Antonio’s Pizza

We received a gift card to go Antonio’s Pizza… Looked up the website and thought we could go to a pizza place… no… It’s a carry out– but if you go next door to Tony Malonies you can get the same pizza but sit at the bar and eat it.
We had Danielle as our server and was probably the best part of the experience. She went thru a list of the bar cocktails and beers and we ended up with a Jose Cuervo Margarita and a Moscow Mule. Then we ordered a pizza. Now my husband and I have been to Italy a few times and were expecting some type of Italian pizza– something close to our travels from the toe of Italy to the top.
We ordered the Thin crust, regular sauce, ham and mushrooms. The crust was good, and the sauce had a lot of flavor. but why oh why do pizza places use canned mushrooms, they become yellowish green and soft when baked. The ham had a great taste if it was on a salad. Big chunks… but again on a pizza? Maybe a thing slice /​shaved ham would have been better. Not sure if we will go back– if we do it will be because we have money left on the card and we can already get a cocktail from Danielle.

been getting their pizza for years, it is very good but lately noticed they are a little heavy handed with the sauce and skimpy on the cheese, called once a while back and the manager said that the new cheese they are using must have a little more moisture content in it… gee, heard that from places that are cutting corners… anyway the pizza is good quality but now i order extra cheese, to get a normal amount… their sicilian square is good, why aren’t they sprinkling a little corn meal on all their pizza, why just the square? Been cheating on them and getting Marco’s White Pizza (loaded with three or four cheeses, bacon bits and tomatoes) and sprinkled with a little cornmeal, it is the bomb. Now we order from both places, depending on our mood.

When I first moved to the area, my co-​worker said I had to try Antonio’s and I’m so glad I did. Every time I order from here I fall more in love with pizza! And they’ve always been 10 – 15 minutes faster than estimated time. I highly recommend to anyone looking for delicious pizza, wings, breadsticks, or salad. This place is awesome!

I have to get Antonio’s every time I’m in town because Dayton pizza is terrible. By far the best pizza in Cleve!

The food is usally good, but they can never get the order correct and they are not consistent, which is frustrating!

red flag, my order was $ 31.49 and they charged my credit card $ 33.49 and then put an extra charge of 27.49 on my credit card that was fraudulant. average pizza, not worth the hassle

If the pricing were a little less, I would be handing this place the first FIVE star rating but I’m a cheapskate. The food is fresh and having many visits of experience behind me have had no bad experiences whatsoever. My wife and I love the pizza and the salad from Antonio’s. I’m not overly excited about their new location in regards to the parking because it always seems so crowded and congested. With so many competing pizza shops in the area, Antonio’s is second to none as my #1 choice. I hope it will be yours as well.