Gus’s New York Pizza Lounge

This place is great! Great food and good service!
I would recommend. Lots of space to party too

Great atmosphere. Great service. Great food. Very family friendly environment. The servers are all nice and super friendly. Great drinks at the bar as well. Just an overall good place to be. I’ve been here twice and will continue to go back.

It is great to see a genuine pizza and wings spot that has a full quality bar in Peoria instead of driving across creation to to get to one. Had the toasted Italian with the antipasto salad and it was great! Plus Christian the server is awesome! He treated my wife and I like royalty.
Overall, I think this is a place my wife and I will frequent more often for the atmosphere and the level of service you receive when you walk through the door.

Great place, great atmosphere, and most importantly great food ! Glad to see a place like Gus pizza here in the heart of Peoria.

Just tried to order the same takeout order I’ve had on 3 prior occasions, this time a «Jessica» answered the phone & seemed oblivious. She did not know that there is a «Gus special» pizza and that they carried a baked wings on their menu.
I had to repeat myself three times for her to understand my order, I asked for the manager and she told me that he will be back and he never took my call.
Next time I’ll try Don’s New York pizza which is right across the street, I read that they have great customer service.

Food is definitely 4 star and service is 2 star so they get 3. Prices are good. 2^nd time here. Got different food each time and it was good. Friends all got different stuff and we’re happy with their food too. Service is completely ridiculous. Both times we came the service was horrible. Both times were different staff also. Super slow and completely unprofessional. Waitress said «you guys ready yet or not?» Mind you, was told from the back to have a seat wherever we wanted when we walked in… not greeted at the front door. No big deal. OK then Waitress comes over and leaves 2 menus and leaves… yeah ill take a drink. Then comes back and says the ready or not. One thing after another. Hopefully the owner checks the reviews and can fix the staff. Little training goes a long ways. Good job on the food though. So… one more thing… as I’m sitting here writing up this review she has came back 3 times for the credit card slip with the tip on it. Really? If she came back that much to see what we wanted or needed she would’ve nailed it!!! Please work it out cause we are lacking for good stuff on the west side.

Food is great but service could use some experience. Got seated and wasn’t asked what we wanted to drink. When the server came over it was «are you guys ready to order, or no?» We ordered two slices of cheese pizza, two salads and six wings. Pizza came out first followed shortly by one of the salads, a few minutes later the other and finished with the wings. Ummm… ok??? We had to ask for silverware and ice for the iced tea that had none. Not baby friendly, no changing table. Moral of the story, call it on and order it to go.

New place. just dropped by on a Fri night. not too busy but seems cool. Bartenders are nice. We will be back.

I went on Sunday and I guess a waitress called in sick. It took a long time to get service and food was fair. I felt bad for our waiter who told us up front what was going on. I wanted to leave by sister insisted on staying. I will not be going bAck.

We decided to try this place tonight and we were very disappointed. The food was very bland and had no flavor and the service was so terrible. When it was time to pay, their system wouldn’t run debit cards (icing on the cake)

Second trip to Gus’s. If I was to judge them on their service tonight It would be 2 stars. Hopefully this was just a bad night for them. We shall see when I do my next visit.
Food was good. My wife got a calzone and said it was very good. Loaded with cheese and she had meatballs added. Large enough that two could easily had enough to eat. I again got the wings. I ordered hot but was pretty mild in compare to the last visit.
The service was horrible. Waiter forgot we were there and finally realized we were there. We ordered our drinks and then waited forever for them to come. We then ordered and people that came in after us got their food and had almost finished their meal when my wings were delivered but still no calzone. It came in about 10 more minuets. After we had finished and ready for a bill nothing came. Finally I had to get up and find someone so we could leave.
Because of the first experience I am going to give them another chance to get it right. There are a lot of pizza places near us. They have to be much better that this visit to get my business.
I will start with 4 stars but will probably be 5 stars after the next visit if is as good as our first visit was.
It’s new and as you would expect everything is fresh and crisp. Lay out is similar to most sports lounges. Plenty of tvs to watch your favorite team play. Outside s seating is coming soon. Bring your family not just for the sport lounge crowd.
I got their hot wings. I am usually disappointed as the hot wings are not as hot as I wish. Not so here. Their hot wings are hot, just like I wanted them. The plus… there is some extra sauce in the bottom. I like that. My wife got a veggie pizza. She said it was very good. Plenty of cheese and the crust or pizza dough was especially good. Plenty more on the menu. Everyone should be able to find something they like.
The service was great. The manager came out and greater us, tell us what they were planning and invited us back. Great personal touch.
We will most certainly be back soon.
Their challenge will be there are is several pizza places in the area. Getting in and out is easy but they are hard to see.
Forgot to say… Welcome to the neighborhood.

Place is great, first time here. Pizza was really good was a little dead as far as patrons go but to be fair not very many people are aware it’s tucked in here. I will makes this my regular spot for sure.

So happy this place finally opened! Happy to have a pizza and wings spot nearby that has a full bar where we can relax and watch sports games! Our server was excellent, friendly and attentive and gladly provided recommendations when asked.
We had the mango habanero wings and the sauce was so delicious! My only complaint was the pizza was a bit soggy in the middle so we’ll definitely order it well-​done next time, but the crust itself is INSANELY good! Crispy and airy!
The place just opened this week so the patio is still unfurnished, but hopefully when the weather warms up if they get some TVs out there, it’d be a great place to hang out and watch sports.
Will definitely recommend this place and hopefully it’ll develop a following and become a neighborhood staple!

This place is awesome! The atmosphere is classy and high end. Their offerings hit all of my favorites including some great beers on tap. The pizza was very tasty with a light crisp crust. I’m excited that their is a new establishment near my house that stays open until midnight week days and until 2 am u on weekends