Legends Caterers

4 word review: Very very good sandwiches.
Unilocal doesn’t like short reviews and posts them as ‘tips’. With this added sentence it now qualifies as a review.

Customer service was great when inquiring about placing an order needed within 48 hours. All in one service including drinks, cold platters, hot dish options and desserts. Along with table service prep and paper goods. Great for the price and services.

Love Love Love Legends Caterers! Never been to the actual store. but I always get catered lunches from them during our busy season at work (tax season) for the past couple years. Atleast every other Saturday! I LLOOVVEEEEE the «Garden State» sandwich, I saw someone posted a picture of it above. soo good! Fiesta pasta salad is AMAZING. Their tuna is great. And everything else that we get catered, I haven’t tried, but it looks amazing. And all 30 ppl in my office always have great feedback!

If I could eat here everyday, I would. Being so close to my house, it’s tempting. I love it here. Charming little deli, right in the heart of Milltown. So clean and the ingredients are always fresh. There are a bunch of freshly prepared pasta and deli salads at the front counter that we usually order one of.
There are SO many sandwich choices, you’re head will spin. If you go hungry, be prepared to be tortured because if you’re like me, unable to decide, you’ll be there for a while. I usually get the Pacini, but on my last visit I had the Garden State. Served either hot or cold, I opted for cold. Also, changed the bread choice. Oh. My. Goodness. I don’t lie when I say, every time at lunch, I think of this sandwich. Honey turkey, corned beef, Swiss, creamy coleslaw and Russian dressing!!! Oh yeah!
We always go at lunch time and never have to wait for out food! Even when a few people are there as well.
The staff is really great! My only negative would be that it’s a little hot inside, even with the door open. Outdoor seating would be great, but I’m sure there’s some sort of zoning laws against that.
If you pass by, do yourself a favor and stop in! Or have your next event catered! Then invite me over :)

We decided to have Legends cater my Dad’s retirement party after I went to another party that was catered by Legends. From ordering, to set up and take down, it was superb service. They make a great variety of sandwiches with clear labels of each kind, the hot food was delicious and the salads and desserts were awesome! Everyone complimented us on the food.

Great sandwiches and friendly service. Limited seating (3 tables), but I’ve never had a problem finding a seat when I’m staying. Love their «Garden State» sandwich! The salads come with lots of meat and cheese, but the lettuce isn’t fresh and you can tell it comes straight from a bag. We’ve had them do some catering for our home parties and it’s always a hit.

It’s almost a shame that you need to eat the food after it has been so artfully crafted. Legends might not look like much from the outside. Even I thought so when I first moved to town but I had heard good things from x friend of mine and decided to give it a shot.
First of all, they use Board Head cold cuts… ‘Nuff said. If you know anything about cold cuts or the food business then you know this speaks for itself. They have a nice selection of fresh baked breads for your choosing even though the extensive and well explained sandwich menu suggests which goes best with your selection. The sandwiches are creative and unique and most importantly, they are SLAMMIN. The house brined pickles are a nice touch as well and the side salads are great too. My personal favorite is the Palermo (eggplant, artichoke hearts, spicy ham, sharp provolone, lettuce, and garlic mayo on a hard crust semolina roll). Can’t forget a side of the spinach pesto pasta salad as well. Oh, the fridge also has Manhattan Special which, if you don’t know, is the most delicious soda on the face if the earth. (Hand brewed espresso coffee soda). The prices are very fair also.
Lastly, they do off site catering. I have never had the chance to actually enjoy it but on 2 different occasions I have sent food to a friend for the passing of a relative and they had great things to say about it. The catering menu has pre– priced packages which include everything from beverages and entrees to plastic ware and desserts that are fresh baked and I have been told was excellent from start to finish.
I would give it a 5– Star but I guess nobody is perfect. There are only 2 tables in the whole place so there. A solid performance though!

On a recommendation of my wife’s friend, we had legends cater a lunch to our home. Granted my wife made the order, which they delivered on time and was reasonably priced, but I was not impressed, because the sandwiches were super small. The hot food was okay, but I have had better. I would prefer to order from an Italian pork store. Then at least I know what I am going to get.

I stopped in this sandwich shop for lunch after going to Target in town. They’re not much on dining in, as there are only two tables in the place, and it’s meant to be more of a catering business. But I will definitely come back even if I have to eat my sandwich in the Target parking lot.
Fresh bread and ingredients, delicious and interesting combinations on their menu… and assortments of Wise Deli kettle chips and Stewart’s bottled sodas makes this place rock. They have odd hours, so if you’re just stopping by for a bite, you may want to call them and see when they are open.

Worthy of the name! Good quality meats and cheeses, as well as excellent bread. The ‘named’ sandwiches on the menu offer good flavor combinations. Even my wife — who is just now starting to experience new foods — is clamoring for their ‘Harvest’ sandwich with it’s apricot mustard and 8-​grain bread.
I developed a favorite sandwich — prosciuttini, smoked turkey, cheddar, bermuda onions, tomatoes, lettuce, and chipolte mayo on soft italian bread. If you try it and like it please ask them to put it on the menu as the ‘Joe’ (they said if enough people like it they’d consider it *lol).
They offer a wide variety of components to appease any palette. The only disappointment I’ve come across is the jalepeno mayo… which is just that (meaning the jalepeno wasn’t pureed or transformed into a cohesive sauce) — a very minor blemish on an otherwise wonderful menu. Either way you go this place is a winner.

I had a great sandwich from this place. The semolina bread was amazing and so was the turkey.

So angry I didn’t find this place sooner. It’s now my favorite sandwich shop anywhere. Stop going to Quickcheck and Wawa you morons, go here.
The Sicilian sandwich is excellent.

Did a bunch of business with these folks over the past couple years. It was a bitter sweet relationship…
1. Sandwiches are FRESH and GOOD.
2. Not enough meat on sandwiches, a little skimpy and they know it.
3. Staff (one girl in particular) a little unfriendly and easily annoyed… bit of a ‘tude if you know what I mean… she has that ‘tude kind of look.
Overall, it’s a good place for food but if you want more than a sandwich (ie a catering order, you are going to have to beg, borrow and plead in order to get anything out of this people other than a few extra slices of meat on your sangwich)

Best Sandwich I have ever had!

Great little place for lunch. Limited seating only 3 tables, but perfect place to grab a quick sandwich. All of the sandwiches are made to order with fresh bread and ingredients. The Naples is one of my favorites. They also have delicious pasta salad and cookies.