Angelo’s Pizza

Excelente atención, fueron muy amables, la pizza estuvo divina, ingredientes frescos y deliciosos. El lugar es muy ameno, excelente música y súper limpio. 100% recomendado…

One of the things that was a must for my husband and I to do while in New York was to have a genuine New York pizza. Did we find it! We came upon Angelo’s while exploring the city on New Year’s Eve. Located right next to the Late Show studio, this is a place that you need to check out.
The restaurant has 2 levels. We were seated on the upper level. We timed things right and beat the dinner rush, and were seated right away. Our server was very nice. Happy Hour was still happening while we were there, so we were able to take advantage of the drink specials. In addition to pizza, the menu has several entrees and pasta dishes to choose from, as well as soup, salads, and appetizers.
Now, for the pizza. In New York, they do it the thin crust way. At Angelo’s, you have a choice of two sizes: 13 inch or 17 inch. You can have it made with the traditional sauce, or you can get what they call a «White Pie», which is made with ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. There is a charge for each topping that you have added to your pizza. The pizza here is absolutely worth it, though, so we didn’t mind. This was the best thin crust pizza I’ve ever had. New York knows how to do thin crust pizza!
The next time we are in New York, we will definitely return to Angelo’s.

What a wonderful experience! Went before Broadway on a weekday night. My wife and I ordered a 13″ pizza to split and told the waitress we had to make a show. The pizza was out before we knew it, and it was FANTASTIC. Service was prompt and courteous. Our waters were always full, and we were in and out in about 30 minutes. And the price was a pleasant surprise as well. I will definitely come back.

Really great place. With the best lasagna on earth and really really good pizza. The only reason I give this place 4 stars is because the bread that they bring out is really dry. I came here twice in three days and the bread tastes like it’s still the same from last time I was here and didn’t eat it.

Pizza was very good and quite a kid friendly place. It was Sunday night around 5PM and it was packed… Just didn’t expect to pay $ 20 for small cheese pizza lol :)

Pizza was some of the best I ever had here on the east coAst! We ordered a family size Caesar salad, which was simple and tasty. Only reason I gave it a 4 instead of 5 is because the pasta was cooked a bit too long, pasta was not al dente and more soggy, but white wine sauce was great.

We stumbled upon this place years ago when we came to NY during Christmas the first time. We remembered enjoying ourselves and returned for nostalgic reasons.
The pizza is delicious… and we are pizza connoisseurs. It is thin, crispy and delicious. It’s not greasy at all. They use fresh mozzarella and fresh basil which essentially makes their plain cheese pizza a margherita pizza (even though that’s not how it reads on the menu) which we would never complain about! Yum!
We ordered a caprese salad which was also fresh and delicious however, it came after we were already eating our pizza which we found to be disappointing. The tomatoes were flavorless because they aren’t in season but the roasted peppers and pesto were yummy. You get nice, large and juicy pieces of buffalo mozzarella!
You receive complimentary bread while you’re waiting which is crunchy and delicious. There is oil, red pepper, etc. on the table for you to create your own bread dipping oil.
The server was blah but I wouldn’t say anything negative about her, either. She was just kind of there. There were plenty of other people also bringing food, offering refills, clearing plates, etc. so it was as if she was just another one of the many people stopping by our table.
They have Pepsi products which I hate but they did have my second choice which would be a sparkling Pellegrino so that made it better.
The place was decorated for Christmas. It’s cozy and warm but not hot. We very much enjoy coming here and will definitely return again the next time we are in NY.

Had great experience with Angelos pizzeria right after the show with Steven Colbert, while waited in line an finished the show. We were so hungry. They have this coal oven which makes pizza have this special smokey taste to them. Price is definitely right for being right on time square. Will definitely come again. Great service and friendly staff.

Pizza is good. All the low rated people are from people who are from South Carolina and Wyoming who eat Ellio’s pizza and think its good.
Service is great. I did suggest they get Mexican Coke.

had their white pie recently and i loved it! cooked to perfection!

I have eaten here a few times. Big draw is that david letterman featured this place as it is right next to where his show was. The seating is upstairs and the service was good. Typical Italian fare at reasonable price for the area.

Ever since we saw David Letterman order the entire audience pizza from here one time, we knew we’d try it if we ever made it to the city. When we found ourselves in the area, we made a beeline and we’re so glad we did!
We’re more deep dish people but wow, this was delicious! A nice zesty sauce, a hint of ricotta, pepperoni with nice flavor and the crust had a slight snap without being cracker crispy. The staff was very nice and price was what we expected to pay. We’ll be back for sure!

