Andy’s Frozen Custard

Legit the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Tastes like God’s cum. Got the peanut butter and Oreo mixed in

Very disappointed.
Stopped three last night, sbout 8:35.
They had an employee stanfing outside taking orders because it was so busy.
Four out of four items were wrong.
Ordered a kid chocolate with strawberries. Received vanilla with strawberries.
Ordered two medium vanilla in a cup.
Received two smalls
Ordered medium vanilla cookie dough.
Not sure what wad added.
VERY DISAPPOINTED as well as my family.
being busy is no excuse.
THANKS ANDY. HOW DO I GET MY MONEY BACK?

Quality of food was wonderful and I really enjoyed my cream soda float!
Service was a little off putting and I’m hoping that is not a regular thing. I went through the drive-​thru and I went to pay, the cashier didn’t give me a glance… not even once! She dropped my change and said it was just a penny… yeah but MY money, and handed me the ice cream cone with her head completely turned away from me saying to have a nice day. Wow, okay. Lost a star for that.
I’ll be okay to give it another try.

The young man that has been working outside for the drive up is always courteous, professional and really shows what customer service is all about, Kudos to him

I have been coming here since this place opened years ago, but after my experience here tonight, I will not be coming back. They gave me the wrong item and refused to handle the issue in a professional manner. The people who work here are all snotty teenagers and washed up morons. I got an attitude and side eye the second it was clear I was coming back with the wrong thing. The custard here is good, but I refuse to deal with the workers anymore. Culver’s it is.

Excellent ice cream and custard.
Comparable to Baskin Robbins, Primos and Wojo’s but richer and thicker slightly.
Has many varieties and serving sizes. Recommended small vanilla ice cream cup for diabetics and those with CKD like me.
Friendly staff, clean. Quiet.
Near White Castle.
⁵⁄₅ stars.

I’ve driven by Andy’s — at least a dozen times in the past but have never stopped in. So, after visiting a friend at Christ Hospital, I decided to give it a shot.
My thoughts: delicious custard, very fresh toppings (I had strawberries and bananas), clean, friendly — all good!
Next time I visit I’ll be bringing some to the hospital — my friend will love it.

This place has great ice cream however this place is very unorganized. We had to tell the people that our order was incorrect twice. I would come back if only the guaranteed a more organized approach

Each year I visit Chicago and I stay at a hotel near 95^th and Cicero on purpose. Just so that I can go to Andy’s Frozen Custard and have my favorite. Turtle Split. The Turtle Split is Andy’s vanilla frozen custard and a whole banana covered with hot fudge. I always have them add extra crème caramel, cause the stuff is addicting. Oh and I love their bottles of Ginger Beer the stuff is heaven. If you are in Chicago stop by this Andy’s, and they will make your day and your favorite treat. Be prepared though cause like I said the stuff is addicting and causes me to go to Chicago every year just to get some.

My family and I been eyeing Andy’s for about a year. Finally went in this evening. We had order the Stolen Brownie Sundae and Turtle Split. I thought we paid too much for both, and as for the taste I thought it was okay. It should’ve been less but that’s business. I did like all of the employees who are friendly, good blue collar workers. I would go back to try something else but not anytime soon.

Had the worst service possible I went to the counter and was waited on by a black female age 25 to 30 I asked for 5 scoops of alternating flavors 3 chocolate to vanilla to go then I asked for a sundae made with custard of chocolate with M & M sprinkles and then said I’m not finish with my order I asked for a to school cone with chocolate and vanilla & chocolate cone, Chola te on the bottom and a double scoop chocolate she came back with a 5 scoops of ice cream sitting on top of a single cone and she came back with a sundae made with vanilla ice cream instead of chocolate ice cream not only that, she got the order WRONG AGAON. Okay it’s one thing to get the order wrong but it’s another thing to be rude this manager that I found out she’s the manager was not only rude but apparently cannot comprehend. I will avoid this Andy’s, there is another Andy’s fortunately on Harlem. If o come back here, I hope like hell I don’t get waited on by her. I was shocked to hear she was a manager.

Really good frozen custard. They have a good variety to choose from. You’ll have to view their menu to see them all. It’s hard to recommend any because they all taste great! At this location they have a nice seating area if you want to stay and eat it there. Only bad thing is that they are kind of pricey (about $ 5 – 6 for most) along with being high in fat content. So I can’t have Andy’s often.

An expensive but delectable pampering. Clean and relatively friendly but a big ticket for a family treat. Worth it but need a little more than just a «B» on the report card… going to take a whole string of «A’s» for this one!

Recently tried the apple pie sundae it was so good. Some of the ice cream specials are a little too sweet and a little on the heavy side for me, I split it with my husband. But my all time favorite is the strawberry shortcake.

