Pizza Pizza

I never got my order– apparently it didn’t go through but i still got the confirmation email. Eat24 support member Linh was really helpful and gave me a coupon code for my next order. I’ll probably second guess ordering through Unilocal anymore– I may just go to them for reviews

Last night there was a little disagreement in my house. Doesn’t matter what it was about, but we had argued for so long that the dinner window had all but run out. We had cereal in the house but no milk, cold cuts but no bread. We were fast approaching another absolute meltdown (hangry is a problem in our home), when we found this menu sitting in a desk drawer. They had dropped them off weeks ago in the building, but we hadn’t tried it yet. The menu said they took delivery orders until ½ before closing (Midnight on Friday and Saturday), so we were good.
We ended up ordering through GrubHub. I was a bit gun shy about trying somewhere new after that disaster that was a visit to Grassy Sprain Diner (see that review if you are interested), but ordered we did. We ordered at 11:04 and GrubHub said the food would be here by 11:35 (I admit, I laughed about this, because that didn’t sound likely). At 11:35pm, exactly, the doorbell rang (star number one. very timely delivery). The delivery guy was super nice (star number two). The food was piping hot (star number three). Seriously, everything was so hot that I had to let the roll cool off for a minute before I could eat it. Finally, the food was good! (start number four).
We ordered fried ravioli (the significant other wanted these). I’ve never been a fan of fried ravioli, but I tried them and they were actually really tasty. We had boneless wings with mild sauce on them. They were tasty, well cooked and the blue cheese that came with them was amazing. The mild was pretty spicy (which I liked), but i’d be careful about ordering the hot. We also had garlic twists. These were average, run-​of-​the-​mill knots. The price on them was great (five for $ 2.75) and they were good, they just weren’t anything special. Finally we got a meatball and cheese pizza roll. When it came it wasn’t exactly a roll. It was more like a calzone that was split open (nothing wrong with THAT!). It was pretty good. Sauces were well packed, and the tomato sauce was hot and rather good.
I’m reserving one star until we order again (and we will be back). Consistency is what will make this a five-​star spot for us. If you are looking for someplace that delivers late, and shows up quick, you can’t go wrong here. We were pretty happy with it.

I’m embarrassed how many times I’ve called for delivery. When I call they say «you want the usual?». I discovered them not long after I saw their menu in my mailbox. It says they deliver rain, sleet, snow… so my first time was the test! I was home from work because of a snow storm. Pizza Pizza delivered and we’ve been ordering from them nearly every week for the last five years. I’ll take the usual!

The food is great, I’ve had the pizza and garlic knots. However, I have always done pick up at night and the guy running the register is completely rude and unwelcoming. I had ordered a thin crust cheese pie for pick up and when I was walking out, I felt like the box was a little heavy for a thin crust so I opened it and was correct, it was an original crust pizza. So I turned around and said I ordered a thin and this isn’t it and he looks at the order form I placed on seamless and then looked at the order he put in and realized he didn’t do his part. I didn’t get an apology or option for a new pizza, instead he said «this is as thin as its gonna get buddy» and I said I’ve ordered from you guys before and the thin crust has been thinner and he said «oh, it depends on who makes it, you need a new one». I said actually, no I don’t need a new thin crust if that’s the thinnest its going to be, I would rather have a refund and he rolls his eyes and said its only gonna be 10 minutes to make a new pie. And I said but if that’s the thinnest its gonna be, I would rather not. His coworker started speaking in Spanish saying how he was in the wrong bc he didn’t put thin crust and In Spanish, I said «I speak Spanish too so please be aware before you say anything regarding this situation». They both looked mortified. Waited for 15 minutes while he worked to give me my refund back through seamless. He needs to be replaced because it’s bringing the business morale down because while I waited for the refund, he treated other customers who were picking up or placing orders with the same attitude, he gave me.

Best pizza in Bronxville! They have the best prices & best tasting pizza in the area. I always get the mushroom pizza bc they use fresh mushrooms and lots of them. I wasn’t impressed with their boneless buffalo wings but if you stick with pizza you won’t be disappointed. I love their online ordering system as well, it’s convenient and it tells you exactly when your food is being delivered.

