Times Square Pizza & Bagels

Delivery time was reasonable and food was warm at least, but I didn’t receive my entire order, and considering it was a full salad that’s slightly frustrating.
Chicken alfredo was definitely not that great — probably should have gone with pizza or something with bagels.
The pizza bites were okay. Nothing special.
Probably won’t be going back.

Thought we would give this place a try since we found a coupon on our door. I ordered the pizza online and received an email telling me my order was received and would be at my door in 25 – 45 minutes. After an hour without pizza, I called and was told it was in the oven now and would be on the way shortly. An hour and a half after ordering my pizza it arrived. Pizza is supposed to be quick and easy. This was neither.

Best delivery pizza I’ve had, not the best pizza but most great pizza places don’t deliver. Would definitely order again and would love to try their bagels.

Pizza has good flavor but several things went wrong here for my hotel room delivery on a Tuesday night. I ordered the meat lovers using the EAT24 app. First, it took almost an hour and a half to get the order. When it came, I had to surgically place some of the toppings back on. That wasn’t too difficult as the cheese cold and pretty stiff from having sat for so long. All in all, not worth $ 27. Might want to consider picking up your own.

I love this place! This is the goto pizza delivery for our office. Always cordial and courteous on the phone and the «NY Style» Pizza is bomb!

Got the Brooklyn Bagel but switched out the bacon for sausage. Sandwich was very very good, it was huge! Very nice guys behind the counter. Highly recommended, my nephews that came with me loved the bagels!
I will be back

I placed an order for delivery, the guy who took my order must’ve been new since he got my order wrong and overcharged me. I called back to find out that a different guy had then informed me that prices went up and he fixed my order; strategically when they sent out a flyer a week earlier of their old prices.
***Heads up, all prices have gone up on every item.
They also said it would take max 40mins to deliver and they showed up an hour and ten mins later.
**be prepared for long delivery time.
2 stars because the food was great but definitely not worth their new pricing and delivery time.

I had their breakfast and it was not even close to New York. Pizza is good but the breakfast sandwich uses cheap bacon and fake eggs… That alone is the whole reason you order a sandwich! I mean I can understand the bagels not being the best but at least use a quality product. I won’t have their breakfast again but I’ll return for pizza.

The delivery we ordered was on time and still warm — but the pizza wasn’t very good compared to the other places around us in UTC. We wanted to try something new, but don’t think we’d get the pizza here again. The guy was very nice and they got the order right (a large hawaiian), it was just plain and rather unseasoned. Almost as if the crust had no time to proof before it was baked.

First, let me say the pizza itself is quality, good NY style. Flavorful sauce, crisp, thin crust, big slices meant to be folded. We ordered a Hawaiian in large and found the ingredients to be refreshingly tasty. I also ordered a garden salad which while not fancy, was crisp and fresh. My issue is definitely not with the food itself.
Yesterday we placed our order at 6 PM — again one large pizza and one large salad. The time estimation said we would receive it within the hour. At 7:30, starting to wonder where our food was, we called and were told they had gotten a little backed up but that he (person on the phone, Mario) had seen to loading up our pizza for delivery just minutes before and it should be there very shortly. I specifically asked if it would still get to us hot and was reassured it would.
At 8:20, nearly another hour later, the delivery guy called saying he had arrived but apparently wanted me to meet him downstairs on the far back side of our condo community. This isnt a short walk and I let the guy know that his choice of location made it impossibe for me to just buzz him in. He seemed confused enough that i didnt want to argue and just went down to meet him. Once i did, I moted that he brought the pizza and not the salad. His excuse was that they were in such a rush to get me the pizza they forgot. A rush that still took a total of two hours and twenty minutes. As penance I at least got the pizza for free.
Back upstairs we opened up the box to find a rock hard, ice cold pie. Now we are seriously irritated — not only did our food take well over two hours to arrive, when it did half the order was missing and what was there was ice cold. I called to inform management and was told (again by the same fellow as before) that they would go one step further by replacing the entire order for free any time we want. Since the pizza (once re heated) was really very good, we decided to give it another go the next day. Everyone has one bad day, right?
Fast forward 24 hours to today. I place the order again. Again I ask to PLEASE make sure the pizza is at least hot and I am reassured that it will be. An hour and fifteen later the delivery guy calls. AGAIN, he comes to the far backside of out complex where I cannot let him in despite being told otherwise the day before. This time our salad was there (small victories), but not surprisingly the pizza was rock cold once more!!!
The big bummer here is really that we liked the food, but if it can’t get to us in a timely manner or at the very least be hot, what’s the point?

