5 Bewertungen zu The Tavern At Shelter Island House
Keine Registrierung erforderlich
Sam C.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Oakland, CA
Had the prime rib sandwich, which has prime rib, Gruyère cheese, caramelized onions, and French dip on the side you can dip the sandwich into. It was pretty good. However, most of the menu was overpriced. The prime rib sandwich I got was $ 19, which wasn’t too bad, but that was the cheapest thing on the menu other than the $ 18 burger. The other entrees tended to be over $ 25. The chicken pot pie, for example, was $ 26, which was oddly only $ 4 less than the NY strip steak.
Yezid A.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Manhattan, NY
Loved it does much the first time I had to go back the next day for the short rib. The staff was amazing and friendly and greeted us like we were one of the locals. Overall it was a great experience and would defiantly recommend it.
Gavin P.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Fun place, we were visiting for a night but made to feel really welcome! It’s almost like a home bar, particularly if you sit in the room with the fireplace. Don’t let the fact that there aren’t many options around fool you, this would be a great bar wherever it was!
Maria G.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Fair Lawn, NJ
They took my order 15 minutes before they closed. Fries were fantastic and the bacon cheddar burger was equally as delicious. They also have brochures and random things to look at, so I took a free map of the island. Nice little touch. Seems like these people know what they’re doing visit here
Daniel K.
Rating des Ortes: 4 New York, NY
We enjoyed dinner very much. Pros: –Solid food –Solid service –Great local wine selection –Nice outdoor seating Cons: –Can’t think of any Favorite items: –Salted caramel gelato –Caesar salad with duck –Mussels