Alexander’s On the Square

My second visit to Alexander’s On the Square did not disappoint! Ate lunch at Rosie’s around the corner after attending a wonder Memorial Day Celebration then on to Alexander’s for dessert. I love the historic atmosphere of Noblesville’s town square and the shops. Alexander’s does have a full menu of great comfort food but we were there for the ice cream. We all ordered a single which will get you more than enough ice cream for the price. I ordered Elephant Ear ice cream that was full of bit of cinnamon elephant ears! One of my family members order S’mores which contained graham cracker bits, chocolate and marshmallow which she found to be fantastic. The shop also sells South Bend Choc Co candies and art work by local artists! Love a business who supports the community! I will always be willing to make the drive from Greenwood to meet family for ice cream at Alexanders!

Burgers and wraps that are pretty decent, service is slow but still we enjoyed the restaurant, this place gets packed for their ice cream

We like Alexander’s because it’s local and quaint, and it really contributes to the ambience of downtown Noblesville (grab a cone and head out to the square on warm evenings – there are plenty of benches and it’s very pedestrian-​friendly). They serve Velvet brand ice cream, which tastes good, and they offer dozens of flavors, but it’s not like it’s house made ice cream you can’t get anywhere else. The other reason I’m a bit lukewarm on Alexander’s is that the kids working behind the counter get pretty frazzled with the long lines in warm weather, and so the service isn’t spectacular. Be prepared to stand in line for a while. But hey, the portions are huge (a double scoop filled an entire dish to the top) and walking around the square with ice cream is a nice way to spend an evening.

I like the old fashioned atmosphere this place has its very nice and the ice cream is delicious. Nice place to take the kids!

We have just moved to Noblesville and this is our first time to Alexander’s we will definitely be back! Lots of yummy ice cream :)

Visited Alexander’s for the first time today with the entire family and a new set of Indiana friends. Great little family friendly place to hang with friends and enjoy some delicious ice cream. Lots of ice cream flavors to choose from.

Good food, fair prices, lots of opinions on the menu. Good rye bread on their Reuben. Great ice cream and so many yummy choices.
Came in today for the Colts Special. Love seeing them support the local teams. Loved the free sub sandwich & chips option. I don’t normally like Buffalo chicken, but the sliders today were the perfect blend of buffalo flavor & cool blue cheese dressing. Glad I decided to try it!

We love Alexander’s! Very family friendly and supports the Millers’ sports teams! Lots of great ice cream flavors!

If you’re going to Alexander’s for food you’d probably come away disappointed. That doesn’t seem to be their focus and isn’t a reason to go there.
I love going to Alexander’s for ice cream. The portions are generous (1 scoop is really the equivalent of 2) and there is a decent variety of flavors.
When I take my family we can all 4 get ice cream and stay under $ 15. When you compare that to the cost of going to Cold Stone or somewhere similar then you see how good of a deal it is.

Ice cream isn’t bad… Velvet brand (you can get it at Kroger cheaper). Food is almost all frozen, but cheap for the portions you get. The décor is nostalgic, including the original tin roof. A Noblesville staple for when you gotta feed the kids and all their friends.

Really good stuff here. old school ice cream palor feel with diner esq. Type of food with a at home taste. The ice cream is delicious and the array of chocolate is great as well. Suprised to find this place and seriously cant wait to make this a weekly stop!
Must go!

Great place to stop for ice cream if you’re in the area. The food is nothing special, but the ice cream is tasty, with plenty of variety and huge portions. Staff are very friendly and accommodating — one guy who had served me before went out of his way to say hi to me when he stopped by on his day off! The place is adorable. One downside is that the aisles are really narrow, so it can be a little difficult to navigate if there are a lot of people. Be prepared to say «Excuse me» more than once!

The perfect little ice cream parlor for the perfect town square. Lots of ice cream flavors and not one disappoints. But don’t even bother getting ice cream if you’re not going to get it in a waffle cone because their waffle cones are absolutely the way to go. If you’re in Noblesville for any reason, I recommend a quick stop at Alexander’s!

This probably won’t be a very long review. I just love this place! I grew up going to Alexander’s in the summer to get ice cream, so it has a special place in my heart and childhood memory. When you walk in to this place you feel right at home, I love what they’ve done with the interior decorating. Staff is very friendly and helpful.
The best flavor in my opinion is the birthday cake. Cake batter ice cream with sprinkles and icing. It’s to die for. They do sell diner food as well, but I’ve never tried it nor will I. I don’t expect the food to be any good, but my god the ice cream is. I’ve always been a big fan of Cold Stone too, but Alexanders always wins in my book!

Every time I’ve been here the ice cream tastes freezer burnt. I wish they made their own instead of purchasing what I could buy at the grocery store for much cheaper.
I agree with some of the other reviewers that it’s worth the drive to go to Handels instead.

I like that they’re locally owned, but the ice cream is nothing special and obviously not made on site … you can buy the same stuff at Kroger! Next time will take the farther drive to Handel’s, it’s worth it.

We stopped by for lunch this Sunday after golf. What a fun, cute old style soda fountain restaurant on the main square. The food was down to earth and good. Simple items on the menu that we all love to have. After lunch we enjoyed some of the wide assortment of ice cream. The servers were great and when back in Nobelsville, a definite stop.

I’ve been here a few times since moving to Noblesville and it never disappoints! As a pregnant lady, I succumbed to the case of ice cream more than once… but it’s so good!!!
As far as regular, non-​ice cream food… it’s the standard diner fare, like burgers and fries, but it’s a pretty large menu so they have variety on their side. It’s not stellar food but I don’t expect stellar, over the top great food from diners.
So for an a casual lunch followed by a sinful helping of ice cream, it’s perfect.

You are on the Square in Down Town Noblesville on a summers Sat. night looking at all the old car, hot rods and the like when you need something cold and there is Alexander’s! The look of the place from outside tells you that once you walk inside you will be getting what you where looking for! This is the soda shop from all the old time movies about small town America you ever seen. The tin ceiling that are two stories high. The glass cases full of hand made chocolate candies. The rows and rows of small batch ice cream in the freezer case.
So many to pick from and so many cones to have it in, or do you want a Sunday, or a shake? You make up you mind and pick you watch as the huge scoops are placed on the cone. Now do you go back outside or eat here where it is cool? What a life to have to make up your mind so many time when all you where looking for was some Ice Cream!
The food is also very good here and should not over looked!
Remember to eat well and live well! And please no chains!

Awesome small town ice cream shop. When in the Noblesville area, why hit up Coldstone when you can support a non-​chain ice cream shop? They stock my favorite cinnamon ice cream year round — you can’t always find it at other places. Prices are reasonable too. They also serve food and sell South Bend Chocolate Company goods.