We recently went back to Times Square Pizza and ordered two pizzas. The pizzas were just as good, if not better, than the calzones. The cheese pizza had the perfect ratio of crust to sauce to cheese and the large size was big enough to eat on for a couple of days.
My boyfriend’s pesto amore pizza was loaded with fresh veggies and he had no complaints.
I’ll definitely keep Times Square in mind for future pizza cravings.

I live in Del Mar Heights and there are very few pizza delivery options. Honestly, this is a big deal to me to the point that I almost moved (ridiculous… I know… but I LOVE PIZZA). Luckily I came across this place on Unilocal.Not only is the food fantastic here, they are amazing with delivery service. Always on time or early, and the food seems to be right out of the oven. The NY style pizza, the calzones, garlic knots, anything made with meatballs, the chocolate lava cake… it’s all great and very affordable. Friendly service, delicious food, excellent prices… this place is a no brainer!

Definitely the best pizza in the area! I’m a picky pizza eater and I would go here any day, no questions asked. At work, my colleagues always get Papa John’s or Oggi’s and I cannot stand either… Give me some Times Square Pizza instead!
The staff is super friendly and their check-​in offer was a bomb! I haven’t tried the calzones yet but all pizza slices were delicious and the bagel sandwich sampler were very good too.
This place is located at the very corner of the food court, is open late, and has free delivery! What else could you ask for?
Thank you, guys! Keep up the good work and see you soon again :)

Bagel Sandwich review.
Harlem Deluxe Bagel Sandwich
(Egg, ham, Muenster cheese, Jalapeño, red onion and cream cheese)
The taste is there, a wallop of flavor in fact, but I think choosing a strong bagel flavor like garlic was a bit too much. Something to think about when you make your bagel choice. The sandwich was also particularly messy with the cream cheese melting all over the place. The red onion was probably something I’d not include next time. As a whole, It was a good tasting sandwich (after picking out the onions), but I’d choose something else next time.

The pizza was good and so were the greek salad, pizza bites and garlic knots. I like that they gave you marinara with your pizza bites and garlic knots. We had delivery which was on time and friendly.
Was impressed they delivered all the way to us in Carmel Valley.
I would order again. The bagels look like something worth trying so that might be the next taste of Times Square for us.

Ordered a calzone, some garlic knots, a large soda, and a few bagels. Was about $ 21 and they gave me a free extra bagel. Have yet to tear into the food, but wanted to leave a review simply because the guy at the counter was so friendly. He even offered to refill my soda when my food was ready. Will update with impressions on the food once I get home.
UPDATE: I will definitely be eating here again. The garlic knots are quite good. Soft on the inside and slightly crispy on the outside. There were 6 (though one was twice the size of the others) and I ate 4 without even thinking about it. Ate a quarter of the calzone and realized I’ll easily get 2 – 3 meals out if it. The ricotta is very creamy, not dry like you often get in lasagna. I like ricotta both ways, but creamy works better in a calzone. The dough was very soft, but thankfully not undercooked. The sides of sauce had a little kick to them and didn’t appear to be very chunky (I don’t like it chunky). I assume it’s the same sauce they put in their pizzas.
When I first looked the place up and checked out their website, I’d assumed they were a regular sit-​down restaurant. It turns out that this location is in a little food court next to a bunch of office buildings. However, I would call the food restaurant quality.
Why not 5 stars? Because I’m stingy and reserve a 5 star rating for the particularly awesome places. This place was very good though.

