Petrellis

You gotta try half pepperoni/​half sausage/​extra cheese… Damn, had my toes curled up like elf shoes… Best pizza in murrieta…

Petrellis is NOW CLOSED… too bad!

This place rocks!!! Love their pizza, it’s is amazingly good!!!

Awesome pizza! We have tried all sorts of places in Temecula and Murrieta and this is the best! Worth driving to pick it up (since they don’t deliver).

Here is my unique experience with Petrelli’s. The first time I heard of this place I thought «Hey, with a name like that, they have to make a good pizza pie.» So I called and asked if they were the best. Of course they said they were, boasting they were the only «real Italian» pizza place in town. So I asked him to order me two of their best pies. It ended up being the pepperoni and sausage and the other a deluxe style with everything on it.
The pizzas were disappointing, just ok. The crust was god awful but the fresh motz and homemade sausage on top makes up for it a little. But the crust really had absolutely no flavor and was dry as a bone. Big deterrent for me when it comes to pizza.
Also no delivery. When I called in my order, I eventually had to speak with the manager/​owner to get it done. Weird.
Probably won’t try this place again unless I hear that they fixed that crust. Bleh!

This place is take out only. I ordered a medium 16“pizza.Pepperoni, Sausage.
The quality of the toppings is Amazing. They make their own sausage. Very good flavor. The cheese is the high end type, not the cheap stuff like most places. The pepperonis are the exact kind I like. The little ones that crinkle and burn just a little on the edges. Very hard to find. The sauce was very flavorful. Not overpowered by garlic or other spices. The dough was quite flavorful and nicely browned on the bottom. I have tried pretty much every pizza in Murrieta and Temecula and this is probably the best yet. A little pricey at $ 18.95, but hopefully they’ll get up to speed and start running some specials and coupons. Regardless, I think I found a new favorite. Can’t wait till they open the dinning area in 2 weeks.

Bomb Ass Pizza! Best local pizza joint around. They don’t deliver which sucks but hey, they’re a small time operation. Super filling! I can easily crush a medium pie from Pizza Hut… a large if I want to. There’s no freaking way I could eat a medium from this place. Petrelli’s is now my go-​to pizza joint. Boo-​yah! You guys are awesome.

What pizza place does not deliver?! Booooo!

Best pizza in town! Delicious dough, flavorful sauce and an over abundance of toppings (I’ve actually asked for «light» toppings because they are so generous with them.) The size of the pizza compared with the price is just amazing. I made the mistake of ordering a «large» the first time and was overwhelmed with the amount of pizza I ended up with. Now I know to order a smaller size, although I always order enough for leftovers the next day. I highly recommend this pizza over the ordinary generic pizza you might have delivered to your house. Spend the extra 10 minutes it might take to drive there and you will be glad you did. Also, encourage them to start delivering. If they delivered they would be the best pizza place on the planet!

Ordered over the phone. The guy taking my order seemed a little lost but finally got the order taken. 2 medium pizzas (1 cheese only, 1 pepperoni & sausage). Total was $ 26.50. Their medium is the size of most larges. The place is small. No place to eat inside, so it looks to be takeout or delivery only. On to the pizza review. Good toppings with good coverage. The problem was the crust — It was hard to chew and lacked any real flavor. In my book, the crust makes or breaks the pizza — and this broke it! It’s not that the overall pizza was terrible it was just OK. For the price I have had way better. If they cannot perfect a better crust I don’t expect them to last very long. There are just to many competitors with better pizza at a better price.

This place is take out only.
I ordered a medium 16″ pizza. Pepperoni, Sausage, extra sauce.
The quality of the toppings is A+. They make their own sausage. Very good flavor. The cheese is the high end type, not the cheap stuff like most places. The pepperonis are the exact kind I like. The little ones that crinkle and burn just a little on the edges. Very hard to find. The sauce was very flavorful. Not overpowered by garlic or other spices. The dough was quite flavorful and nicely browned on the bottom. I have tried pretty much every pizza in Murrieta and Temecula and this is probably the best yet. Only negative is I wish they had a dining area. They are just starting up, so I’ll cut them some slack on the menu selection and lack of choices displayed. A little pricey at $ 18.95, but hopefully they’ll get up to speed and start running some specials and coupons. Regardless, I think I found a new favorite. Hope they make it.

The Pizza dough is great. I had the Vegatale and it was loaded with tons of good veggies.(maybe a few too many olives). Nice people, they offered a free soda while I was waiting.

Toppings are good. Dough is tasteless. Whoever is answering the phone for orders is a moron. No menu on the wall, then they don’t offer you a paper one so you and the cashier just end up staring at one another until you ask if you can order a pizza. Walk two doors down and try the neighborhood market.