Oteri’s Italian Bakery

Just stopped in for a quick treat while I do laundry. First impression, this place is clean and have a huge selection of baked goods. Ordered a simple chocolate cupcake with a cherry top and a small coffee. Coffee tasted fresh, cupcake was amazing. Moist center and delicious chocolate. So good I had to lick the wax paper! Will definitely be back to try the rest of the selection. Cant wait for my next laundry day!

I ordered a cake one day ahead of time knowing that it was a last minute thing. I had always going to Hornbergers in Bensalem on Byberry Road but they had some weird hours and were closed two days in a row. Therefore I did not know what to expect, when I called to order a 10 inch raspberry pound cake, the customer service was especially great, the girl I spoke with was very polite and able to deal with me when I wasn’t exactly sure about colors and what it should say. Then the next day I went to pick it up and it was ready two hours before they said the day before and the customer service was also great at this time as well. The cakes exceeded my expectations it was delicious you could actually taste raspberry in the raspberry pound cake. Needless to say I won’t go to horn burgers anymore Oteri’s will now be the bakery I go to for all family birthdays! Writing this review is actually making me have a sweet tooth and wanting to stop there for some type of snack

Holy Cookies!!! I cannot emphasize enough how delicious the cookies here are. They have a huge variety of cakes and pastries. The ladies were sweet and walked with me when I was consistently asking «what’s that?» What is this?” hahah I also had a red velvet cupcake and oh my lanta. It wasn’t too sweet and the moisture and presentation of the cupcake itself was very pretty. My only complaint is that their hours are off. The business card says they are open on Sundays but they weren’t. I am not sure if its outdated or not. Parking is in the plaza very limited and they accept most cards including access. I am going to be ordering a cake from here soon and will check in and post some pictures, Also, the «small/​medium cakes are $ 15 & up. Depends on he flavor etc and of course custom orders are priced accordingly. I definitely recommed this bakery. Very good quality!

I ordered cookies for my son’s birthday from here. I was asked to send a picture that they would laser on, since they did not make sugar cookies into shapes. Okay, fine. Well, I got home and realized it was not the same picture I provided. I was kind of annoyed they didn’t tell me they weren’t going to use the same picture. I paid for them in the store not even noticing, so I suppose it’s somehow my fault for not noticing! The cookies tasted good, but I was a little disappointed over how they looked.

I love this bakery. Even better for me being that is right in the neighborhood. I buy cakes for every occasion here. Birthdays, my anniversary, even for Sunday dessert. The selection is almost too much to take in. Everything is always fresh and beautifully displayed. I am always greeted with a smile. Ill never go anywhere else.

I remember Oteri’s as a kid on 5^th Street. They always had the most delicious Italian cakes. This Fairdale store, first thing I noticed when I walked in was how dirty the model wedding cakes in the window were. You could scrape the dust off with a finger.
I started looking though their wedding cake books and the lady behind the counter, without even greeting us, says not to order anything with fondant, just go with buttercream because fondant cakes taste like crap. So, why make them? Isn’t this a bakery?
If you want someone’s business, you convince them to buy things. You don’t tell them not to buy something you’re selling. Not sure if that was just laziness or what.
I was already semi put off, but decided to give the place a go on tasting some of their baked goods. I have to be honest. This is the worst bakery I have ever been to in my life. Between the cookies, cream puffs, chocolate cupcake, cannoli, red velvet cupcake, it all had the same taste. I can’t really describe it, everything we bought had the same flavor and felt like imitation ingredients or something. The texture of the icing and creams were very thick like plaster and I swear you could probably use it to glue things together.
I will never recommend this place to anyone. I also can’t go back to a place where someone with untied hair smelling of cigarettes is selling me anything edible.

to me the food here is a average at best. Be prepared to wait the lines are long
I won’t be going back. I refuse to do business with any business who sells luxury items and accepts welfare cards.
You can get the same quality and lower prices from the dining car at Frankford and Academy

Oteri’s is located in a small strip mall hidden in the corner of the lot. We almost missed it on our first time going. From the outside I was not expecting much, but fortunately looks can be deceiving. We walked in to find the counters filled with various cookies, tarts, pies and cakes. They have a very good selection of pastries and their prices are very reasonable. They make one of the best butter cakes I have ever eaten; gooey yummy goodness and perfectly crispy golden. My husband loved their tiramisu cake and thought the rum cake was very good. He is a dessert freak, so that is high praise indeed. We have been back several times and the service is always very attentive and friendly. Oteri’s will be our holiday spot for desserts

Ahh, so glad this business made it to Unilocal!Since I live in the area, bakeries are scarce. Love this place! Everything looks incredibly scrumptious and fresh. Everytime I go the owner is there and I end up learning something new about the place.
I crave their cannolis !!! After the last bite, I deff fall into a depression, it’s just that good. They really have all kinds of things from cookies to cakes to pies to other pastries that look nothing short of amazing. I’d love to try everything. SERIOUSLY — GO ! Make sure this place stays in business, we need an awesome bakery around here that lasts. yummm

A very good bakery hiding on the outskirts of the Franklin Mills area. When you walk in, the smell is fantastic. Nothing beats the smell of freshly baked goods, and this place is really fantastic. They have a variety of donuts, cakes, pies, bread, cupcakes, cookies and the list goes on.
One thing that deserves special mention is their buttercake. Buttercake is getting harder and harder to come by, when it used to be a north and northeast Philly staple in the 80’s and 90’s. Oteri’s makes a fantastically gooey buttercake that was sweet, and just the right size and price. also, the donuts were quite delicious as well. I have tried a variety of donuts here and they range from cake like to light and fluffy. they are large, perfectly cooked and delicious.
Good old fashioned Italian style bakeries have been closing left and right in northeast Philly. Places like this just aren’t as easy to find anymore. It’s a great neighborhood bakery that’s worth the drive for me. Check them out, they definitely have something to satisfy that morning sweet tooth.