Bruster’s Real Ice Cream

Graham Central Station is the best flavor every! I also like Birthday Cake and Apple Pie flavors. I absolutely love this place especially the Middletown location. It has a beautiful outdoors seating area. One time I called just as they were making my favorite flavor and when I arrived they knew who I was, I got to speak directly to the owner who was extremely nice. I would buy it by the quarts because I had to have some accessible from my freezer.

I tried so hard to find Peach Melba, it’s either sold out, or they don’t have it. Finally today I get it in Middletown, DE! No regrets :)

The ice cream is fabulous. The coconut chip and peanut butter chocolate buckeye are creamy and full of flavor. The butter pecan and mint chocolate chip looked delish. We will be back!

Came here a few weeks ago because my brother had an intense craving for ice cream and DQ was closed. Having been here in the past I expected the same delicious ice cream I’d always had. WRONG
My brother was happy with his cone, but not being really in the mood for ice cream, and knowing that their ‘small’ is massive, I asked if there was anything smaller than their small. The girl taking our order looked at me like I was stupid, then rolled her eyes and said they had a baby size. Which I proceeded to order, BAD DECISION!
What I got was was a disgusting stale cone, I’m talking like as stale as stale can be. It tasted like cardboard, and there was no ice cream INSIDE the cone, just maybe a ping-​pong ball sized scoop on top.
Normally here I have a great experience, but I had to throw this cone out, and it will be a while before I go back.

Had a great experience at this local Brusters in Middletown. It was extremely creamy and not overly sweet (I had coconut chip). My 18 month old daughter received a free baby cone of vanilla and devoured it. My husband had the mint chocolate chip and was also really happy. This is definitely the real deal! Highly recommend Brusters!