Peppi’s

First time to Peppi’s. Hard to believe after all these years that I have never been to a Peppi’s. Read the menu on the counter because the chalkboard is confusing; even the staff said so!
You order at the counter and they delivered to your table. It did take a little longer than we expected but not to long. Enjoyed looking at all the photos while we were waiting.
Ordered the Franco, an Italian with a little extra salami. Probably did not need the extra but the sub was very tasty and to large to finish, so I have lunch for today too. While not the best Italian sub/​hoagie that I have had, it was very good and better than most sub shops that have popped up everywhere.
The staff was super friendly and thought busy did stop by our table. If you are in the area and looking for a pretty good sub or sandwich, Peppi’s is a good stop.

Love their sandwiches, especially at this location! I always enjoy the mushroom cheesesteak and their French fries! A great, laid-​back atmosphere as well! Definitely one of my favorite stops when I’m home in the burgh!

One of the best places in Pittsburgh to get a sandwich. The cheese steak with mushroom is my go to. I always get some of the fresh cut fries as well

Awesome Roethlisburger. Lives up to the hype. May have to get another one before I leave town.

Quintessential Pittsburgh. A hit for our party of 5. I’m gonna say it– I liked it better than Primanti’s.
Hearty, creative sandwiches made with love and likely to keep you full all day. Dedicated following of regulars. Seats are old church pews! Some seriously good French fries. Service with a smile — and speedy. The décor, photos of local celebrities and business cards of patrons, tells the story of this local institution.
What would have made it better: simple kids menu/​pricing.

I LOVE PEPPIS!!! Everything about their sandwiches is glorious! The guys behind the bar are always smiling and joking and just generally happy. You really can’t go wrong with anything on their menu because the subs are all so good! The place is a cash only establishment but they do have an atm inside. Always enjoyable and left feeling full and satisfied. Thanks guys!

First time experiencing Peppi’s and it did not disappoint. I love the whole feel and set up of this place. After ordering our sandwiches at the counter we took a seat in the dining room and I immediately became caught up with looking over all the people photos lining the walls and reading some of the various business cards patrons have placed under the wooden strips along an area inside the dining area. Perhaps I will decide to give Good Fellas Remodeling a call… or maybe not! The Phantom Steak hoagie was very enjoyable and filling. I am looking forward to another go at Peppi’s!

I always used to cut class and head over there for one of their delicious sandwiches. Always has been one of my favorite places.

I am driving from Virginia to Seattle with my two dogs and a trailer of my things. Needless to say, I’m exhausted and it’s only the beginning. I told my friend I was excited to be coming up on Pittsburgh, somewhere I’ve never been before. I asked her what I should eat! She then recommended this place.
My first experience with them was awesome. My friend had already talked to them so they were expecting me (and knew about my long journey). Super friendly on the phone, ordered a cheesesteak.
When I arrived, they had put up a welcome note (which I didn’t see at first and passed like a million times! Hah) which totally made my entire week. They were so nice even with me being in my frazzled state! The people who work here… SERIOUSLY AWESOME.
And now the food… So bomb! I scarfed it down so hard. I WISH I lived here so I could continue to eat at this awesome place… But since I can’t, you can eat here for me!
Totally recommend this place to anyone who wants good food and awesome people.

If the old city mainstay littered with sandwiches-​of-​old, walls festooned with photos of celebrities with the owner, and the SAME things they have been doing since they opened ever go out of style, then I’ll quit at life.
Peppi’s isn’t just a spot for lunch. It’s a storybook opened to the meat of the climax of one incredible story. To say they have «history» would be a disservice. These guys wrote the book from what I can glean from the pictures sports memorabilia. I had the pleasure of visiting while in Pittsburgh this summer and was thrilled with the product and especially the service.
I had a group of kids with me, so I made sure they didn’t have to do too much talking for these fast-​paced guys. We ordered a bunch of fries, drinks, and a mixtures of mains. Some of the kiddos decided to go for comforts (i.e. chicken fingers. Lame) but a few of us went for some menu titans. Namely, The Big Wheeler. Holy cow. Quite literally. Steak and sausage with provolone. Pretty unreal. It was a massive sandwich, too. All of the flavors melded together were like the Blues ancients, all of the Steelers and Pirates players, and all of the Ohio riverboat captains together were giving me high-​fives. It just felt right. Meaty, greasy, melty, packed with flavor, and delightfully heavy. I felt like more of a complete human after having this sandwich.
Though we were all famished from the seemingly manual labor we were doing, I could only make it through half of it in one sitting.
Also, the owner and all of the folks on the line were incredibly nice. They had grace with our group and made us feel incredibly welcome.
Pro Tip: Make sure you have cash for this location. They have an ATM in-​house, but it’ll speed things up if you have your own when you walk in.
If I’m ever in Pittsburgh again, Peppi’s will be a definite visit. Rock on.

