Cibelli’s Pizza

Amazing food! The white pizza is top notch!
Not to metion the service and the people there are so friendly!

Do yourself a favor… get the meatball pocket. Enough for two big eaters or 3 people if you throw in a side salad. Deliciously fresh dough with tons of cheese and meatball pieces. The marinara on the side was equally yum. It was a slow night and I still waited about 20 minutes. Tip: Call your order in if you don’t like to wait. I noticed the signs for gluten-​free options. I didn’t try it but it’s good to know it’s available.

Very small menu, very small joint… not that great. there are way better pizza places around… Bizarros being one.

The staff seems to turn over a lot, but with that being said I’ve never had a bad experience here. They have really good specials for instance 8.99 gets you a footling slice of pizza, 5 wings, and a draft beer or soda! The pizza is delicious and they are my favorite wings on all of beach side!

On vacation in Melbourne beach area and stopped here for dinner one night. Service was better than excellent. The lady working the register (one of the owners) was working harder than anyone I have seen in a while. Just as nice as can be too. Pizza was very good. NY style. The wings were better than you will get at a BW3s. We definately will be back next year.

Best pizza I’ve had in a 50 mile radius if not more. Super friendly. Great food. Awesome atmosphere. Have nothing to say but good things.

Stopped by here and got some pizza. White pizza was delicious! ! Pepperoni was good as well. Love the crust. Nice service and very fast. Will be back! Way better then other pizza places around here.

We went at noon on Sunday and it was completely empty, so we were a little dubious. We had pizza, wings, and fries. Everything was piping hot and delicious. The staff was solicitous but very chill. Will definitely go again.

The BEST pizza in town with the most generous staff you could imagine and its local! Their salads, wings, and garlic knots do not disappoint. My favorite is the white slice.

We’ve had take away pizza a few times, and it’s been consistently good. Nice flavor, esp the sauce and good crust. I used to be a pizza man years ago, and this is how I would make it. I also like Bizarros Indialantic, but that’s a very thin crust NY style.

ITALIAN SUB… let me start by saying this is a one item review. This Italian sub is, without a doubt, the best Italian sub we’ve ever had… and we eat a lot of sandwiches. The lightly seasoned bread is always fresh and warm. The cold cuts are ample but not overblown. They also have a sauce that mixes with the melted cheese and adds a moist, melty goodness.
We’ve never had anything else here. A friend brought us here a couple years ago for this sub and it’s all we’ve ordered on every visit… often driving 20+ minutes from home past a half dozen other sandwich shops just to get our fix.
Don’t pass it up if you visit.

Simply put… really, really good NY style pizza! Huge foot long slices or up to 24″ pizza. Garlic knots are awesome too. Come here if your at the beach. Kids love it too.

Just had some delicious pizza, wings, and antipasto salad! Wings were crispy and moist. Ask for pizza extra crispy. Just the right amount of cheese, sauce & toppings. Antipasto salad was nice and fresh and had fresh shredded mozzarella. Did I mention the wings were delicious?!

We parked in the back and as we were coming in we noticed the three young kitchen staff and one was clearly itching and rubbing his body under his shirt and then started to prep food

What a gem! My husband had lunch here (a suggestion of his coworkers) and found the food to be quite delicious. They have the best pizza in the Melbourne/​Cocoa area hands down. Their stromboli is mouth-​watering! We also had barbecue wings which we delicious as well. The owner is this really cool guy who looks like Sean Penn. Also, this place is the picture of cleanliness from the moment you walk into the door you notice it even in the restrooms. Soda, water, and or tea are self serve. What I liked the most is that there was a feeling of home.

Not sure why there are so many good ratings.
The pizza by the slice is a precooked 24″ pizza. When the reheated pizza finally arrived the cheese was not typical greasy pizza yumminess. Rather it tasted like reheated day old pizza, was dry (like you see in mud during a drought all cracked) you know like you get out of your home oven.
The salad was HUGE. A large feeds 4 to 6 easily. (It came out 35 minutes after ordering and arrived with our pizza)
The Amber Bock was room temperature, slightly colder I guess.
The wings came out 10 minutes after the pizza (45 minutes after ordering) they made a mistake in the dry erase order forms they use (my order got smudged lol) Didn’t have blu cheese as requested (but said they did and gave me ranch after ordering) They said the spicy garlic parm were the best. Guess that does not consider the fact that they taste like they were rolled in salt and heated in a microwave.
The waitress placed our paper plates for our salad on my phone? Pardon my personal property (and your dripping sweat… Call someone in if you’re too busy to wipe your sweat off)
I give it 1 star because the water comes out of the fountain super cold! Otherwise I would rate zero stars.
I chose this over the burrito shack next door. Big mistake to end my day trip from Tampa on!
Staaaay away unless you know the owner, she was sweet to a few regulars but completely left a conversation with a first time customer to hug and kiss the regulars goodbye. Good way to keep em, how about getting more?
C’mon Unilocalers! Get this shabby pizza joint in line with its true rating! It’s not 4 stars!

I’ve been here a few times and it’s always been good each time. The single slices of pizza are FREAKIN huge and more than enough for most people, I would have to believe. The wings are pretty good. I get the met lovers and there’s always plenty of toppings and the crust has a nice crispness to it.
You can it outside and enjoy a beer while you wait (which is typically not very long). Great place. I will definitely be back.

I came here for lunch with a group from the office. They highly recommended this place and said it was a must while in town…
AND WERE THEY EVER RIGHT!!!
I ordered a calzone with onions, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. It was also loaded with three kinds of cheese. OMGosh was this thing ever huge! AND OHHHHHHHHHHH so tasty!!! I can’t rave enough about how good it was… I would have to say it is close to one of the better calzones I’ve ever had!
Defiantly enough to share!!! …but I didn’t… LOL!
I did see a couple of their pizzas… they looked amazing! Others in my group had meatball subs, and other types of calzones.
I sure wish I could have made it back to try some other items!!!
Next trip!

We enjoyed our stop at Cibelli’s, a real mom and pop pizzeria. A lot of the reviews are arguing whether or not this is real NY style pizza. I didn’t see anything in the restaurant that claimed it was NY style pizza. It’s just pizza. And it’s pretty good. The restaurant is clean and spacious. Be prepared to roll up your sleeves and get your own paper plates and napkins and drink refills. It’s just that kind of place. Garlic knots were fan-​TAS-​tic! The small salad was large enough for 2 and very good. The pizza was hot and not too greasy. Fresh mushrooms are always appreciated at a pizza place and the crust was light and crispy. Also that night they were featuring $ 1 drafts with several beers, including rolling rock, on tap. Give this place a try!

Some guy below wrote, «Marginally better than frozen.» Huh? Oh, and, «The crust was not New York style.» Huh?
Not at all the experience I had at Cibelli’s. Great New York style crust, great sauce, great portions, GREAT pizza. Nuff said.