P&G Pizza and Deli

Amazing pizza great people. This place is a hidden gem out east. All of the bad reviews are made by people too weak to belong on Long Island. Coming back here every time I’m out east.

I live in the Hamptons all season and I’m considered as locals here. Living in the Hamptons area and being a resident here means I’ve almost tried every restaurant and pizza places around east and southampton.
I personally never order in from this place as I’ve always had the worst experience with the employees of this pizzeria, like whenever you go there they stare at you like you owe them $ 1Million, these people never smile at you (smiling at customer’s stands for number 1 rule of restaurant business) which you never get to see in this place. Stuff they sell like garlic knots and pizza is always made with an old dough or either has a disgusting smell.

Long story short: about two weeks ago, right after the Labor Day, I’ve had some important guests from West Coast visiting the Hamptons and staying in my place, it was raining and we decided to order stuff for delivery. I called half hour before they were closing and the person on the phone was extremely rude, I’m guessing it was the Owner of the place as he is very popular in Southampton for his disrespectful attitude to his customers. It took them about an hour to make couple of pies and after an hour and a half we finally received our pizza. Everyone was starving and very excited to finally eat something, so imagine you open up a box of pepperoni pizza and find a DEAD SPIDER on it. I tried calling them but nobody picked up the phone, I GUESS this is THEIR WAY of TEACHING LESSON to CUSTOMERS who happened to ORDER A delivery HALF HOUR BEFORE CLOSURE !!!
NEVER EVER COMING ACROSS THIS PLACE AGAIN !!!

My children and I stopped here on our way to Montauk. My daughter (15 YRS OLD) ordered a stromboli and asked about a smaller item. At that point I returned to the car to my car to give my wife her cold beverage. When my daughter returned to the car she told me the person behind the counter (I beleive the owner of the pizzeria) charged her for the small dough like item. At that point she explained to him she didn’t want the item and that she only inquired about it. His response was well you ordered it and I can’t take it back because I already heated it up. Granted the item was only $.90 he took her money charged her for the item and said it’s only $.90 cents. She came out very upset and couldn’t beleive how she was treated. I too am truly amazed at how someone could treat a customer. Being an owner in the customer service industry I would never give business to a person whom operates his business like this. If he does this to 5 – 10 people a day, it adds up. My advise is go where the owner appreciate s the business and respects customers of all ages.

Great pizza! Deff would come back! Not sure what al these other reviewers are talking about service is great I love Richie and Julie they always have smile and joke to crack! Worth the stop!!! Great garlic knots and Heros! Meatball parm on garlic bread YUM! Awesome and friendly staff! Small eating area but def worth the trip! The house salad with shredded mozzarella cheese and grilled chicken and the house dressing is so so good I get it everytime I go! It comes in a large bowl if you enjoy salad its a must try

The place is dirty, nasty and dirordely. The pizza is subpar. The garlic knots were old. Losing my trust with Unilocalers! Came here for the ratings. Left like I just burned dough. This is a business that it appears that the owners just don’t care.

The best pizza in Southampton! Great service! Hidden inside of Dunking Donuts, it’s great for take out. They have variety of salads and different kinds of pasta and appetizers. I’m definitely going back.

Best plain slice I’ve ever had! Crust is super thin and crispy, the sauce is flavorful, cheese does not slide off of pizza and there was no grease dripping down my wrist.
$ 2.25 a slice is the norm but the flavor is out of this world!