Insomnia Cookies

Bomb cookies at all hours of the night. This is my favorite spot in NYC for a simple sweet, a cookie. The staff here were friendlier than the other locations that I have frequented. My favorite are the double chocolate mint chip. My recommendation is to ask which cookies are be freshest & just order those!

The cookies are very much of the Mrs. Field’s type quality, but hot fresh cookies until 3am, either in store or delivered?
Insomnia is a God Send for drunks staggering out of the bar or compulsive eaters with a vicious sweet tooth like myself.
All Hail Queen Diabetes.

Great cookies, extremely incompetent service. I ordered a Valentines Day cookie cake for my girlfriend with the saying «Happy Valentines Day». The cake arrived without any saying and it was hard as a rock. Thank you Insomnia Cookies for ruining my surprise.

Pretty damn good cookies! The double chocolate chip and snickerdoodle are so good. For 1.60 each great price and they open late.

Wow. Warm& freshly baked cookies until 3am! The deluxe smores& double chocolate mint r my fave!

The absolute worst customer service and the person answering the phone seemed like he could care less. We placed a huge order and this is the last time I’m ordering from this place. To top it off the guy who answered said, «next time order from us directly». You are not preparing a five course meal, it’s milk and cookies, you are 2 hours late and less then a mile away. If this is how you treat your customers you should close this business.

The cookies are great, at all the locations. Good job cookies.
Got off my bar job late at night and it’d already started snowing. Stopped by there on the way to the L for post work, trudging-​through-​a-​blizzard sugar. The guy at the register, big dude with dreads, kept bellowing over and over, «I just wish all these F*CKING PEOPLE would get out of my F*CKING STORE so I could go home! All of you should just GO HOME!» Over and over: yelling it, seriously, in this tiny little store. There were four or five of us in there. It had to be at least an hour or two before stated closing time so it’s not like we were pushing his time limit back.
Just… seriously. So unprofessional. Don’t worry dude, I’m not going back there.
FYI, this is my second poor experience at an Insomnia Cookies after, at the LES location, some guys were blocking the door while another dude tried to hit on me from the kitchen, soooo…
I get that it’s a shop aimed at college students, but maybe you need some adult managers at these places, guys.

Tough decision, settled on 3 stars for their amazing service and quick delivery… and although the cookies arrived on the warm side, not all the cookies were fresh.
Ordered 6 cookies late at night (they’re open till 3am!!!) and pretty much picked one of each they offered. The chocolate chip and double chocolate chip were good, seemed fresh and soft. Unfortunately, the peanut butter, snickerdoodle and others in the box were not fresh. The snickerdoodle cookie was kind of dry and hard so threw it out. The peanut butter wasn’t good just okay.
Like i mentioned above, fantastic service, speedy delivery, pretty cool hours of operation but cookies were not that great.

Seriously so good! Insomnia cookies are best known for being all sorts of chewy and delicious and i was not disappointed when I got a desserts craving right after dinner. I got a traditional choco chip while my friend had a deluxe cookie and we both were super satisfied. It might be a lil pricey ~ 1.75 for one but worth the splurge!

Fresh baked cookies in the middle of the night? Tell me more!
This was a great place for just picking up some treats while jetlagged and needing a fix.
The guys inside were all chilling out and waiting for orders to come in as they deliver to a wide area, and fulfilled my order in quick time and adding an extra for good measure.
They were soft and moist, sugary and buttery and exactly what I needed. Thanks guys!

Good cookies served warm, but you can taste just how much butter they use in their cookies to keep them soft. They’re actually way too sweet and rich for me. Also pretty overpriced at near $ 2 for a normal and over $ 3 for a deluxe cookie.
Still convenient that they’ll deliver them to your drunk self at 2am.

Well I know a little something about insomnia, it happens to me more than I like too admit. But insomnia with cookies hmmmmm now thats a twist. Plus its not too hard to decide either going to Insomnia or hitting up Liquiteria which is right across the street.
Insomnia won on this evening with a box of 6 cookies for $ 9.00 which isnt bad. I ordered 2 of each chocolate chip, double chocolate chip and peanut butter. Yes they were good in all actuality. They helped me to fall asleep which is a super plus.
Service was ok on this rainy night, some hot cookies made it even more cozy.

