Johnny’s Pizza Stone & Pub

Good food, good service, good experience. I would recommend to my friends. The atmosphere is nice on outdoor deck.

everything would have been ok if i didn’t come home smelling like a pizza oven, which oh by the way, they don’t have. bad ventilation!!!

Good pizza, excellent service, awesome happy hour prices (4−7pm). I would definitely come back. I was a bit leerly after reading the reviews but I’m glad we decided to eat here anyway. We had the final four chicken pizza and a Cesar salad. Both were good.

After a couple of disappointing experiences earlier this year, I have been back to Johnny’s 3 times since the end of August and all three times, they nailed it. Pizza was great, salads were fantastic, and the service was spot on.
Tonight (a Friday), they were packed and they didn’t miss a beat. I’ve noticed they managed to retain some of the waitresses over time… a good sign.
Show these folks some love, Prosser! Winter is coming on and we need a good, reliable place to enjoy a pizza, beverage and game.

I’ve been going to Johnny’s for nearly a year a couple of times a week. The staff and owner are great people and the pizza is some of the best around. They have become good friends to me and I really enjoy the family atmosphere. Welcome back Tosha!
From the injured finger guy!

There was a group of us staying at the Wine Country RV Park down the road. Decided to walk to Johnny’s for some dinner. The food was great and so was the service. They even accommodated us by giving us separate checks. We’ll be back.

It seems like the same thread running through this place. Simply, bad wait staff and under appreciating their customers. The food is pretty good. Once it actually gets to you. Came in to order to-​go, stood at the counter, waited patiently while the waitress helped the people Behind me and the couple who came up to pay their check. Ugh. Unfortunately, the Chinese place next door was closed (my 1^st choice, AWESOME food and EXCELLENT customer service). We’ve been here only 3 – 4 times in the last 2 yrs (we LIVE in Prosser) and their customer service is always bad. It started out strong. Family owned/​operated? If you have plennnnty of time to kill… Literally, one of the only restaurants I don’t leave my usual 20% tip.

My husband and I were staying at the Wine Country RV park down the road We really wanted some pizza but after reading all the negative reviews I was a little wary. We decided to just go for it and were glad we did. Waitress was very friendly, no issues there. We made it in time for happy hour which has $ 3 drafts (they had about 8 to choose from). Pizza arrived after about 20 minutes. Pizza was SO GOOD! Glad we went and if we are ever in Prosser again we would definitely come back. I had to say something because I don’t understand how this place could have so many bad reviews!

We went today for lunch. The waitress was friendly and talked really fast. We had pizza, clam chowder, basil tomato soup, salad, buffalo wings, penne with Alfredo sauce, artichoke sandwich, beer, and soda. We enjoyed everything we ate, it was good. The one thing that we said wow to was the tomato basil soup. That was good! The Alfredo was a bit pricey for the amount that we got but it was good. The only thing I didnt like about our visit was when I told our waitress that the water tasted kinda metallic (like very hard water unfiltered) and that the soda also has that same taste, she kinda snapped back at me telling «well nobody else complained about it all day» so I told the owner. I think it was a great place for lunch and we will be back. For dessert we went to sister sister and had some of there amazing gelato ice cream. A must in prosser!

Don’t know about the pizza but service is awful. We were seated, the table behind was seated, they ordered drinks, we’re served and had their dinner order taken. The staff walked by us like we did not exist. May be a great place if you are friends, if not go next door.

I came in around 430 pm on a Saturday. Only 2 other tables were sat. My friends ordered a small 2 topping pizza, it literally took ONE HOUR AND 15 minutes! Insane and a joke. Will never go back.

My wife and I went here one night after going wine tasting in the Lower Valley one day.
We got there and it seemed a bit busy. We waited for about 5 minutes before seating ourselves since they seemed to be understaffed as well.
The waitress finally came by and took our order after about 10 minutes. We ordered one pizza. Half meat, half vegetarian.
15 min later the waitress came back to retake our order because she forgot what we ordered.
After an hour of waiting we finally decided to just leave. We walked up to the counter to pay for the drinks that we did get and leave. The waitress finally pulled out a pizza that had meat on most of it.
We told her we were leaving and didn’t want it because it took so long, it was made wrong, and we had to leave. She said it was fine that it had meat on it because she was just going to give it to us for free.
Needless to say we will never go back. It looked like it had potential too.

I’ve been here a few times. The pizza is good and the service is friendly enough, I make no bones about that, and if you like their menu items as-​is, you might have better luck than I. Unfortunately for me, I’m picky, and there are certain things I don’t care for on a pizza. Today’s adventure was over onions.
They brought out my pizza and I found onions on it, having asked for no onions. I sent it back. The same pizza was then sent back out to me, and the waitress was apparently told to tell me that there were no onions on the pizza. Believe me, I wasn’t sending it back just to be a jerk. I would have much rather had it right the first time, eaten it, and had time to do other things with my lunch hour.
I found a different one without even trying, and sent it back again. I waited and ate the replacement pizza, then found out later from the cook that she had dumped onions on the first pizza, and then picked them back off. Apparently, she would rather accuse customers of lying than acknowledge that she might have missed some. On top of that, they offered me a free dessert for my trouble. Fine, that might have helped a little bit. if they hadn’t come back and told me they were out of the one I wanted. You couldn’t have figured this out ahead of time, huh?
Anyway, I won’t be back. If the cook can be that dishonest over onions, there’s no telling what she’ll put on my pizza the next time she sees me walk through the door. (I shouldn’t even have eaten the first replacement pizza, but I was there with my whole department and didn’t care to walk out on them.) I was happy to keep coming here occasionally as long as they made it right when they screwed up my order, but the last time I went will remain the last time I went.