Bagel Boys of Nanuet

Salmon salad is excellent as is the whitefish salad. Bagels are good versus others in the area generally. Service is spotty and can be anything from good to atrocious based on which clerk you deal with when. Coffee is weak and not worth the pretty pricey brew. Not a regular stop for me.

A visited this store for the first time which happened to be on a Monday morning. Terrible way to start a work week. How difficult is it in retail to say «hello, can I help you»? Instead I got… Next and a head nod. What do you want? As I give my order I notice that he doesn’t write it down but tries to remember it while looking around behind me. Of course he then asks me to repeat my order which I do even slower so it might sink in this time. Both times asking for my sandwich to be on a toasted «buttered» bagel. Still no communication… no smile… just an unhappy employee spreading his attitude to everyone starting their day.
As I watch him prepare my sandwich, knowing he still might not have remembered my order I watch him place everything on the bagel WITHOUT the butter.
«SIR! Can you please butter the bagel like I asked?»
With an angry sneer he looks back at me and says «if you want butter that costs 25 cents more!
«Why didn’t you tell me that when I placed my order… two times?»
I have never been to any bagel shop that charges for butter! You got to be kidding me!
He then puts the sandwich in a bag and hands it to me. YUP! You guessed it! NO THANK YOU.
I normally stop at John’s Famous bagels in New City just a mile or so away. Always greeted with a friendly welcome. Any egg sandwich ordered gets TWO eggs no extra charge. And best of all the BUTTER IS FREE!
If you want to keep a happy attitude on your way to work… avoid this place.

This place sucks now. Never going back. They screw every order up and the bagels are horrible.

The bagels taste good but the hole is way too big. I guess this is the way they save money. Lot of hole but not much bagel.

What is wrong with these people? The bagels are inconsistent … sometimes they are very good, but other times they are lousy. The scallion cream cheese is to die for, but five dollars for a lox spread? And sometimes they are just plain rude. I don’t understand what is up with this. They sometimes are very busy, but that’s no excuse for treating me like crap.
Do yourself a favor, and go to Zimi’s instead.

This place is pricey for sure, but when you are catching the early morning express to hitch a ride to the city, this place gets it right. I’m surprised at a lot of the previous reviews (damn 1 star is harsh!). The staff was nice to me & they never charged me a different price when I ordered the same thing and they have adequate drink selection aka my Starbucks Mocha in a glass bottle and then some. I can’t comment on the lines because I usually come in before 7am and people are still hitting snooze when it’s that early.

I would give it more stars however just got two large black coffees for $ 4.69? Dunkin is cheaper than this.

Bad service matched by bad bagels

Bagels are crap-​staff is really rude. I’ll never go back there. Still think that Nyack Hot Bagels are best around.

Freakin horrible– usually long lines in the morning and a lengthy service time. The bagels are dreadful and tasteless. There have been times when you go in and there is no smell of breakfast?
Why? Because they keep piles of bacon already cooked probabably from day before leftovers they simply just reheat.
You get a general feeling its family run and that family is not all that interested in you or your business– very unfriendly.
Have felt same scam of being charged different prices for same thing.
They get those register fingers working and next thing you are paying more for same and looks like they sometimes hesitate and make prices up as they go.
No thanks this place has been history for awhile.
You want great bagels its ZIMIS in Nanuet or Pearl River or Bagel Bin in SV.
They seem to get business simply because of congested traffic location and nearby businesses.

The food isn’t bad, it is just priced inconsistently. This is the result of poor management and I would recommend going somewhere else in the area that doesn’t suffer from this. It is just annoying as a customer to not only be overcharged, but to be charged differently for the same item on a different day. Management just doesn’t seem to care, which is why a customer like me would go out of my way to share this with other Unilocalers. Just be cautious of this. If you absolutely have to go there or if you find yourself there, you won’t necessarily be disappointed in the taste. So it’s up to you.