Eddie’s Irish Pub

I’ve eaten there twice during my travels to the area and both times been pleased. Yesterday, they had a catfish filet sandwich on special that my dining companion thoroughly raved about and I had a Eddie burger which totally hit the spot and was prepared perfectly. It got a little busy and they had one server only, but we still managed not to wait too long but did have to chase down the ordered beverage she’d forgotten. I’d say along this route in Prairie du Chien, this is absolutely the best place to stop for a quiet, enjoyable meal!

Service was pretty slow here, BUT the burgers more than make up for it. Seriously, come here, get a burger, you’ll be happy. The menu at this place is 99% not Irish, but the decorations are really beautiful, and seriously, the burgers… Wow.

My favorite lunch spot when traveling to PdC for business. All the of the burgers, sandwiches and wraps have been great! Try the homemade chips for a nice alternative to fries. Service is always very friendly.

Eddie’s Irish Pub. It’s a gimmicky sports bar. Food is decent. Onion rings seemed hand battered. Steak fries were similar to oreida brand. I had the pub burger with cheese. They offer american, cheddar, swiss, and pepper jack. Nice to see a couple real cheese options. I had mine topped with bacon, which was nice and crispy but not over done. Onion and pickles. And they were not shy with the onion or pickles. I’m talking 2 full onion slices, like a third of an onion. And 8 pickles. The pickles tasted as though they may have been homemade. One of my kids got the classic burger and fries, which she enjoyed. And my oldest got the TBLT. She really liked that. The service was pretty good considering it was packed and there was only one waitress. I never received my refill. Though she realized it when she brought the check and offered to give me a to go cup. I would have been irritated if not for the fact they were clearly understaffed. Actually, I was irritated, though I couldn’t rightfully take it out on her tip as she was genuinely doing the best to serve more than 50, perhaps 60 people, alone.

This is a «do not miss!» Loved the ambience, friendly and good service, and the sandwich and sides were delicious!

Came in for lunch today. Came around 2, so after the lunch rush. Prices were very reasonable. I ordered the blue cheese bacon burger and it was really good. Service was rather prompt. I’m not sure if the waitress was just trying to get us out of there or just overly friendly but she said have a great weekend like 3 different times. Biggest complaint is that there’s only 1 stall in the bathroom. Seems dumb for a bar, lol.

Couldn’t tell you about the food. My family put our order in and waited 45 minutes before being told they forgot to put the order in with the cook. We were there for an early lunch with few patrons so we were very surprised by the error. We still had to pay for our drinks which is a joke. They could have handled it better.

Great food at great prices! Love the bar also!

I came here to meet a few of my coworkers around 6:30pm in a Tuesday. There were a bunch of cars parked in the small parking lot, but we still managed to find parking. The place was not busy with only a few handful of tables with people sitting. The interior was not bad and I remember seeing a lot of wood interior. We sat at a booth near the bar which accommodated our group size nicely.
The menu had a lot of choices and I was pretty hungry. I ordered a 16oz glass of Guinness ($ 4.75), the Cheeseburger in Prairie-​dise ($ 8.69), and small Pub Fries ($ 1.69). It took a little while later before our food came out. The Cheeseburger in Prairie-​dise was a half pound burger which didn’t appear to be the case but I just looked at it too quick. It was pretty good when I added all of the toppings on the burger including the thousand island dressing. I finished the burger with ease then started on the Pub Fries. Those were in a small basket and was about the right portion to go with a burger. They were steak fries so that was good. I also tried a piece of Eddie’s Choice Wings which were only okay in my opinion.
I thought this pub was a good place to grab a few drinks and food!

Apart from the name and the Guinness signs there was nothing that struck me as Irish about this place. The interior and exterior décor is good and at least the place has some atmosphere, but the choice of just four entrées was very disappointing. I opted for the fish and chips, but was then somewhat taken aback when the server asked me what kind of potato I wanted with it! When I suggested «chips» she seemed rather confused. While the service was OK, the servers seemed largely disinterested and made you feel like you were being processed through a feeding machine. Sorry, but there is nothing Irish about that!

What struck me as Irish about Eddie’s Irish Pub?
Well, they serve Guinness and the name.
Otherwise it seems to be a bar/​restaurant with the typical burgers/​pizza/​apps mix. No Shepard’s pie or whatever.
They serve several InBev favorites as well as local up and comer Potosi so all is not lost. And they offer a 20oz version for times when a pint just won’t do. Guinness come straight or half & half with a number of beers.
The servers are friendly and we received our order in good time with no hassles.
Sláinte

Eddie’s Irish Pub isn’t particularly Irish, but they get high marks for service, reasonable prices, and one of the better steak sandwiches in recent memory.
The décor is split between typical Irish ornamentation and sports bar accoutrements, including dartboards and a pool table. The menu is similarly confused, with fish and chips among the sole attempts at Irish cuisine — you won’t find shepherd’s pie or other authentic favourites listed. Beer list is American macrobrews or local beers with the token Guinness and Smithwicks taps — no Harp, Bass, Fullers, Boddingtons, etc. on tap.
The clientele appeared to be a mix of tourists and tradesmen, whose plain white work trucks and vans dominated the lot. Tradespeople usually means good cheap food, and while it wasn’t dive-​bar-​cheap, it was really reasonable. I had a very nicely prepared, medium rare steak sandwich for ten bucks, a side salad for three, and a huge order of potato wedges for another three. Add a few bucks for a pint and I was out of there for twenty bucks, totally stuffed.
My server was attentive and prompt, bathroom was nice and clean, place is clearly well kept. All in all, Eddie’s is a really decent American sports bar masquerading as an Irish pub.