Imagine Candy

I love this place. The selection, from chocolates you can’t find anywhere else to classics like candy necklaces & Pez, is amazing. You’ll end up browsing way more than you’d expect to… it’s like a cool bookstore for candy!
And the seasonal items like frozen pops are an unexpected treat.

This is a candy store that appeals to adults as well as children. Visibly it is exciting without being overwhelming. The candy is delicious and there is a unique and vast assortment. On top of all that, the owners are so nice very welcoming.

Fabulous shop! So many unique and special items. Not only do they carry excellent chocolates and candy, but several other great items like cool bags, plush blankets, etc. Great place for gifts and favors. Knowledgeable and helpful staff too.

What a fantastic charming and well decorated place. I happened to be around Scarsdale today and few friends of mine suggested to surprise my wife with a box of chocolates. I tell that I wasn’t wrong at all going there. Bill and Donna where very helpful and now they earned a costumer for life. I really recommend everyone reading this review to support this little Scarsdale treasure.

This candy store is amazing! They have every type of candy imaginable and everything is always fresh. The chocolate covered pretzels are especially delicious! Can’t wait to go back!

First of all Donna and Bill are sooooo nice! Given the area and the items that they’re selling, I would have totally expected a sort of «I don’t care» attitude from them but they’re really not like that at all. They’re obviously so into this store and were so sweet even the first time I came in, just to grab a gelato pop for myself and the little one and Bill gave the little one a gummy candy on the house which made for a very happy little one. I didn’t get enough time to look around last time though so I wanted to go again. The gelato pops by the way were amazing. Most intense pistachio flavor ever.
This store is amazing! They carry so many local and artisan products, the kinds I usually only read about (because yes I read about candy) but they’re actually here in front of me to buy. Yippee!!! They carry Big Picture Farms goat milk caramels which are some of my absolute favorite, in various flavors. This is a nice award winning caramel from Vermont and a lovely addition to this store. I highly recommend the original and the chai. The Amella caramels which are vegan, made with coconut milk, and covered with grey salt are amazing. I could eat a whole box in one sitting if I lost control. There was an awesome gluten free rice krispies bark from very close by in Larchmont — local is cool. The Cocopotamus chocolates are amazing. Touted as being in gift bags for award shows. Rightfully so as I tried the Mrs. French which is french almond fudge covered in chocolate and topped with salt, which was amazing. I could easily also eat a whole box of those and will be back for the other plentiful varieties. Along with a few other purchases, like a PB&J bar from Brooklyn and a bar that’s vegan, gluten free and soy free that I plan on eating for breakfast on a lazy day, this was quite the candy shopping experience.
There are a lot of cute little gifts all over the store and they do gift baskets, which is definitely a nice little setup. Perhaps one of my new favorite candy stores. Oh and the wall to wall jars of candy to bag up yourself. Perfection.

Solid local candy store, good selection for such a small place. Gifts are expensive. Staff is warm and helpful.

I have to say, I was shocked to see this place poorly rated by anyone. I’ve been here twice now, most recently to pick up some chocolates for my dad for father’s day on my way home (in MA) to visit him.
I did not find their demeanor at all off-​putting, and they were very willing to talk about ingredients and where everything was coming from (I’m a huge fan of the fact that they source from locals and so was asking a lot of questions in this regard). In fact, «they» were more than willing to help and asked me what I was looking for right away.
Unlike some reviewers, I actually find it charming that the man’s daughter was there. She was not rude, and it shows me that it’s a family business, which is very important to me because some chocolate places in the area have a really stiff, don’t-touch-anything atmosphere. If someone is so «customer-​oriented» (I call it self-​centered) that you don’t find a guy sharing time with his daughter to be sweet, I don’t know what to tell you. I never felt my experience suffered as a result.
That being said, the chocolate was also delicious and exceptionally smooth. Will continue to make it a point to stop by!

Great service, candy, and atmosphere to be around. One of a kind candy decoration and great music too. A must visit if you’re around the Scarsdale area.

I’m pretty sure this place just opened up a few months ago, but it’s definitely worth a visit! I went there with my girlfriend and another couple to pick up some chocolates for after dinner, and the owners were VERY friendly and helpful. Everyone agreed that the candy was just amazing, and we’ll certainly be shopping there again. It’s not really on the «main» street, but it’s worth the effort to walk over the extra block! I just hope more people find out about this hidden gem!
I’m a bit surprised that they held parties there, but we’re already looking into having an event set up by them.

Imagine’s candy is always fresh and it makes a huge difference. Everything is delicious — best chocolate covered pretzels I have ever tasted — it made me realize that I probably had eaten stale pretzels in the past. The staff is friendly and does a beautiful job gift wrapping. You can also order customized gifts. My daughter received the chocolate shoe for her birthday and loved it. For the kid in all of us they have jars and jars of gummy worms and other delights.