Boooo this place stinks. The service was odd and food was mundane. The pizza got cold so the mozzarella was like rubber. The photos look better then the food taste.

This was close to my hotel and I walked by and had to try it and my god, it was the best decision I had EVER made. The pizza sauce they use is perfect and has a little bit of a sweet taste to it. I ordered the 20 inch pizza with my sister and we murdered it! It was absolutely the best pizza we’ve ever ate. It’s not the pizza where it’s greasy and you feel disgusting after eating it. I got the cheese and basil. Next time I’m in town I will definitely be coming here again.

Called regarding how early they’ve noticed the line form for The Late Show with Stephen Colbert (around 2pm) and they were VERY helpful and friendly!
Saved me a lot of trouble and wasted time.
Can’t wait to try their pizza, too!

Verify descent Italian restaurant in mid town.
Good and affordable food, lots of place every time we went, and quiet for discussing with your colleagues.
They also deliver for your business working lunch at the office.
Not recommended to impress your dates or friends though :-)

Hidden gem! Well, I guess not so hidden since it’s right next to the old David Letterman studio; now Stephen Colbert, but I’m so surprised this place doesn’t get more attention for their pizza.
What we ordered:
Pepperoni pizza — delicious! Thin crispy crust, had that classic pulled melted mozzarella cheese while taking a slice, great proportion of pepperoni per slice ratio, great flavor!
Beets salad — very good, however get the dressing on the side since they overdo it a bit
Spaghetti with sausage and peppers — tasty, however not as stand out as the pizza.
Came here for lunch and we were seated right away with great attentive service. Great spot for lunch in the middle of touristy Times Square!

I’ve come here a couple of times for a few goodbye lunches for co-​workers. It’s never too busy during lunch but I’m sure nighttime would be bustling with tourists.
The first time I ordered their pasta with vodka sauce (I say pasta because I think they used penne back then. Now it’s rigatoni), I remember it being really good. It came with bacon bits and to be honest, I don’t know if there ever was a time that I had food with bacon bits in it and didn’t like it. So that was a nice twist to a classic.
This time, it tasted like it was already premade and they microwaved it. The pasta was kind of mushy and flat, and the oil was separated from the rest of the sauce and sitting in a pool at the bottom of the plate. It was also a little too creamy.
I settled on three stars since I did like it the first time. Just not the second time. So I guess the third time will have to be the tiebreaker. Next time, I think I’ll stick to a panini. You can’t go wrong with a sammie (I would hope)!

Food still excellent! The grilled chicken breast side is outstanding in taste & portion size to compliment any salad. The Rigatoni Campagniola is delicious and the bread is great. Still 5 Stars for the food.
The service not so perfect. The Hostess didn’t understand much English (only the basic «how many?», «hello», «goodbye», & «thank you», which I find odd. The waiter, though nice was too busy with his tables upstairs to not only ask the traditional Is everything okay/​How is everything question but he wasn’t even by our table until he brought us the check. This visit 3 Stars for the service.
I’d still be back for the exquisite food!

Short review based on the one slice of White pizza I tried from Angelo’s.
My cousin brought back 2 pies on foot. Even though the pizza wasn’t the hottest, the one slice I had was great. The use of ricotta cheese in addition to mozzarella added much appreciated flavor and texture to the pizza.
It’s $ 15 for a small pie, $ 17 for a large pie and $ 2.50 for each additional topping. In a city full of great pizza, I believe Angelo’s easily holds its own. I would definitely order another pie from Angelo’s.

Literally next door to David Letterman is this Italian restaurant. I’m sure the other food is good, but I came here specifically for the pizza!
We arrived at 2:00 and was seated promptly. At first the girl wanted to seat us by the door (WTH!?) but I asked to be moved upstairs and there were PLENTY of seats. Fortunately for us, the table was near a wall, and I sponged off their power outlet to recharge my phone.
In California, we can’t use coal to cook our pizza. But, when I come to NYC, a must eat for me is the NYC pizza, and Angelo’s has never disappointed me. I’m not sure if the other Angelo’s are related (their menus sure seem alike) but I normally go to the one off Avenue of the Americas. Just like the other location, service is just so-​so, so you have to bring your patience when eating here.
We ordered a large Margherita and a small pepperoni/​sausage pizza for my parents. The 2 pies filled all 4 of us, and we left happy.
I’m giving this place 4 stars, because of the slow service. Oh, and its a Pepsi place, which I was not happy with… but what do you do?