Date of visit: July 28^th, 2015
A pizza place serving New York-​style pizza (i.e., thin crust) in a food court that isn’t Sbarro’s? Color me intrigued…
I had a Groupon for $ 20 worth of food for $ 12 that was set to expire the day of my visit last week, and as I didn’t want it to go to waste, I got over to Times Square Pizza & Bagels as fast as I could. Surprisingly, this place inside the Sorrento Towers food court stays open until 9pm Sunday-​Wednesday (and until 10pm Thursday-​Saturday), making this one of the few places in that mall that serves those late night Qualcomm workers.
Anyway, I was told that I could use the Groupon, but I had to one-​shot the whole $ 20 amount first. So, I got the following:
Garlic Bites ($ 3.99) — An order of six bread bites; these are made with parmesan cheese, pepper, paprika, olive oil, basil, and garlic so fresh you could feel the bite. With pizza sauce to dip into, these were a worthy appetizer.
Combo #6 ($ 9.99) — This is a slice of pizza (I ordered their NY Supreme: pepperoni, sausage, red onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, oregano, & garlic), five wings (choice of buffalo, BBQ, or plain — I chose plain), a bag of chips, and a fountain drink. To round off my order, I added a second slice of NY Supreme ($ 3.50 for a single). The pizza was excellent, with a nice, crispy crust to both slices. Although, I should’ve ordered the wings with sauce, as the plain ones were a bit on the fatty side.
Smoked Salmon Bagel Sandwich ($ 5.99) — This was my lunch for the next day; the combination of the smoked salmon, capers, red onions, tomatoes, & jalapeño cream cheese on an onion bagel (which was still chewy!) made the people next to me in our office cafeteria envious as I was enjoying it.
I’d like to try some more of the pizzas, and Times Square Pizza & Bagels’ breakfast offerings have me wondering what those are like. Hopefully I can stop by again to try them.

My friend and I came here for a deal that I found. I was a bit skeptical when I discovered that this place was in the middle of a food court. Not only that but kind of separated from everything. Seems like the main business was the offices nearby. However it was much more than just a lunch place! The people were ridiculously friendly and helpful. The food was really tasty! Not only that, but it was at a great price. I would love coming back here. They were really nice about having one pizza, split in half with two different bases for pizza sauce. Normally places refuse to, but they were great about accommodating my order.
BBQ Chicken Pizza: A pizza with a crispy crust all the way through? Count me in! This BBQ chicken pizza was a bit different but amazing either way. The tangy heat and saltiness from the BBQ sauce was nice since it added a nice depth of flavor. The sliced banana peppers added a nice heat and tang that I didn’t expect but enjoyed. The tomatoes were sweet and the chicken chucks were tender and juicy. The onions added a nice flavor and crunch.
Pesto Amore Pizza: Another crispy crust all the way through! Woohoo! The pesto sauce had a nice basil, garlic, olive oil, and Parmesan flavor. The broccoli was nicely cooked, the wilted spinach was a nice touch, and the roasted red bell pepper was tasty. For a full vegetable pizza, this was one of my favorite ones. Usually I apt to add grilled chicken, but this is wonderful as is!
Lox Sandwich: A nice tasting smokey flavor that was complemented by the creamy-​ness from the cream cheese, the fresh slices of tomato, the crunch from the sliced red onion, and the nice saltiness and tang from the capers. This was similar to what I make at home minus a few ingredients.
Overall, this was an amazing find and I was glad that there was a nice deal too! Though I’ll easily come back here for more good food and great service without it because the price is great considering what you’re getting. I can’t wait to come back here again for some crispy thin crust pizza!

I’ve been here on two separate occasions. Here is what I ordered:
Visit 1: 6-​piece buffalo wings w/​blue cheese, and 4-​piece pizza bites
Visit 2: Tandoori chicken bagel sandwich, slice of NY pepperoni pizza, and 6 piece buffalo wings
As you can already guess, the buffalo wings are scrumptious. They are served piping hot, with a great texture and plenty of heat from the sauce. Luckily, the blue cheese dressing cools them off!
The bagels are OK, and the sandwich is definitely not their strong suit. However, being a New Yorker, I can vouch for the relative deliciousness of their pizza, as well as their pizza bites: cheesy, pepperoni, rolled, and ready to dunk in marinara sauce! The pizza is thin, with the right crisp and plenty of cheese and pepperoni.
All in all, this place is definitely worth a visit!

HUGE, stuffed bagels. My favorite is the Manhattan Joy sandwich within a jalapeño cheese bagel for breakfast. Their bagels and cream cheese spreads are delicious. I am stuffed after eating half of the sandwich in the morning. It just means I can enjoy the other half at lunch. Seriously reminds me of the East Coast and makes me miss living there despite frosty winter days & nights.
Their customer service is on point as well. The manager seems to work there every time I order that bagel sandwich in the morning. He’s super friendly and approachable. Definitely a people person! Thank you for having this business open in the morning when I don’t have anything to eat before work.