The food is embarrassingly overpriced for the portions and quality. I understand that Gurneys is attempting a facelift to attract hip young wealthy guests and the façade is refreshing but the quality of the food at its eateries and room service are all the same and inedible. As guests of the hotel we tried every restaurant, breakfast, lunch and dinner and every time we had sub par food. The burgers were frozen and cooked poorly for $ 24, with no condiments. The lobster roll had frozen small portions of claw meat only served with potato chips for $ 22. Clam chowder was salty celery broth with no clams. The eggs were runny and the bacon was soggy. For the cost Gurneys needs to step it up. If you enjoy the hotel and spa which are and always have been great, eat elsewhere or pack your own food.
J D.
Rating des Ortes: 2 New York, NY
Barely edible lunch — omlet, crab cake, club sandwich. Very small portions. Very dissapointing especially since the cost for these mini servings was $ 17 — $ 22. Service was attentive and friendly.
Gourmet 2.
Rating des Ortes: 5 New York, NY
I use to come to Gurneys for a long time! everything is so beautiful, 4 restaurants in one place, so you can go in the morning to the beach with kids and have a delicious fish tacos, come for lunch in Tillies and have a delicious lobster roll and panzanella salad. At the night time you have the best italian restaurant in the Hamptons Scarpetta, and if you think is over wrong wrong wrong they also have the Regent which i had been in Miami and now is here also with amazing cocktails and music ! everything is perfect. Is a new world. well done
Luciana F.
Rating des Ortes: 3 New York, NY
Had dinner outside and ordered everything on their bar menu. The lobster roll is a must skip. The worst I had in Montauk. The burger was well prepared but nothing exciting. The avocado toast was big and the avocado creamy but needed a little more spice. We also order a chocolate cake though it looked beautiful it was just terrible. Overall I recommend the ambience and the burger with fries.
Nyla I.
Rating des Ortes: 5 New York, NY
I really enjoyed the breakfast buffet at Tillie’s! What a treat! For $ 20 they give you a beautiful spread of delicious pastries, yogurt, breads, fruit, oatmeal, potatoes, eggs, meat, waffles, as well as juice and coffee. Add the great service & beautiful ocean view, and you’re set! They even had free valet! I’m a fan!
Rory G.
Rating des Ortes: 5 The Roads, Miami, FL
Not sure how anyone gave this place a one star(although it’s very new so I guess not everyone is patient). I had a great meal here. I mean I started with a Siracha lobster roll. How bad could it have been? Burger was cooked to perfection and quite delicious. The raw clams were very tasty. The real winner: the oysters. I don’t remember exactly what the server said but basically then are hand picked and rotated daily out in the ocean… Whatever the process they do it works, so fresh and so very delicious. This property has a very proper american 3 meal restaurant, world class Italian(Scarpetta Beach) and a beach club with beach front barbecues. Montauk/Hamptons finally stepping their game up. See you soon!!!
Natalie W.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Montauk, NY
Absolutely not satisfied with the service. Ordered one dish but another was served. The waitress blamed on my friend’s accent… which is beyond rudeness…