Maggie Moo’s

I went there on a Thursday to get a root beer float. Very good recommend to people that are not on a diet. And I am not on a diet so I’m good.

Maggie Moo’s has OK ice cream at an OK price, but if you’re already in Nashville you should just make your way over to Jeni’s Ice cream or Hot and Cold (who serve Jeni’s flavors) instead. I find that they have more inventive and delicious flavors, a richer taste and a much better consistency for equal the price to Maggie Moo’s. And if you do happen to take my advice, I highly recommend the Brown Butter Almond Brittle ice cream, cannot go wrong!!!

I love Maggie Moo’s! It’s so difficult to find peanut butter icecream I like. If you go to grocery stores, they have ice cream with peanut butter cups crushed into them but I like the smooth kind that tastes like icecream mixed with smooth peanut butter. I love that Maggie Moo’s icecreams aren’t super sweet so if I don’t feel like something too sweet but something smooth in texture, cold and soothing for my throat, I know I can count on them. BUT I can add mix-​ins if I wanted more sweetness. They serve milkshakes, banana splits, cold marble mix-​ins, sell by pints, waffle cones and have many enjoyable options. Bonus that I live less than half a mile from here.

This was actually a really cute find on my recent trip to Nashville. We grabbed lunch next door and we’re heading out to the airport when my friend noticed that there was ice cream in a very cool looking store front.
While it took a while for someone to come up front to take our orders, we were met with friendly service.
I settled on the Sweet Cream with Reese’s and my friend got the chocolate ice cream.
It is a bit overpriced but seems to be competing with Coldstone so I barely noticed that I spent 10 entire dollars on 2 scoops of ice cream.

You’ve gotta love the handmade ice cream of Maggie Moos — specifically the butter pecan… woah! The ice cream is sweet and smooth making it a great option for all your sweet tooth needs. The saving grace of MMs is being able to «stuff the scoop» with unlimited toppings. Granted, I didn’t try to test the limits on those, but you DEFINITELY should. A little pricey, but MMs is worth the trip.

I love coming here! The ice cream is wonderful. I think it’s even better than Jenis. The unlimited mix-​ins are great! I’m not sure of any other ice cream shop where you can do this. What really keeps me coming back is the top notch customer service I always get from a man who works there. I’m not sure of his name, but I believe he is a manager. He is always smiling, and it’s obvious he genuinely enjoys his job. He even has my order memorized and does a great job with the mix-​ins each time. He is efficient yet is still able to show each customer that he cares. I would highly recommend this particular Maggie Moos!

Great ice cream, terrible customer service. I have been there several times, and the staff there is routinely slow and unprofessional. If not for that, it would be a great place to go.

Worst customer service. We’ve been here multiple times and have never been treated nicely. We went to grab ice cream tonight and stood in the lobby for five minutes while multiple people were sitting there eating ice cream. No one helped us. I went around to the front and could see the employees just standing in the back. This place has cameras so I’m sure they could see us standing there; still no one helped us. This place could care less about their customers; if they did, they would do a better job at training their employees and teaching them about customer service. This place will not be getting any of our business anymore.

I dont know why ppl talk so much about Jeni’s icecream. I like this place so much better! I am not a big fan of icecream w crazy mixes. No licorish sage butternut caramel icecream for me. Nothing like the good old plain strawberry. And hmm mixed w brownies and reeses cups. Im a fan!

Maggie Moo’s is a great place to stop for ice cream. It has great flavor mixes and the ice cream itself is very rich and creamy. It was $ 9 for 2 people for the medium size. If you are on vacation and looking for a classic nashville ice cream shop this is not it, but if you are looking for good tasting ice cream this is the place for you. It is very similar to cold stone creamery.

