Kathryn’s Custom Cakes and Cups

Great tasting cake! Very moist!

I’m a photographer that has used Kathryn’s for the last few months at least 4 times per month to provide cakes and cupcake for my clients. The cakes look phenomenal and taste even better! I’ll admit I grab few bites of what’s left behind! Moist and yummy! I’ll be ordering all my personal items there too!

Best cookies in the world. She is very sweet and kind. Very clean. And 100% family owned!

Ughh what a disappointment… I so wanted to like it, Kathryn is such a nice lady that it pains me to write this review. However, I wanted to let other prospective customers read my honest review.
I went in to Kathryn’s Custom Cakes and Cups to try some cupcakes as I have just moved to the area, and needed a new place to buy cakes from. I wanted to order a birthday cake for a party next week, and decided to stop by to taste some flavors. I am SO happy that I did…
I found 3 things wrong with the 2 cupcakes I picked up today. (German Chocolate and Italian Crème)
1.) Price Point: $ 6 for 2 tiny cupcakes? The value was so not there. I would rather pay $ 3.75 for a Sprinkles Cupcake.
2.) Dryness: I don’t think the 2 cupcakes that I tried could’ve been any drier. They were probably made at least 3 days ago maybe more.
3.) Taste: The lack of flavor was shocking. I think I could’ve whipped up some box cake mix with store bought icing and they would’ve tasted better. So, even if the cupcakes would’ve been moist, the flavor was still lacking.
Kathryn’s Custom Cakes and Cups has so much potential, but the flavors/​freshness are not there. I wish her the best of luck, and maybe by seeing this review it will help her to reevaluate her bakery!

Amazing! This was one of the most moist cakes I’ve ever had! It was beautiful and delicious! So many compliments. Definitely recommend.

We stopped in for cupcakes — I got white on white, my husband bought a carrot cake. Kathryn suggested we not eat them immediately, but let them come to room temperature. There’s a science to that folks… something about the butter hardening and squeezing out the air trapped in the cake, making it seem dry. Anyway, I don’t think we waited long enough. We so love the idea of a person (Kathryn) so loving to bake that she opens a one-​person business to do just that, that we’ll be back to give it another shot!

We ordered a cake with only 48 hours notice and it turned out fantastic.
The cake was reasonably priced and looked adorable. Everyone said it was great! And I am guessing that’s how I missed out on getting to trying. I did get a bite of icing. It was really good. Not he beat u have ever had but very good.
I will definitely order again. Next time I will make sure I get a piece!

I was so excited to see this bakery had good reviews because it’s right next to my house but I was very disappointed. This place was good but I’ve had better. The lemon cookies are AMAZING however, the cupcakes and other cookies I got were not so great. They didn’t taste fresh at all and the icing on the cupcakes could’ve been a lot better. The cupcake it self was very bland and dry. I did go at the end of the day so maybe that was the reason but I doubt I will be back. I would rather spend my money somewhere else like Nothing Budnt Cakes. Moist cake and delicious frosting!

Kathryn is a very nice, patient, caring & understanding woman! I stumbled across her place & very glad I did! She was great to work with to design a cake for my daughters surprise 21^st birthday party! The cake was looked fantastic & tasted amazing!!! I will highly recommend her to everyone!

Kathy makes the best cookies around! Soooo good.