The Cupcake Orchard

If i could give 0 stars i would have. I tried your bakery discretely for our wedding and my cake craving. Horrible selection, you only had 7 flavors to choose from, which would have been fine. But all of them were stale! I make better cupcakes using a mix and Betty Crocker frosting. Very disappointing. If your baked good were made daily, they wouldn’t taste like crap hours later.

This place is a little Gem, right in the Village of Orchard Park. I for one am a big Fan of Cupcakes (a Personal cake you can hold in the palm of your hand, who needs a slice). This is a place to get something for Birthdays, Graduation Parties, Anniversaries, Weddings (They’ll make your Wedding Cake entirely out of Cupcakes, Cupcakes on each Platform, all the way up to the top and you can pick them off One by One) or you can just get some to satisfy your Sweet Tooth (I know I would).
Here are the Flavors: The Everyday Flavors — Very Vanilla, Chocolate Chocolate, Red Velvet, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Vanilla, Vanilla Chocolate, Sunshine and 24 Carrot (out of the 8 Sunshine and Very Vanilla are my Favorite, Sunshine is a Lemon Cupcake with Lemon Cream Cheese Frosting and the Very Vanilla is (as the Title says) Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Frosting, So Simple yet so Good), The 24 Carrot is okay (last time I had one it was a little Dense) The Red Velvet is my Brother’s Favorite.
They have Seasonal Flavors: Snowball, Snicker Doodle, Honey Banana, Chocolate Strawberry, Double Strawberry, Chocolate Cherry, Cannoli, Chocolate Mint, Chocolate Salted Caramel, Boston Cream Pie, Lemon Raspberry, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Chocolate Mocha, Cookies & Cream, Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Raspberry, Creamsicle, Chocolate Blackberry, S’Mores, Strawberry, Lemon Blueberry, Peach, Pina Colada, Caramel Apple, Pumpkin, Blondie, Chocolate Maple, Sweet Potato, Gingerbread, Chocolate Peppermint and Cupcakes based on the Holidays (So many to choose from and its hard to pick one Each Month).
Some of My favorites: S’Mores (Chocolate Cake with a Graham Cracker Crust on the Bottom and topped with a Toasted Marshmallow Frosting, I love when you Bite into Rich, Decadent and Moist cake followed by that Gooey Marshmallow and a bit of Crunch from that Graham Cracker on the Bottom. Who needs the Campfire). Lemon Blueberry (such a beautiful Combination, Sweet and Sour, Tart and Tangy). Others I’ve Tried, Others I’ve yet to try and Others I have no desire to try.
At $ 3.25 a Cupcake I thought it was a tad bit pricey at first, but then I realized that it was worth it treat myself every once in a while. The manager is very nice and hard at work in the back making sure her Cupcakes are being made Fresh and ready to be put on Display. So be sure to come down and grab some Cupcakes.

I decided to try this with a groupon. The flavors were ok, I especially liked the piña colada cupcake, but all off the cupcakes I brought home tasted like they were not baked sufficiently. I would not go out of my way to go back there.

Cupcakes in OP. This was an impulse stop for me. I was at Orchard Fresh and just Unilocaled to see what was in the area that I could check out. This popped up. And since cupcakes always make me happy off I went.
It’s a discreet doorfront. Don’t let it fool you. Inside is lovely and cute.
There were perhaps 9 flavors in the case when I was there. I picked up 4.
One peach which we enjoyed. Fresh peaches I’d wager. Very nice cupcake.
One chocolate with chocolate frosting. Very rich. Enjoyed.
One peanut butter. Perhaps slightly sweet but good.
One salted caramel. Least favorite. Frosting either not blended or supposed to have sugar graduals but it tasted a little odd to us.
These are a normal size cupcake, not a behemoth one. They have a reasonable amount of frosting. From a balance and ratio view, they hit it. Not too big. Not too small.
These are all better at room temp and better if eaten within a day. If you fridge them take then out before eating so they warm up.
They cost 2.50 each, tax included. That makes it easy.
I’d stop in again when in the area. Thanks Julie C., fellow Unilocaler who wrote the review that sent me this way.
Easy parking in private lot.

I’m a huge proponent of desserts… but they HAVE to be good. Anybody/​everybody is opening cupcake bakeries today, so you need to stand out.
I have 3 quick things to say:
1) Great selection. Very interesting flavors combinations and looks.
2) Amazingly delicious cake… you know, that part underneath the frosting. Mine was very dense and moist — the way a gourmet cupcake should be! (in my mind)
3) I disliked their frosting base with a passion. I sampled 3 different cupcakes purchased by my friend. We opened up the box of cupcakes at work and ALL of the frosting was heavily smeared all over the inside of the box. My friend said she transported it as carefully as possible, so I knew something was wrong with the cupcakes themselves. Sure enough, all of the frostings had a had cream-​cheese base ingredient as I tried them… meaning that it does not hold shape well, especially on top of a cupcake. The cheesiness of the frosting conflicted with the sweetness of the cake. The peanut butter frosting was bad, really weird taste and gummy consistency.
To Cupcake Orchard — Create a non-​cream cheese based frosting and I will gladly re-​rank you at 5 stars.

