Pie In the Sky

Nothing has ever come close to this home made — personalized, family run ice cream parlor .
We always buy the local seasonal fruit

Oh my god. Any icecream, you can’t go wrong. The pie and jams looked amazing as well, and I don’t doubt they are. I believe it’s a $ 10 minimum on cards, just a heads up. So if you’re short on cash, just order more icecream: P

The handmade ice cream is so yummy !! The black and white and red all over was made the same day! They have home made cream soda also! This is a must stop if your in the area.

Let me say first of all the place is pretty and the handmade ice cream is pretty decent for hard ice cream. They have vegan options, dairy free options, nut free options and the menu is pretty inexpensive and enough choices to please the whole family. In addition to ice cream they sell cookies and fresh produce and maple syrup so that is pretty cool and the inside of the parlor has a nice old timey look to it.
What I did not enjoy is that this place is named Pie In the Sky. «Pie» Well the sky looked nice but there was no pie! No freaking pie! I didn’t even see an empty pie tin! WHERE IS YOUR PIE YOU DEVILS!

The handmade ice cream is wonderful and the flavor selection is quite varied. The atmosphere lends itself to a great overall experience.

Pie in the Sky has a delicious variety of homemade ice cream flavors. The workers are extremely nice and the food is so cheap!
They also sell a lot of knick knacks so it’s fun to walk around and look at everything while your eating your mouth watering cup of ice cream :)

I love Pie in the Sky, and I’m not just saying that because I went to college in Oneonta. I eat a lot of ice cream, and I think Pie in the Sky has the best hard ice cream I have ever had. It it always super fresh, and just enough soft that you don’t have to wait forever for it to be perfect to eat. The prices are reasonable, and the help super nice. I would reccommend it to anyone who likes ice cream. And try out the corn maze in the fall!

We’ve been coming to Pie in the Sky for years. They have great produce, and the original and best Polar Bear Ice Cream.
This is a true Country Store, with crafts, and a old-​time soda fountain atmosphere. Family run and family friendly.
You won’t find better pies in the area, either.
Great place to get your Hallowe’en pumpkin.

This is the best place for ice cream in the Oneonta area. The homemade ice cream is wonderful – a huge variety of flavors from Amaretto Cherry Chocolate Chunk and Raspberry Blueberry Swirl to Almond Joy and Caramel Fudge Swirl. They still serve old fashioned ice cream sodas, root beer floats and banana splits as well. Not in the mood for ice cream – the night we were there, they had a few different cookie choices and Blueberry Peach pie that looked incredible (for only $ 2.50 a slice)
They also have pancake breakfasts and an odd mix of crafts, video rentals and satellite radio installation (odd – yes!) But, it’s well worth the trip. Especially makes sense if you go and grab some ice cream in the summertime before going to the Unadilla Drivein.

This is a produce vendor that also has video rentals (VHS actually). But the main reason why you would go to is the homemade ice cream. Their ginger falvor is real good. They claim their ice creams are lower in fat (and calories) than most others, giving an actual figure, but I am in no position to say whether that is actually true or not. The prices are right (low) as they tend to be in this area. They serve pancakes for breakfast on some weekend mornings but those are not so good.