Calvert Manor Bagels

I drove 45 minutes to get some bagels and cream cheese and let me tell you… The bagels are delicious and the creamcheese… To Die For! I ordered the Funfetti cream cheese, Raisin/​Walnut cream cheese and Sundried Tomato/​Scallion cream cheese. MOUTHWATERING!!! Not sure why some people did not enjoy this place (must have been a bad day), but I loved everything I got. Oh! I also enjoyed the Bialys. Light and tasty.

Probably the best bagels around. Unfortunately I can’t say the same for the service. Maybe I expect to much. Some people might say, what do u expect from a bunch of young kids ?? They ask for my order all at once even though it’s a large order. When I get home its always wrong. One or two bagels at a time people. Not 5 or 6. BTW don’t order any cold cuts. The salami looks brown or grey in color. Does anyone look at their foods or salads in the window ?? Just got home and there is no hash brown on my sandwich and I didn’t ask for a whole wheat hero. Thx for nothing. Thank god I looked in the bag before I left. She didn’t even put it in the bag or charge me for it. I’m so done with this place.

Without a doubt, the best bagels around! Can’t beat the quality and on top of that, their prices are reasonable. The only negative is the wait. This might actually be a positive as their volume of business keeps the bagels fresh. Best everything flagels around, but they tend to run out early during the weekend.

the bagels are some of the best around. I will go out of my way to get these bagels and most of the staff is friendly. I get an assortment of sandwiches and bagels. the bagels are always delicious, whether it’s an everything or a French toast bagel. I love that Calvert sells rye sticks– that’s a rare find nowadays.
the only problem I have is that the workers tend to be more interested in their own conversations than helping the customers. I have, on more than one occasion, waited over 20 minutes to order.
it’s also frustrating when there are four workers behind the counter and no one is helping customers.
overall, I continue to come to this bagel store because of the quality and quantity. the prices are more than fair and I have never complained.

Good bagels is all you need from a bagel store and that is what they have. If the service is slow it seems to me its because its crowded and that’s a good thing. Nice solid bagel store,

No complaints about this Long Island Bagel shop. We walked here a couple of times from my brother’s house. They have a great variety of bagels and cream cheeses. The bagels are just as a bagel should be light and fluffy. I had a toasted everything bagel with sun dried tomato cream cheese the first time and the second time I had an everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. The jalapeño cream cheese had pieces of chedder cheese in it whi ch was yummy. They give you a generous helping of cream cheese, maybe a little too much for me, so I just took some off.
Service was quick and efficient and prices are right!

Not the best, not the worst.

For Long Island, this store is such a disappointment. The service is terribly slow. I was second on line and by the time someone even acknowledged a customer, the line was out the door. The servers kept walking back and forth and not making eye contact with the customers like they didn’t want to be the one to take an order. Then when we ordered 4 bagels with cream cheese it took around 15 minutes before we were handed 4 bagels sloppily wrapped in paper and covered in cream cheese. We had to ask the lady to put it in a bag because she was handing us 4 stacked bagels with cream cheese all over her hands and the bagels. Also, when we asked our server if she could speed it up because we were trying to catch a train, the lady at the register interjected and directed her not to go faster and to keep working at her own pace in a very loud volume which was very awkward. I should have walked out.

This is the best place for bagels in North Massapequa IMO. Whenever I am visiting the area, I want a bagel from here. I had a bacon egg and cheese on an egg everything bagel and yum! They have good veggie cream cheese too (if you’re into that).
There is usually a little line, but definitely worth the wait.
Most of the bagels are nice and soft, but if you want the best one, ask which ones are warm and they will feel them and tell you which ones came out of the oven most recently.

Really good bagels (with a hard shell which I like) with a nice selection of cream cheeses and other spreads. Used to work in the area so I ate here often. The everything bagels are my favorite. One of the best shops around.

when you grow up in a jewish home on long island, you can’t help but become somewhat of a bagel connoisseur… having sampled offerings from dozens of bagel places over the years, it has become very easy to spot what i like & what i don’t, and my aging ass can be extremely picky, i’d say 8 out of 10 spots i have no desire to return to because their bagels frankly suck
here in massapequa there just aren’t any good bagel shops, so typically I will make the drive to bellmore for LI Bagel café since they are by far the best in the area… unfortunately time constraints limited me to the neighborhood today, and since I will not go near that garbage place on broadway that everyone seems to love I chose to give Calvert Manor Bagels a shot as I was already in the shopping center… to my pleasant surprise, they make a pretty darn good bagel — not quite LI Bagel Café but definitely a solid product at a reasonable price & with some pretty friendly folks behind the counter… I will definitely try them out again in the future to see how they hold up

Cardboard with seasoning is the best way to describe the bagels here. If there is anyone out there who knows how to make a decent bagel this area is an open market. This place is packed all the time and everyone agrees it really shouldn’t be.
Nice staff but slow.

Best hot and fresh bagels! I come from East Meadow to Seaford.

My favorite bagel place hands down. Nothing compares. Service isn’t that slow as the other reviews say, it honestly just depends on what time of day you go. It’s especially popular in the morning I would guess between 8 – 10 and during lunch time. It’s busy but that’s a good thing, bc it tells you how good those bagels really are. If the food wasn’t worth it then nobody would be willing to wait on those lines.

This is pretty solid bagel joint. Decided to re-​visit this place while stopping in to the old neighborhood.
I can honestly say that this place established the standard for which all other bagels shall be judged for me 20 years ago. The interior has changed a bit from back then but the bagels are still amazing.
Back then this was a very simple bagel joint. You walked in, two fridge cases on the right with butter, cream cheese and eggs in the case.
The’re were less then eight types of bagels to choose from back then.
I’m glad this place didn’t change along with the surrounding businesses.
Place is a classic example of the perfect mix of «doing it right» and «keep doing it»
Place is awesome.

I only go here because there isn’t anywhere else to go for bagels by me. The service is TERRIBLY slow. I waited on line for 10 minutes today and had to leave because I had an appointment to get to, bagel-​less I might add.
Everyone on line was getting frustrated.
They only had two people behind the counter, a line out the door and it seemed the staff didn’t really care that everyone was sitting their WAITING and just took their sweet time tending to everyone. It was just ridiculous. They just moved so slowly.
I really wish there were a decent bagel place in this town.

I’ve been going here for 10 years and noticed in the past year or so that the bagels are smaller and not as fresh, and this is on a Sunday morning so I would figure they would be very fresh. I hope that they go back to their old ways because lately I have been driving to Bellmore to pick up my morning bagels and Calvert Manor is a short walk from my house :/

best bagels on long island? i’d have to give that to A&S in franklin square but calvert manor bagels does a pretty damn good job. bagels are great, and their vegetable cream cheese oh my god, i dream about it.

My favorite bagels on long island, hands down. No one else reviewed it so even though I am an out of towner, anyone looking for a bagel place on Unilocal in the area should see that it has 5 stars, at least for a little while.
And Unilocal,fix the map thy places it on Jerusalem ave.