All Star Pizza & Restaurant

I ordered wings, both the hot wings and some with a sort of savory bbq sauce (Jimmy’s?). The flavor of the sauces was decent, but the wings themselves were pretty terrible. Small with very dry meat and a mushy, disheartening exterior.
The bleu cheese dipping sauce that came with the wings seemed to be just mayonnaise with a few chunks of what I assume was bleu cheese sparingly intermixed. Very dissatisfying.
The woman at the front counter, who was also the only other person I saw in this desolate establishment, was actually quite polite. So I guess that’s something.

I can’t see what all the fuss is about. I called All Star at 1:46am and had food at my door by a polite delivery guy by 3:30am. What’s to be expected from a place that delivers that late? I can also say that the pizza wasn’t anything gourmet, but it also wasn’t bad. We ordered a side of wings and those were great as well. Thanks for delivering so late!

Late night drunkness calls for a craving of greasy messy food. But how drunk do you gotta be to eat this garbage? The pizza is bad. And I mean really really bad. From the cheap dough, government cheese and dog pepperoni. Yikes! 2 stars for being open late though. Honestly guys. You could really be an amazing spot. Reevaluate your menu and take the criticism.

I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and curly fries… All star didn’t have curly fries so I asked for regular fries with a side of cheese and they refused. Then I asked for seasoned fries and they said crab fries were too much extra to substitute. Their order and stock was underwhelming and they wouldn’t give the customer extra cheese for their own error! If this wasn’t the only shop in town after 1:30 am they would be out of business due to their customer support… Just ridiculous! I will try not to order from them from here on out and you should too! What’s a small minor order of cheese that they refused… Horrible!

Pizza was pretty good and I like that they stay opened late. A night like tonight I didn’t get get a chance to eat until late and didn’t have time/​too tired to cook. All the other places close at 10pm. So this place was clutch. Didn’t give it 5 stars because it was my first time ordering and I only got a medium pizza. Which was really good btw. I look forward to ordering from hear again.

Ummm. Thanks for your response to my review. But let me just tell you ONE or TWO things. When the waitress came to my table… there was the same EXACT amount of food left on both of our plates. Minus most of the fries. (As I stated before. they were halfway decent) Also we said things were great? Nah… not at all. I absolutely said things were OK… it was late… I was hungry and expected better. I didn’t receive it. There was no point at whatever time it was to get the situation rectified. But for you to respond and blatantly lie about how my food and service was is ridiculous. I’m not the only review that was bad. That’s it. No more. no less. Just take the constructive criticism and do better. Bc if you knew better you would do better. Thanks.

The ladies in here are super nice and are always down to give you change for bus fair when you need it. That was all I had really been in for, until I got super hungry late on a Thursday night. Didn’t matter that it was 12:30 on a weeknight, All Star Pizza was ready to go.
I ordered online because you get a little savings of 5% and chose the buffalo chicken cheesesteak and an order of fries. The total came to around $ 12 which I thought was kind of steep, but I was ok with it because they’re right across from my house and I guess you’re going to pay a little bit of a premium when it’s so late and your options are slim.
The fries were crunchy, hot, and delicious. And there were tons of them. It would have been nice if they had come included with the sandwich though. Speaking of the sandwich — not half bad. The bread was pretty fresh, the chicken was spicy and delicious, and they obliged my request for ranch instead of blue cheese. It really didn’t end up being a bad deal because the sandwich was HUGE. I went to bed super full and ended up having the other half for lunch the next day, so I guess two $ 6 meals is worth it.
All Star is a good option for those late night cravings. They’ll do you right.

Would you like some mold with that? This place was never good, not even for drunk food, and I avoided it mostly entirely. Recently when a friend suggested that we grab a quick bite from there I semi-​reluctantly agreed and ordered chicken quesadillas which came with a side of sour cream and salsa. However, when I opened the salsa, it was a small container of mold– maybe it was once salsa but it was unrecognizable. I don’t want to even know about what is in the rest of their food! For the health of everyone in the area, I would be thrilled to see this place shut down. For now, I highly suggest avoiding this place like the plague. Should you decide to chance it, I wish you happy puking!

I live pretty close to All Star and it has yet to fail after a night of drinking. It seems to become my go-​to for walks back from the bars as I havent had a problem with the food or service.
I havent tried any other menu item besides the BBQ wings, but they absolutely hit the spot. And let’s be honest, even if you have a problem with the food, any place that is open as late as they are deserves some credit.

