Insomnia Cookies

Omg, a late night cookie store!!! Hell, yes! These should be in every college town or just every where! And they deliver?
The cookies were amazing and soft on the inside, nice crispness on the edges. Served warm and still even good the next day.
Peanut Butter was my favorite, but the double chocolate mint was right there after.

This place was highly recommended by the IU Ball ICU nurses, PT staff and MY nephew. So we knew we were getting some good stuff. We got a half dozen.
Meh.
Sure it was warm and gooey — but the white chocolate macadamia nut and snickerdoodle cookies were way, way underdone. Doughy, undercooked. The double chocolate chocolate fudge cookies were incredible! The mint chocolate chip were OK but couldn’t overcome the undercooked ones.
Probably won’t win a return visit for me. Save your money BSU peeps — buy your favorite Grandma’s or Subway cookie pack and nuke it for 12 seconds.

Buyer beware.
The cookies are great, don’t get me wrong.
But I always seem to have problems ordering, and they try to overcharge me for things that are minor because (I assume, based on the time I order) they assume I am drunk.
The first time, they took my order, and then called me to verify and asked a trivial question about upgrading my ice cream. I didn’t want to. Fine, I don’t care.
Tonight, they called me back to verify my order (placed online) and told me, «we have an order for brownies… and…walnuts? Or something? Do you still want it?»
I said yes.
They delivered my «Brownie a la mode» without the damned ice cream. Because they ran out. They didn’t call me to say they were out of ice cream. They called to say «do you still want your order?» Them charged me full price — of the order with ice cream — and delivered only a brownie. And the receipt stated a la mode.
It’s trivial.
It’s only $ 2.
But, they knew they had no ice cream. And they attempted to charge me for it anyhow. I spent 20 minutes on the phone trying to correct it, and the local store tried to claim they warned me, and that somehow I «chose» to pay for the ice cream, even though they didn’t have any. That’s a full on, illegal, scam. And most (drunk college kids) people won’t report it. Don’t let them get away with it.
I tried to file with Better Business Bureau, but the Muncie store is not listed.
This is shady practice, and if it is commonplace, it needs attention. So beware. If they seem like they’re trying to rip you off… they probably are. And let people know it’s happening.

I was in town for a tournament, and Insomnia was recommended by a local. The cookies were good (I shared a white chocolate macadamia and a double chocolate mint) and were served warm. I don’t know that they were particularly special, but still good nonetheless. However, we were served by an especially unfriendly male worker. This was probably the biggest turn off of our visit. I’m not one to be extremely talkative but this guy was very standoffish.