches are top notch.

This is my hometown bagel place. I have been coming here for the back 8 years. I was a customer when they were still in a little corner store and still come back when they moved to a more mordern café.
Now I’ve gone to college and the only thing I miss more than my family when coming home are the breakfast sandwiches from this place. Everything bagel with pork roll, egg, and cheese. Everytime.
I was only disappointed once, when I went on an afternoon because the bagel wasnt as fresh and it was kinda small. And they don’t recognize me anymore so I don’t get as friendly service.
But I will always vouch for them because they bagels are so damn good. A very mom and pop shop with a homey feel.

Love this place… great fresh bagels all the time and tastes great. No complaints. They make great coffee and I love the butter they use on the bagels. We order from here a lot because they are pretty consistent with the quality and good places are tough to find.
Even if the place is packed, they move quick and they don’t mess up in the process. The staff is friendly and everything is reasonably priced and fresh. Highly recommend!

I bought a dozen muffins this morning for work and every single one off them was old and stale tasting. Sooooo embarrassing. And shame on the owners for selling old goods. It should have been my first clue, the fruit salad sitting on the counter had brown strawberries covered in «fur». Shame shame shame!!!

After moving down to glassboro for school, I sure have missed a good bagel. Back when I went to St Joseph high school, this was always a spot to pick up food before school. Bagels are fresh and taste so light.
When you first walk in, it may seem a little hectic because it’s almost always crowded and busy and the space is kinda tight. But take one bite into a pork roll egg and cheese on an Everything bagel and you’ll feel as if you’ve been transported out of that teeny tiny bagel shop and into a universe where bagels are considered deities. But in all honesty, the sandwiches are probably the best I’ve had and even just a plain bagel with butter really hits the spot.
Love this place. Glad it’s summer and school is off so I can stop in more often!

Located right next to Middlesex Ave and William St, Bagel Pantry is my new favorite spot for bagels! The guys here are always so helpful and the bagel is out of this world!
I am from California, so I don’t know a lot about bagels to start off with, but I know deliciousness when I taste it! The place was easy to find and right as you walk in, you see a cabinet filled with freshly made bagels ranging from plain, poppy seeds, to garlic bagels.
Here’s the breakdown of our items:
–Eggplant Panini
As mentioned before, I am a complete novice in bagels, so i ordered a panini… haha! They make the panini right in front of you, they put in fresh ingredients and melt the cheese right in their panini press. The eggplant goes so well with all of the ingredients and being a person that almost always skips on the olives, I Loved the olives in here. Definitely a 5 star panini!
–Plain bagel with Lox and Smoked Salmon
This was suggested to me by my boyfriend. I mean after all, we did come to a Bagel Shop… haha I’ve had plenty of bagels before, but something about this one was just magical (i think it’s the random surprise of crispiness in the bread that takes it to the whole ‘nother level) They give you just the right amount of cream cheese, Lox, and the smoked salmon is high quality also. FIVE stars Bagel!
–Vegetable Lentil Soup
«it was very lentil-​y,» says the boyfriend. He rated it 3 stars for the soup.
Also, i would like to add that the soup comes with a full sized plain bagel (thumbs up)
–Pound cake
«FIVE stars,» says the boyfriend lol
It’s hilarious b/​c i was the one that wanted it, but after we unwrapped the cake, i went to get some water and came back with 90% of it gone. Of the bites that I had, the cake was fluffy and delicious and the sugary topping was the perfect amount of sweetness.
Definitely coming back for more!

Fantastic bagel shop. We have come here countless times and love the bagels. I love the lox sandwiches albeit they are pricey. Bagels are well priced and delicious! Service is nice too. One of our favorites!

Nice job, Bagel Pantry. Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a roll — salt, pepper, ketchup to dress it up. Wash that down with an OJ. Tropicana, of course (mini carton – never the bottle). Taylor ham had a nice crisp to it on the edges, which means they didn’t rush it and let it cook. Cheese was melted, Kaiser roll was fresh. My only issue was the egg. I like the egg fried so that the bread collects three yolky goodness. I wasn’t asked how the egg should be cooked. It was decided for me. Partially my fault for not mentioning my preference. But other than that, everything else was on par. They had a nice variety of bagels, muffins and other great looking treats. Plenty of parking available as it seems like the business shares their lot with a bunch of other businesses. The place is cozy with their tables, window counter and I think I saw a little couch as well. Solid place that I’d return to if I’m in the area again.

I love bagel pantry to a point that I get offended when someone goes to another bagel place in town. The bialys are a personal favorite in our house with eggs, cheese, and Taylor ham. The service is quick and friendly and the bagels are always fresh. When out of town friends come in search of a good bagel, this is where we head and they are always impressed.

When I first moved to town before I even unpacked my utensils I was basically living off of this place for breakfast every morning. The bagels and assortment of cream cheeses are delish but I would advise you to skip the muffins as they are not all that. The cappuccinos are on point as is the ease of getting in and out in a timely fashion. On the downside, the prices are a bit steep and for that reason I don’t frequent as much now.

I was driving through this area last week and decided to bring a dozen bagels back home to Philly. Unilocal brought me here.
After bringing said dozen back home and noshing on them this past week, I’ll tell you that I like the bagels overall. Their sesame bagels are as good as any I’ve had.
My wife wasn’t as much of a fan of the cinnamon raisin which I saw fall apart in her hands as she was eating it. I brought home some lox spread which I was actually slightly disappointed in. But I liked the strawberry cream cheese better.
It’s good enough.

A neighborhood favorite. The bagels have the home-​made texture and home made expiration date. To appreciate it, you must consume it ASAP, since if you store for a couple of days it turns to stone.
Ambiance is nice and comfy if you go in during non-​peak times.

Great, fast service. Friendly staff. DELICIOUS food. This is the best bagel shop in the tri-​state area.
There’s a reason the line is out the door on weekends. They also know my order on sight, after about 3 visits. I usually go, but once my sister went for me after back surgery. They knew who it was for and asked if I was okay! Awwww.