It’s ok, not the best. Their Philly Cheesesteak pizza is the WORST!!!

Great food! Delivery can take sorta long depending on what day/​time you order (Fridays and weekend usually takes longer) but food is always delivered nice and hot! Always delicious and fresh! We order from there at least once a week!

Ordered the ham hero, which came with about a pound of meat. That’s generous but hard to eat so I felt bad but had to throw a chunk of it out. They could save $ by cutting back on that qty. Bread was okay but not great. Philly cheesesteak came light on the most important ingredient– cheese! I think maybe they used provolone? Save $ by using less ham and invest that into cheese whiz! Mozz sticks were ok.

I love their Meatball Calzone, they deliver pretty quickly and the person who answers the phone is always friendly!

I have ordered pizza from here twice. Each time I was very disappointed. The second time especially. The second time I ordered I asked for garlic and tomato as toppings. When it arrived the box seemed to weigh 8 pounds! They literally poured minced garlic out of the jar onto the pizza. This then made the pizza cold and soggy. It was a waste of my money.
However on other occasions I have ordered hot sandwiches and sides (French fries, mozzarella sticks etc). And these were delicious. They should stick to these items and leave pizza alone.

My friend was right about the pizza. They are really good one of the better one’s that I have had locally. The spinach salad was nice. Loved the dressing

Pizza is on point. Cheapest prices in the area and fast delivery. They also have great coupons. Must check it out

Sauce is downright bitter. I prefer Johnny or Joes or Lincoln Lodge or Scalas.

Their pizza is terrible and the sauce tastes like chef boyardee. will not go back here EVER again. i’d rather order domino’s
Flames and Joe’s has great pizza

I’m a fan.
Tried Pizza Pizza agian and my pasta alfredo dish was perfect! Not oily and bland like the last time.
We also ordered the chicken gyro and the bite I had made me regret I had not chose that instead. Tender slices of grilled chicken breast, soft pita shell without an overwhelming amount of tziki sauce. Yummm.
I gave them 5 stars this time around because my homie is diabetic and ordered a diet pepsi, which arrived as a regular pepsi. After calling the store, they sent the delivery driver back and he was really sweet in making the trade saying something along the lines that «you’re our customer.» — totally saved the day.
Will definitely order again!

ehh…
Not good, not great but it does the job when you’re drinking and hungry.
Believe me.

Waited over an hour for a delivery that was supposed to take 30 minutes… called the store and asked them to have the delivery guy call me since I had to leave to go to an appt… no call… i’m walking out the door now.

Nothing stands out at this establishment its the typical westchester pizza shop. Chicken slice is pretty good along with their white slice. Prices aren’t bad at all unless you get their pasta entrees which are a ripoff. They have an amazing chicken cutlet Caesar salad. Fast delivery service which is a reason why i eat their food often.
They have 2 locations and their menu is listed here:

This pizza restaurant is located in Fleetwood a short distance from the train station. It is larger than most but still primarily a take out restaurant.
The pizza here is fairly standard and definitely better than most national chains but is lackluster compared with other local offerings. The crust is too thick and a little soggy. Both the cheese and the sauce were bland and tasted somewhat processed. This place is okay if you need something and don’t have time to go more than a block from the train but an extra couple blocks walk will get you much better pizza.

This past Saturday night, I ordered a Foccacia pie from «Pizza! Pizza!» and it was «ummmmm good»! It cost me $ 16.50 [Hence, the missing star]. Yeah, that is a grip, but on the menu that came with the delivery the price was listed as $ 18.50 …so I don’t know the «real» price. Anyway, the pizza was JUST baked (you could tell it was fresh) when it arrived. It was topped with minced garlic, FRESH, JUICY slices of tomatoes, FRESH, chopped basil (I’m obsessed with FRESHNESS)… and beneath all those layers of fresh goodness, was pesto (which I’ve never had on a Foccacia pizza before). Oh and I guess to make up for my recently empty wallet… they threw in some yummy garlic knots. Call them for some great food next time you have a movie night!
Oh yeah… there is a $ 1.00 delivery charge… so keep that in mind too.