18 Degrees Celcius

This store is now called #piewholestuffer…the owners combined their 3 stores together in one convenient location… same people, same ideas, same customer service…

We happened to stumble upon this place and were delighted that we did! The pineapple pink peppercorn was one of the best ice-​creams we’ve had. These guys deserve full points for innovation!

Yeah. Straight up awesome. Best coffee ice cream. They even have Chaga flavored! Never heard of that? Me neither until I stopped in there. Going back for seconds.

Once you open that door the smell inside is amazing, the fresh smell of that maple waffle cone which are made in house will send your taste buds to heaven. Quality not quantity ice cream is sold here.

Delicious! Loved the small batch concept, and the flavors were delicious (we had chocolate and salted caramel). The owner was nice and patiently explained the logic behind the temperature and ingredients.

Yes yes! Glad to see such a fun ice cream shop in North Conway. The owner obviously takes pride in his creations, and I’m happy to try them out.
Great flavors:
Coconut (a more natural coconut flavor)
Salted Caramel (lush and caramelized)
Pineapple Pink Peppercorn (herby and fruity)
Good flavors:
Mint chocolate chip is more herby than candy flavored. Some would say it’s better, but I thought it was ok.
I did have coconut with caramel sauce sundae, and it was fantastic. Oh and their fresh homemade cones ARE AMAZING.
My suggestion: have a list of what all of your sundae flavors are, because it’s annoying to have to ask the staff what each one is!

I tried this because it was rated the best ice cream in North Conway. It was good– but I think it was overrated. This reminded me more of a specialty hipster joint in a city, and pretty out of place. The ice cream was very good, I can’t deny. But the portions were tiny and there were no options for dairy free/​low fat/​any specific diet. Maybe portion control is better than a big portion of low fat ice cream, but it seemed odd to have this specialty place without any ice cream options for people with dietary needs. There were some Popsicle options, but not ice cream. I just overall wasn’t impressed considering the hype. If you are looking for a mom and pop type ice cream place like I was. This isn’t for you.

We travel to the Mount Washington Valley every summer and have for years. Sadly, businesses in this prime, corner location don’t seem to stick around. I worry that this ice cream shop will suffer a similar fate. The flavors are interesting and yummy, ingredients are top notch; however, I worry that this place isolates itself from folks with a less adventurous palate. For example, someone in my party asked what the pineapple pink peppercorn ice cream was like. The server’s response was «exactly what it says… Pineapple with pink peppercorn.» Eh… Okay. We had kids in our party who wanted Popsicles and we were told that only one flavor from the list of offerings would likely be appealing to a kid. This makes me worry for the place. Everyone likes ice cream, including people who don’t eat pink peppercorns and spicy Popsicles. We did enjoy our ice cream though. In fact it was delish. We got the grumpy old man and the salted caramel pretzel. Both were great! Just wish this place behaved more like an ice cream shop and less like a high-​end hair salon… Especially when there’s another ice cream shop two doors down and gelato across the street.

Decent ice cream at best. Asked for one type of popsicle and was given the wrong one. The cones were too thick. Over priced ice cream.

Almost left after seeing the odd flavors but so glad I didn’t. I settled on banana in a waffle cone. Most amazing thing ever. The waffle cones are made right there and mine was still warm when served. Definitely will be going back!

Did you want your hot cocoa with a shot of local maple syrup? How about Indian spices? Mexican spices? Or maybe classic peanut butter? If you’re a cocoholic looking to sip on a master cocoa creation… STOP IN!!! I know that *I* will be, every time I pass through to Gorham.
The shop is small, but busy! When we popped in on a Saturday evening we were sixth in line. While it didn’t take us long to get our order in, waiting for that milk to come up to temperature took about 8min or so (impatient I-​only-​do-​drive-​thru people might want to skip this… but we’ll be laughing at you when you turn away).
The price for this INCREDIBLE mouth treat: $ 4-​$ 7 depending on your flavor selection. Did I mention incredible flavors? Salted caramel, vanilla bourbon, egg nog, malted, mexican spice, punjabi, lemongrass, new englader (that’s maple syrup!), peanut butter, traditional… the list goes on! But it shifts around, so don’t go in expecting a specific flavor (though, I doubt you’ll have trouble finding something delicious).
Other sweet treats (cookies, bars, cakepops, and PIE! The best apple pie EVER!) is on sale near the register and ice cream bins are off to the right (yum!). Pay via iPad square swipe and get the receipt emailed to you instantly while you’re still bopping your head to the shop’s sweet tunes and watching the milk be stirred on the stove.
***CAUTION!*** those wearing coats (be it trench, pea, parka… or clothing in general) — STAY — AWAY — FROM THE WALLS. While I’m a big fan of neon chalk-​on-​board, I’m not a fan of walking away with tic-​tac-​toe results on my derrière.

I’m dairy & soy free right now, which is never more of a bummer than when ice cream is involved. That was not the case here! 2 words: homemade Popsicles. I had a banana red hot coconut concoction that sounds weird, but was the most delicious Popsicle I’ve ever eaten. Just thinking about it now I’m salivating, and so sad that I’ll have to wait until I’m back in North Conway to get another.
My husbands obsessed with coffee, and he loved the flavor of their coffee ice cream.
Just a note for people with kids: their rainbow sprinkles are the tiny circle kind, not the regular shape. This caused my 3 year old to have a meltdown. Consider yourself warned.

Highest quality, inventive, small batch and almost too good to be true.
The selection is minimal and they do run out but get any flavor; you can’t go wrong.
The home-​made waffle cones are the very best I’ve ever had.
If you’re an ice cream freak like me and can appreciate an attempt at the «state of the art», then you need to try this proud little gem.
Can I get an amen?

Very friendly operation and proprietor was extremely accommodating to us. The I’ve cream is excellent and the flavor combinations are inventive and delicious. You are encouraged to be adventurous.

The place smelled like bacon. Really strongly like bacon. And their flavor are really weird. I almost left. I’m so glad I didn’t leave. I got the Dolcé. So good. My wife got blackberry in a bacon waffle cone. Which didn’t actually taste like bacon. It tastes like awesome. Just go here and ask the girl who works there what her favorites are and buy one of them. You’ll be glad you did. And don’t get out off by the smell of bacon or whatever they’re cooking on the day you show up.

Start your review. Stopped in while visiting the shops in downtown North Conway. So glad we did, it was awesome. We had the chocolate, Unicorn chasers, blackberry and a raspberry & cream popsicles. We all loved it. You can see the ice cream being made and the ingredients being used. Small batch, with ingredients you can read. Wish we went in the first day of our stay

In all honesty, this is the best ice cream I’ve ever had! They handmade the waffle cone right in front of our noses — it was still warm when they gave it to us. We were thrilled to find such a hidden gem.