It’s so funny that people expect 5-​star gourmet pizza, chicken fingers & burgers from a place that’s open and delivers until like 3AM during the week. I literally live across the street from All Star Pizza and couldn’t love this place more! My boyfriend always gets a stromboli which is huge for the price we pay and I love love love their buffalo chicken cheesesteak.

They are open for late delivery on weekends. Do not order and fall asleep. That’s frowned upon and they may not deliver to you again.
Chicken cheesesteak is the best order. Pizza is good when you’re drunk but I’m not a huge fan while sober.

Everything is pretty average at All Star Pizza. Not really good, but not that bad either. It is a good late night spot since it is one of the only places open after midnight and they deliver. The pizza is decent and the fires are average. They do have good chicken fingers. We order from here for late night eats quite often and it does the job, but I would never go really go here otherwise.

Great spot for late night eats…

This rating is mostly based on the fact they are the only place by my work that is open late enough to coincide with my ‘lunch’ break at 2 am. Even when I called 15 minutes before closing one night, the woman on the phone was very sweet and still let me place a delivery order.
I’ve seen the pizza before and have been told by co-​workers (and Unilocalers) that it’s pretty awful. I usually stick with a cheesesteak with whiz, fried onions and sweet peppers. Skimpy on the onions and peppers (so order extra) but the steak itself is reliably satisfactory.
Last time I ordered the broccoli and cheese bites — amazing. Will definitely be ordering those again.
I will admit I have yet to garner up enough courage to try their pizza and I’m not sure I ever will.

2.3 STARS. What a mixed place! 4 star buffalo chicken cheese steaks but 1 star pizza. If you order at this place, you need to know what to get as much as what to avoid. Cheese steak is middle of the road 3 stars and everything else besides the afore-​mentioned is slightly below average. Their pizza has no redeeming qualities except for it is better than Marrones and previously frozen. Friendly blue collar atmosphere that makes you feel welcome.

You know a pizza place isn’t great when it’s not even good when drunk. The one big plus of All Star is it’s proximity to my house and very late hours. Additionally, the staff is friendly and service is good. The food on the other hand… I’ve never got anything at All Star and thought it was good. Pizza, sandwiches, etc… Pretty much is shitty fair

You’re eating All Star because they are open late, not because you’re looking for a fine dining experience. I’m not quite sure how late they are open, but I believe they delivery to 4 AM and are usually rather quick.

First time I’ve ordered from this place.
I ordered the chicken Stromboli — and I have to say it was one of the worst Stromboli’s I’ve ever had. Being Italian, I have grown up eating Stromboli’s all the time — and this one takes the cake (as the worst). The dough is the only redeeming factor — it was alright. As soon as I cut it open, a very large amount of liquid came pouring out of the Stromboli — I had to hold the box on an angle over the kitchen sink. The onions were soggy and dripping — so were the green peppers. The chicken had no taste whatsoever. Not a hint of salt or pepper. You could tell that the cheese was the cheapest option — as it also had no taste whatever, and was generally rubbery. The rest of the Stromboli ended up in the trash. (Such a waste).
To give them credit, I’ve heard that they have pretty good wings — but I probably won’t be ordering from here again regardless after this experience. Oh well.

Got pickup last night with my boyfriend and a friend for dinner/​munchies as we planned to drink later on. Got the #7 Special (XL pizza, 40 piece wings, fries, and a 2 liter for like $ 28). Pizza was decent and the fries were fine, but, I’ve had better. The wings were absolutely phenomenal, though. I wholly recommend them. Overall a good value.

N.B. The given star rating does not imply that this place is comparable to other three-​star establishments; the rating given here is skewed, as no one has ever had food from All Star while sober.
That said, as I recall, All Star is the best food I’ve ever had – ever. Every time I ordered it, I was starving and it was 3am. When all other establishments had left me for dead, All Star was there to rescue me, much like a St. Bernard with a barrel of rum tethered to its collar, there to rescue a moribund skier.
I don’t recall how much it costs – I just gave the delivery guy money until he left – but I assume that the price is good, too.
So, if you’re kind of far from sober, awake at 3am, and starving in Manayunk, call All Star. They will be at your house in no time, and you won’t be able to recall a time when you’ve had better food.