I stopped here based off a strong recommendation from someone I work with and this place meets expectations. The cupcakes are awesome and taste great. I wish I lived near this place!

Although I’m from DC where cupcake shops abound, the cupcakes from Cupcake Orchard are among the best I’ve had. After trying them when visiting family over Thanksgiving, they made such an impression that we had to go back again on another recent visit to the Buffalo area.
Every flavor was delicious with a moist cupcake topped with a fluffy icing that has just the right amount of sweetness. A couple flavors were were particularly memorable on our most recent visit: The S’more cupcake, complete with graham cracker crust on the bottom and a little Hershey bar garnish, was AMAZING. Also, the strawberry strawberry cupcake was absolutely divine.
To add the icing to the cupcake, all of the folks at the counter who helped us were wonderful, very kind and friendly. We cannot wait for our next trip to Buffalo to get our cupcake fix!

I recently had the chance to taste two of their cupcakes, and after doing so, I felt like as much as the cupcakes looked pretty, it failed to deliver when it comes to taste.
I was able to try the strawberry lemonade, as well as the chocolate blackberry cupcakes. The presentation was quite splendid. They rank rather high on aesthetics. However, the cake was rather dry, and I actually took solace in the fact that there was frosting that was rather decent, in order to moisten my bite. As I personally know someone who was professionally trained to bake, I have rather high standards when it comes to cakes.
For the Cupcake Orchard, the frosting may be great, but the cake has plenty of room for improvement. A great frosting on top of a blah cake, they just cancel each other out. Hence I am giving it 3 stars.

I was looking for alternatives to traditional wedding cake and found this place. I live in San Diego and will not be back to Buffalo until my wedding reception in June. My mom and sister came out to visit me last week and brought me a six pack of cupcakes from The Cupcake Orchard. I was very impressed!
The cupcakes were moist and the frosting was tasty but not too sweet. They have a huge variety of flavors, including my current favorite Salted Caramel! Plus they are a steal at $ 2.25 each! Cupcakes where I live are damn near $ 5. They deliver for only $ 10 too. I plan to order about 15 dozen cupcakes for my wedding reception. Now I just need to figure out which flavors to get…

I just visited this place for the first time while doing some outreach for Give For Greatness. I’m having this problem that’s not really a problem where I keep discovering awesome new local businesses! I’m a cupcake fan in the worst way, and this place has HONEY FROSTING. What?!? I mean I’ve had cupcakes from coast to coast but this was a first. Beautiful store, elegant ambiance, which I didn’t expect, but made me want to drive to Orchard Park for a decadent cupcake experience with some dear friends. One side of the store features beautiful tables and chairs to sit, eat your cupcake and watch the world go by (until the sugar high kicks in…) and on the other side of the store one finds a fun festive atmosphere for kids and curious cupcake fans who want to see where the magic happens! A cupcake from this place could heal most wounds, pretty sure about that.

Every cupcake I have had from there has been super moist, delicious, and TO DIE FOR! I am super picky when it comes to frosting and cupcakes. I don’t like that nasty buttercream and too harsh of taste, but they seem to nail it. Like, WOW! I have been there twice so far, and wow those cake pops they have are so freakin’ good!
I found my go to place for cupcakes. Finally!

Excellent cupcakes. The cake is moist, the frosting is delicious. I ate the caramel apple and the very vanilla. My wife enjoyed her red velvet and 24 carrot. Our son enjoyed his sunshine and chocolate maple. Highly recommend the Cupcake Orchard for a special treat. It is also a great alternative to bringing a cake to a party. A great pick-​me-​up for someone who is feeling down. We plan on picking some up for Thanksgiving but I am sure we will be back before then!

Because of the previous review and the fact that I had a free day today and don’t live too far away, I stopped in for cupcakes. Basic storefront. The strange thing is that I pass here every single day and did not know this place existed. Now that I’ve discovered it, I’ll be back a few times a week.
Wonderful selection and fabulous product. Very pretty as well. The sad thing is that I’m not a real sweet fan but these have me hooked.

The three greatest inventions: the wheel, fire, and the cupcakes at the Cupcake Orchard (not necessarily in order)
The place hasn’t even opened its doors yet (October 8^th Grand Opening) but I got to attend a «soft opening» and I am not really that much of a sweets person but these cupcakes are surreal. Forget a dozen roses for your sweatheart buy her cupcakes from the Cup Cake Orchard and all will be forgiven for 20 years.