Tony’s Pizzeria

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza an order of poppers and 2 lbs of wings. I have never ordered from a restaurant with employees as rude in my life when the food arrived it was horrible wings were raw pizza was so bad the dog wouldn’t eat it. The poppers were still partially frozen… DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS «pizza parlor» you would be better off with frozen grocery store pizza…

Tony’s pizza is by far the best pizza in New York only problem is there like 5 tables.

I love this place, BEST pizza in Rome, hands down. I moved to Rochester last year and can’t ever get it but I miss it so much. Nothing compares to it out here. You know it serves good pizza because like the other review, it seats maybe ten people, it’s cheap, and the pizza is a big size. Love love love Tony’s! Soooo good. Try their hot sauce too!

Altogether a TERRIBLE experience. The food quality SUCKED. Customer service was RUDE. The place was DIRTY.
I don’t know what is wrong with all the people giving good reviews. Maybe they like soggy pizza, rude customer service, and a dirty restaurant. I tried it because they said the price was low. «Best in Rome», they say. HA! I have tried many pizzerias in the area and I have to say that this is the worst pizza I’ve eaten anywhere.
The toppings were clumped in areas and had very little in other areas. There were parts of the pizza that had way too much cheese and other parts that had barely any. There were a few times I got a mouthful of sauce. Parts of the pizza was just crust (not the outside). It was undercooked and soggy. The pie was quite large, so they cut it into square pieces. I still couldn’t try to pick it up to eat it, so I had to try to eat it with the plastic fork that I had to get up to get for myself. I was given a paper plate to eat on, and as soggy as this pizza was, I had to really work to not eat part of the plate.
I have a family of 5, and we don’t want to spend $ 10 on drinks, so we typically order one large drink and share. They only had tiny cups, and he wouldn’t let us share. With us having 2 drinks, we filled up about 4 times each.
The floor was noticeably dirty, the tables (picnic tables) were sticky to the touch. The only high chair was filthy.
I tried to be friendly with the guy who took our order but he didn’t even say hello, just stared at me until I told him what I wanted.
For a pizza and two drinks, we spent about $ 20. For the amount of pizza we got, I guess it was a good value (not considering its quality).
With so many other choices, I can promise I’ll never choose to eat at this place again. Go over to La Roma, it’s only a few blocks from Tony’s. The food is MUCH better and only maybe a dollar or two more expensive.

Best pizza in Rome. Possibly the cheapest too. Fold up chairs and tables, seats about 10 total. A true local Roman experience.