Mellow Mushroom

The Milledgeville location has closed…
Very good food, and flavorful!
Nice atmosphere and clean.
Servers are friendly and responsive.
A little bit pricy, but good quality. Not your typical pizza, so I recommend you try it. If you are a picky eater, ask questions first! Be sure you know what you are getting. :)

Best Pizza in Lake Country!
Do yourself a favor & eat here. It will CHANGE your life!

Food is good, but way overpriced. 1.50 for toppings (per topping)? Are you kidding me? Servers are friendly and helpful, but the prices are terrible.

Meh. It was overall okay. I may have not ordered the best thing, so I’m willing to give it another shot some other time I’m in Milledgeville.
I came up here with my nursing class and they were very accomodating to our group of 9. Wonderful service!
I ordered the Jerk Chicken hoagie and I wasn’t a fan. I forgot to ask for no mushrooms, so I picked them off after I had bitten into it and got a mouthful of rubberiness. The sandwich then fell apart on me, so I was having to eat some of it with a fork the best I could. The spinach got mushy and slimy since it was a hot sandwich; I guess I should have picked that off as well.
I tried a piece of pizza from my classmate who ordered the House Special without peppers and onions. The crust was tough in my opinion. You couldn’t cut it with a fork and knife, so I picked it up to eat it and the toppings all slid right off. I ended up eating the toppings with my fork and then taking bites of the bread in between.
Like I said, it may have been I just didn’t order the right thing, but it wasn’t the best pizza or hoagie I’ve ever had.
Hoagie: $ 6.50+ tax
Small Pizza (4 slices): $ 10.99+ tax

Absolutely love coming here during a UGA Bulldogs game! ½ price beer and ½ price apps! Got to love it!

Consistently good pizza. The crust is what really makes it — the parmesan cheese makes it almost like a breadstick. The ingredients and toppings are fresher than you’ll find at the big chain places. It’s easy for takeout and a good atmosphere in the restaurant too — with a nice draft beer selection. I wish it were a little cheaper, but it’s a good option to have.

Best pizza you’ll ever eat. Has to be one of the best restaurants in Milledgeville. About 20 beers on draft — cool atmosphere.