I’ve been to Peppi’s dozens of times, and I can say it’s been a rare occasion that I haven’t ordered the #7. Soft, delicious sub roll, spicy sausage, fresh lettuce and tomato — can’t go wrong. I always load mine with a healthy dose of hot sauce as well.
North side location stands out on service alone, friendly group of guys working behind the counter.

Amazing subs. Incredible atmosphere. Friendly service. What more could you ask for? Get the Cajun fries with your order and dip those puppies in ranch! Peppis, get’cha peppis!

The sandwiches are great with a good amount of meat. We also tried their Cajun Fries which are deliciously spicy.

Essence of a good hoagie is that fresh bread with a lil flaky crust and just the right crunch to compliment that gooey goodness it holds.
Perfect bread. perfect amount of meat and seasonings. very reasonably priced.
Not 5 star as the meat is a lil too salty. we tried the spicy sausage and sicilian .both had meats that were a lil too salty to our liking.
Craving a real hoagie hoagie!!! not that «i am so fancy that I will leave you guilty yet hungry» good for nothing sandwiches?? i suggest head here.

The Roethlisberger is the reason to go here. Quality every thing any time I went. Consistent service and taste as if these guys are robots. I’ve had lots of fresh cut fries but something about theirs that makes them stand out. The whole experience makes this as important to eat at as Primanti’s.
Remember to go to the one on the North Shore. Excellent flavor and excellent service with options for your atmosphere.

Peppis. well known sandwich shop in the burg. I just started a new job in the North Side so couldn’t wait to go back to Peppis. I remember visiting the strip district location often many years ago.
I stopped in and ordered a steak hoagie. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Cash only — no credit cards. There is an ATM in the restaurant just in case you don have any cash handy. I was surprised at the very little meat on my hoagie especially by the price $ 6.75. I might just order double meat next time. Another surprise was that there is a burger called «#7 Roethlis Burger» which I love the idea although I have never had. but ketchup brand offered is not «Heinz» brand. I love the menu. so many different types of sandwiches, salads etc. there is something for everyone.
These were just observances. my steak hoagie was good and satisfied with the great customer service.
I just visited recently during lunch time at Noon. As soon as I got there I regretted it but soon realized «it was all good». The staff was so cool and calm and on the ball. it was a zoo and the line was out the door.

SETTING:
Seems like a lot of Pittsburgh sub/​sandwich/​hoagie places have a similar ambiance. Peppi’s is no different, but it separates itself from the rest with its SUB-​stantial flavors. Wooden benches/​booths and walls adorned with photos of interesting characters. Laid back place to grab a quick bite.
FOOD:
First time here, so I decided to go with their most famous sub: «The 7». The description wasn’t kidding when they called this sub a juggernaut. Loaded with ground sausage, egg, american cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, and mayo, the «7″ – aka the «Roethliburger” – delivered the perfect pass. A tight spiral down the chute and into my stomach. Touchdown, baby! It’s THAT good, not to mention filling. Ain’t nobody got time for SUB-​par hoagie pokey.
The fresh cut fries are pretty solid too. Don’t be fooled, the small size is plenty big. If you’re here with another person, I would recommend sharing one sub and small fries. Yes, the fries are a bit greasy, but let’s be honest… you’re not here because you care about eating something «delicious and nutritious,» you’re here because you want to devour a monstrous sandwich and have fries with that!
SERVICE:
Order up front and you get a number that you put on your table. Seat yourself. In 10 minutes or so, your sub will be brought to you, and it will SUB-​consciously change your life. Friendly staff all around.
IMPRESSION:
I’d definitely come back again to try their other subs. Gotta be in the right mindset though. This is for sure a heavy duty lunch. As of now, my sub/​hoagie ranking is as follows:
1. Peppi’s
2. Uncle Sam’s
3. Primanti Brothers
How many more SUB-​liminal messages and hints do you need? Go get yourself a sub at Peppi’s!