Sweet cookies o’mine Remix — Guns N’ Roses
She’s got a smell it seems to me
Reminds me of childhood memories
Where everything
Was as fresh as the bright blue sky
Now and then when I see her face
She takes me away to that special place
And if I had to share
I’d probably break down and cry
Oh, oh, oh
Sweet cookies of mine
Oh, oh, oh, oh
Sweet cookies of mine

You do not even need to go into this store to smell the magical aromas that are sneaking out the front door. This place is so small but so big in taste and oh those smells of chocolate chips and oatmeals and oh my oh my! Cookies of course.
I cant tell you how many times we have seen this place and not walked in, but finally it was a walk in and let me tell you its awesomeness at its peak.
This is really no place to loiter since its super small. How they crank out these cookies in this small place is unknown, but who cares, they make it happen. The cookies are fresh and good and moist melt in your mouth bits of yumminess.
Yes its a little pricey, but its Manhattan. its suppose to be pricey. Can you imagine the rent for this place. Its probably like a bazillion dollars. I could not live above this place. I am sure I would be down every night getting some hot deliciousness. Anyway, I regress… If your near one of these stores stop by… you wont regret it.

Parking in NYC is a pain, but I found a spot right in front of Insomnia Cookies so I took it as a sign from the powers above that I must try this place! We went with the dozen assorted (chocolate chunk, double chocolate, m&ms, peanut butter, oatmeal raisins, etc). Warm ooey chocolate gooey yummy cookies!
Of course, we weren’t able to eat all of the cookies right away, especially since it was 2AM. I munched on the cookies throughout the weekend. They stayed soft and chewy the entire time!
They also sell milk. This is a small cookie shop. No place to sit. Just order and go. Great place to satisfy your sweet tooth!

If you’re craving a warm gooey chocolate chip cookie, Insomnia Cookie won’t disappoint!
I’m always skeptical when purchasing cookies because they typically lack the homemade taste that I hope for. To my delight, Insomnia Cookie was fresh and tasted like they came straight out of my oven at home.
My boyfriend and I walked in during prime bar time on a Friday night and were worried that we’d have to wait in a ridiculous line of drunks. The service was super fast, and we were out in just about 2 minutes.

Must have!
Be aware… You may not be able to stop eating those cookies!!!
They are still warm when you buy them. So, they melt in your mouth. Soft in the inside, Crunchy on the outside… Perfect combination of a delicious cookie…
Mmmmmmmm

Tiny little cookie shop that’s open late to serve your warm cookie needs. My favorite is the double chocolate mint which is killer when warm. Milk is behind the counter and you may get a secondhand high from both the sugar and the patronage.
Enjoy! They deliver late night also. Cookie delivery: Don’t you love this city?

Went into this TINY store in the middle of a long day of walking for a little sugar-​rush and I left very satisfied. We spent about three minutes in the shop chatting with the person behind the counter. She was perfectly pleasant and not in a rush to get us out the door like I would have expected from a place this small.
I got a cookie. I forget if it was a peanut butter or plain cookie. All I know is it had a peanut btter cup in it and it was to die for.
It was a little underbaked. I want to point how how much of a GOOD THING THAT IS. The cookie quickly bent and fell in half in my hand. It was all melty and so was my heart. It was soft and delicious and I want another one now.
Please and thank you.

a closer east village location of these ALL day & LATE night cookies!
I enjoy this location’s cookies MUCH more than the west village location’s since the cookies aren’t overbaked and hard… the cookies here are either nice & soft OR under-​baked … (i guess every insomnia cookies location is INCONSISTENT)
warm cookies when it’s cold out? yes please!
–double chocolate: good!
–snickerdoodle: underbaked but this is one that is fine when its gooey!
–mint: just ok
–white chocolate macadamia: really good if you’re a fan of white chocolate
NOTE: also pretty much a to-​GO shop, not much space inside