I have always loved Maggie Moos, but bc of the frozen yogurt craze, I haven’t been back until recently… and it made me wonder why did I not come here instead?!
The ice cream here is made fresh daily and the small is HUGE… you get sooo much ice cream! I loved the peanut butter flavor… I mixed it with dark chocolate and topped with a brownie! yum~
Also, their ice cream cakes are fantastic, got one for my dad’s birthday this year and everybody was fighting over the last piece! We got the turtle flavor, it was dynamite!

Great ice cream. The quality is always the same — superb.
I just don’t enjoy the new «points» program. Guess I’m old school and enjoyed the punch card system better.

Maggie Moos is sinful. Seriously. How many decadent flavors of ice cream is it really legal to have? And all those yummy toppings too? I love the whole mixing-​ice-​cream-​on-​cold-​slabs thingy places have started doing. Its nice not having melty ice cream from the start. I am personally very fond of their cakes as well, and they have kept many a birthday folk happy in my life for years now. While this location is small, and is very crowded on the weekends with its proximity to Vanderbilt, it’s still nice to come here with a sweet tooth and taste the various flavors that interest you in the quest to find that perfect combo to satisfy your craving. The staff are always really helpful and have great recommendations. You’ll pay a little bit more than say a dairy queen but it will be worth it. And with its closeness to Centennial Park, I would recommend a picnic with ice cream on nice days. The cake batter ice cream is my personal favorite and I would recommend it to anyone guilty of making a cake or cookies at home and eating half the batter instead.

I somehow made it through my childhood, teen and college years without having tried this type of mix-​in ice cream on a cold slab situation, so I don’t have much to compare it to when I say MAGGIEMOO’S IS REALLY FREAKING GOOD. It is also just a few blocks from my apartment, but it always trumps the equally close DQ when I have cravings.
The employees are really patient when you need to try a few flavors to make sure you make the right decision, and they also make very delicious suggestions.
My only complaint is that I wish they were open later. Sometimes you just need ice cream + Netflix to end a long day.

So my fiancé and I had some vouchers for a BOGO ice cream from Maggie Moo’s. It is sad that this place is shrinking as much as they are, as they are really good. In fact I dare say they are second only to Sweet CeCe’s, which only has them beat on concept, and tied with Ben and Jerry’s. But the quality of the product is extremely good.
I had two of my favorites, cake batter with cookie dough and it was amazing. Plenty of cooking dough chunks mixed in along with crushed oreo cookies into cake batter ice cream… so good that it made me feel like a kid again.
I wish they would expand back out though as they have been shutting down a lot of locations recently. :(

I got a small dark chocolate. It had two large scoops of ice cream, which I came nowhere close to finishing, but it was really tasty! Next time I need an ice cream fix, I’m coming here! And I’m probably going to try the strawberry ice cream since I can imagine MaggiMoo’s being really good.

I was only there one time. I had a peanut butter and chocolate shake. I loved it! I would go back for sure.

Okay, to be fair, I was pretty cross with my previous review. I guess I was needy and it made me write a crappy review for MaggieMoo’s when they are out of all the things I wanted.
Since then I’ve been back several times and it hasn’t generated as much frustration. They still don’t have Nilla Wafers (as a chain they don’t have them) but the Waffle Bowl problem has not reoccurred.
If you are looking for Ice Cream Treatery, you’ll do just fine at «The Moo» (nobody calls it that, I just made that up)

Super rich ice cream — especially the strawberry and the new root beer ice cream

Maggie Moo’s has always been good to us students for a nightly ice cream run, especially before the boom of fro-​yo places. A big cup of creamy ice cream with tons of mix-​ins is sometimes what you need over a frozen yogurt, although Maggie also has smoothies and fro-​yo now, too. I love the colorful menu with the examples of ice-​cream/​mix-​in combinations. They always let you taste-​test the flavors, and the workers are generous with their portions and do their job well. The entertainment book always has good coupons for Maggie Moo’s. Great parking, good number of chairs and tables, brightly lit, and open when we need ice cream– all good things. While I’m more of a fro-​yo fan, I do like Maggie Moo’s when I’m craving more sugar!