I recently had a chance to check this place out for the first time. Had seen it before but never had a chance to go and it’s not near me either. Anyway, I went in without checking any reviews. I liked its looks, set-​up, atmosphere and all. Reminded me off an old-​fashioned ice cream joint. Their menu looked good and prices were reasonable. I decided to go for their Concrete of the Month — Key Lime Pie where they add a whole slice of that Pie and blend it w/​their Vanilla frozen custard. The result was tasty but a bit too sweet flavored concrete. It felt like I was eating sugar. The texture was alright — creamy & smooth. I liked this place and would give it another try. 3.5 stars.

Alexander Pope once said, «You eat, in dreams, the custard of the day.»
I’m quite fond of Mr. Pope and this whole custard-​consuming dream business of his.
Andy’s was a welcome addition to the Oak Lawn area with their incredibly friendly and cheerful employees, a lightning-​fast drive-​thru and frozen, creamy concoctions. My favorites are the Snowmonster (with extra strawberries) and their Peppermint Concrete. The key lime pie has a nice bit of sour and is also enjoyable, although I wish it was less sweet and had bigger pie chunks mixed in. I’m sure they’re going to read this and get right on that for me.
Now I have my favorites for ice cream (nearby, insanely affordable and delicious Cupid’s Ice Cream Fountain and the amazing Beverly Rainbow Cone), but this suits my custard cravings while providing jobs for local teens and giving couples and kids a place to sit back and enjoy a treat. Of course those couples and children are why I always use the drive-​thru, but still it’s good to see families and friends gathering and enjoying themselves… especially from a distance. I kid. I kid.*darts eyes* White Castle is next door and so I’ll sometimes snag a bag of onion rings to dip in my custard, but only on rare occasion when I’m eMo and the world has crushed my hopes and dreams. Nom nom nom…
I would have thrown them five stars, but for those of us who *sometimes* have to watch carbs or sugars, there are no specifically dedicated low-​carb or sugar free options. I also feel they are a bit pricier than I’d care for…(this is why I LOVE Cupid’s.) Still, I dig the variety here. A small is pretty filling, but if you get a bigger size, ask for a plastic lid in case you don’t finish. I always freeze my unfinished portion to save cash for another cheat day. Then I can buy something else I want, but perhaps don’t need, like a killer «Kiss» Snuggie. \m/

Mmm… always creamier and yummier than Culver’s! ANDY’S IS THE BOMB-​DIGITY! Whatever you order, get extr toppings and they’ll end up putting it in the next size up at no charge to you! Simply great. SnowMonster with added cheesecake and pecans is my favorite! Go get it!

This location for Andy’s was when I absolutely loved their frozen custard. I’ve been to many ice cream parlors, and this is one of my favorites on the list. I was nearby Andy’s after a doctor appointment, so I decided to head there!
The custard machines are about the same as some of the Culver’s restaurants. It might look a bit weird, but it is a step to making awesome custard.
The service was fast and pretty good. The staff do pretty good at timing. It only took 5 minutes to get a sundae and 2 concretes (for the people that were with me). That includes people behind me in the line.
The food is the highlight. I get the Boot Daddy concrete which is what I get sometimes. I usually get my concrete from inside. The richness in the custard is a perfect amount. The flavor with the custard is very nice with the toppings. The toppings aren’t mixed in with the custard (usually in «layers»), but it’s not a big deal anyways.
If your on the road and you find an Andy’s Frozen Custard, go there. It may seem small, but it’s worth the wait and the custard is fantastic. I obviously will come back here!

Just visited Andys for the first time! Great mixed custard. Mint Oreo concrete was yummy. A lot of parking, great signage, and good customer service.

I went here at least twice — the frozen custard here is deeeeeelish!
You can have it with toppings, similar to a Dairy Queen’s Blizzard, or you can have it in a cup, cone, or waffle cone. Probably what they offer here is at least what places like Dairy Queen or Tastee Freeze has and then more… and with their frozen custard, even more delicious and sinful.
They also have products from Sprecher’s, like Cream soda or Orange Dream. Can have it in a cup with ice, or in a 4-​pack of bottles. Liquid sinful yum!
This place handles their customers with very decent ease and efficiency: the first time I was there, got my humongoid cone with 3 scoops (I think I recall that) fairly quickly; the second time, there was a family of 8 — the 2 person crew there was a bit overwhelmed, plus 2 drive-​ins too, but by the time they got to my buddy and me, they were still calm, cool, and fairly happy.
Wow, I would of thought they would be upset or at least a bit tired from that ordeal, but they managed that fairly well — never mind that thepeople in the line was waiting about 10 minutes, but its no big deal as they took care of us VERY well and quickly… I forgot if they gave me a discount or something, but being there for the frozen custard was reward enough and worth the trip.
Will definitely come back here to this store, even if its far away! (I live in the NW burbs)
A little word of warning — getting to this place by car is weird — not Andy’s fault, but the flow of traffic of the parking lot for this strip mall is very odd. Don’t go further and enter using the south entrance on Cicero Ave right by Marshall’s. Going through White Castle seems like the better way.