Middletown Pizza & Pasta Restaurant

Hands down the best pizza in Middletown! Every time I have eaten there I have had very pleasant experiences. The staff is very friendly. I feel like I am home there. The food is high quality, delicious and served in generous portions. The cheesesteaks are beyond huge!!! One of, if not my favorite, restaurants in Middletown.

This place is fantastic whenever I go. They are always polite and courteous. Their pizza and Stromboli is the best I’ve EVER had. I highly recommend anyone give this place a try.

Overall, the experience eating at Middletown Pizza is pretty good, especially with your expectations with a local pizzeria, it surprised me.
With the look of the restaurant, it has a recreational modern design, with art on the wall. It looks clean, which is good.
The same with the food. There is a large selection of food on the menu, and everything is delicious, so I always come back to try something else.
Overall… Its a good pizzeria restaurant, and I recommend it to anyone in Middletown.

Didn’t try the pizza went with the pasta terrible decision. Their sauce can’t be homemade as advertised is was so bland. Nothing that I ordered was any good so I won’t be visiting this place again and if you choose to stick to the pizza.

Great pizza and service. If your in the mood stop in and give it a try.

Worst pizza I’ve had in DE. Just moved from Newark, DE to Middletown and figured I’d try some local places before I started calling Dominos and Papa Johns. Time to look elsewhere! Digiorno is much better than this place.

If you are used to pizza with a thin crust made on the premises, DO NOT GET THIS PIZZA. I think it was heated from frozen, it was so bad (although many frozen pizzas from the grocery store would have actually been way better than this monstrosity). Got a chicken parm that was quite tasty, but never again this pizza, a total disappointment. I make no judgement about the staff, we got take out, and it was ready when they said it would be. (If you are in Middletown, and are looking for a good pie try Caruso’s. I have no affiliation, just want to help others avoid the mistake I made)

So happy I could be the first to review this place. I have been coming here since about 2002 when I had first moved to Middletown. By far the best pizza and pasta that I’ve had really in all of Delaware. And I really have a hard time comparing any places in PA (of similar layout, a pizza/​pasta joint) either. I actually worked here for several summers, and still love the food and the family that owns the place.
The pizza is just really simple and delicious. The sauce is made in house, the meatballs are made in house, everything is made in house. Just straight forward good Italian food, made by a straight forward and super nice Greek family who care about what they do. It takes me hours to decide what I want everytime I go, because seriously just about everything is awesome and I can never decide which awesome thing I want for that particular meal.
I highly recommend ANY of their pizzas, especially the Middletown special which is your basic works pizza but more delicious. Pastas are fantastic and made to order. Meatballs are great as well. Salads are probably the only I wouldn’t recommend, as they’re made early in the day and saran-​wrapped. They still taste pretty crisp when you order them, but why order a simple salad when you could get an awesome pizza or hot sandwich? Pizzas range from 6 – 7 for smalls and then 10−13÷14 for large and specialty pizzas. Pastas are about 10 – 15 (large portions), and sandwiches are 4−7ish.
But if you like cheesesteaks, definitely get them here! I verrrry rarely eat red meat, but I get the cheesesteaks here made 3 out of every 5 visits. They’re like 3.75 for a «half» which is a ginormous 6 ish inch roll! And maybe 2 dollars extra for the whole size. The meat was always awesome, and just so delicious and melty in your mouthy.
Go here! Go all the time! Bring your friends, and try everything on the menu.*
*ps, I swear I have no current affiliation with the restaurant, the family, or the food. I just have a flair for the overly enthusiastic tone.