Geno Nottolini’s Pizza

The food was absolutely freezer burnt they ask how everything was we told. them they did nothing about it. Tasted like cardboard. Garlic cheese bread was only two small slices not even enough to to serve 2. The combo appetizers were only for onion rings 6 verry small breaded mushrooms 3 mozzarella sticks which also were freezer burnt. Pizza was burnt. Never again!

We came to town for a visit and odered for delivery this was by far the worst spaghetti I have ever had the noodles were overcooked and watery the suppose meatsauce disgusting, my daughter ordered the fettuccini woth alfredo sauce. She said the sauce was unflavorful and nasty and watered down. She didnt finish it because it began to make her nauseous. She wouldn’t try my spaghetti just because of the way it smelled. We found it to be a waste of money.

The pizza is great when HOT. When delivered not so hot. Why??? Hope you guys at Genos can fix that. Pizza took an hour, it seemed to be sitting a half hour then delivered.

I ordered one 12″ cheese at 9:40 on a Monday night. It was estimated to arrive a full hour out, and in an hour it still hadn’t arrived. I called for an updated ETA at 10:50, and the man who answered the phone refused to give me one. He just said it was «on the way». After another twenty minutes it arrived (I was located 13 minutes away according to Google Maps) — not very warm, and not what I had ordered. The pizza itself was not that great.

It’s pretty good… sometimes. I have found their pizza is really hit or miss. Some times it’s great, wonderful homemade tasting crust, hot, good toppings. Other times it is a hot mess. Would totally order all the time if they were consistent in their good pizzas, as it’s the only one my husband and I can agree on. But not sure we’re gonna order any time soon as it’s too inconsistent, and you don’t know what you’re going to get.

Depends on the day. Some days it’s delivered hot. More often it’s late and cold. Not many non chain options deliver here so they’ve been our go-​to option for years. Have finally had enough of them and their horrible customer service. Frozen pizza from here on.

good pizza, VERY good cheese. I wish a few of my other favorite pizza joints would use a quality cheese like this place does. 4 stars

Good food, fast delivery, reasonable prices. We ordered dinner at a hotel, and were told up to 1 hour until the food would arrive, but it was there in less than 30 minutes. I don’t know what they charged for delivery — no where does it say free or indicate a cost. But the total wasn’t bad, and food was very good.

This place is located in the old Dairy Queen building in downtown Port Washington. We were very excited about the place at first and got delivery several times. The food has always been delicious when ordering delivery and it’s better than just pizzas. Port Washington delivery is hard to come by.
We’ve gone there to eat with a large group of our family members several times and the service is less than adequate inside the restaurant. The place is clearly run by a small family which is nice but the restaurant itself is lacking. They have the same paper menus in the restaurant as they stick to your pizza boxes on delivery but they didn’t have enough paper menus to go around for our group of 9 so we had to share. They also only had about 3 naps in our napkin holder on the table so we had to get them from another table which also only had a couple so we had to go grab them from a third table.
One time when we went they told us they were out of all pastas but then they still had the stuffed shells and pasta primavera that we often order so it was no big deal to us. So the next time we went we called ahead to make sure they had everything we wanted. They assured us that they did but then when we got there they said they were out of alfredo sauce which several of us asked about.
IDK if it were my restaurant and I knew that I had a group of 10 people coming in who CALLED AHEAD to make sure you had something… I would make sure that I had it when they got there. If I ran out, I would book my booty to the store to get some more.
I digress, the large menu and option for delivery make this place awesome but it’s not much to be seen to eat there. stay home and enjoy this in your livingroom!