Visiting Pittsburgh last weekend, this is the first place I had to try. Mainly because of The 7 aka «The Roethlisburger». I may not live in Pittsburgh or anywhere near it, but being a Steelers fan, Pittsburgh is definitely a part of me.
Walking in this place, you’re greeted by at least 4 – 5 employees while you check out the big board/​menu. When you’re ready to order, you order, take a seat, and they bring out your food not long after. I ordered The Roethlisburger along with an order of Onion Rings. The sandwich came with american cheese, sausage/​burger, and egg as the primary ingredients. I told them to put everything on it so it came with tomatoes, lettuce, and I believe a few other things.
I wish we had sandwiches like this in Louisville. From the bread all the way down to the smallest ingredient… the sandwich radiated freshness. The onion rings were fresh as well. Definitely the type of onion rings that have started disappearing over the years… the kind you bite into and with the bite you sometimes pull the onion out with your bite.
I could easily make this place a regular stop if I lived in the area. My only complaint & I won’t take off a star is they only take cash. Luckily they have an ATM inside, but keep in mind that it’s cash only. I understand why businesses do this, but if I was going to open a business… I’d take card, cash, bitcoin, whatever payment that someone wanted to give me.
Since I don’t live in the area, I can’t become a regular, but I will make it a point to visit everytime I’m in Pittsburgh.

I give the steak sandwich (The Special) with peppers and onions 4 stars. One of the better in the city. But the music they play here coupled with the good food moves me to 5 stars. I’m a foodie and musician so this place warms my warm Pittsburgh heart. Its also home to the Roethlisburger which is essentially a heart attack hoagie. It’s also cash only yinz so leave the plastic at home.

Don’t yinz native Picksburghers hate me nah, but I have to admit that I didn’t find Peppi’s that impressive. I’m from DE, where we have Capriotti’s (can you say fresh turkey and all the fixins on a bun?!?) and are near Philly (a sub mecca), so I have high standards for subs. Also, I pride myself on being an exacting – yet fair – reviewer. In light of these facts, I’m afraid that Peppi’s failed to deliver the sub nirvana I was hoping for.
I visited on Sat. for lunch with a friend while cycling. Our original plan was to hit up the food trucks at South Side Works, but she was tired due to some grueling rowing practices the previous couple days, so the North Shore is as far as we made it. She suggested Peppi’s, and I agreed, given that I’d heard good things and that I hadn’t been yet.
Since I don’t eat beef, I was limited to two options: the amazing Sigfried or the turkey supreme. Both were very similar, consisting of their respective meats plus grilled mushrooms and onions and LT. I opted for the turkey, probably because I’m so used to the turkey awesomeness on a bun that Capriotti’s delivers. My friend ordered the roast beef, and both of us had drinks. Although my friend told me the fries were good, we decided to forego them because we thought it’d be too much.
When I bit into my sub, I was underwhelmed by the amount and quality of meat, which was a thin layer of deli-​style turkey slices. To me, the sub seemed to be more then 50% veggies, most of which was lettuce. I also found the bun too light for my taste, since I’m used to thick, bready buns. While the taste was decent, it didn’t blow me away, and texture-​wise, it wasn’t super-​interesting, given its composition.
While you get a lot of sub for your money and it’s better than Subway, if Peppi’s is the best PGH has to offer sub-​wise, they have a ways to go. At least Primanti’s has a unique product! I know yinz’ll hate me for saying this, but perhaps you should go to Philly – or even DE – for some sub-​inspiration, n’at.