The Sugar Cookie

I found out about this place from a friend. Wow, the cookies are amazing! Wonderful service too!

I guess I was mislead thinking all cookies would be sugar cookie consistency… You know, dryer and dense. While they do have the normal sugar cookies, most of the cookies are the puffy kind, similar to a muffin top? My son really enjoyed their regular sugar cookies. We tried almost all of the cookies they had. My favorite would have to be the red velvet or any cookie with a cream cheese topping. Overall I had to have ordered 9 big cookies and 6 – 7 small ones and i want to say it came out to under 20 bucks… I think that is pretty good for fresh cookies that come in a nifty white box. They also sell the day old cookies for a discounted price, I believe a box is $ 5? The shop is clean and I’d def stop by again.
Side note: Beware of your iPhone map for directions as it lead me astray. It is located across the street from the old navy shopping center behind Applebee’s.

This place is EVERYTHING. These are perhaps the absolute most delectable pieces of divinity that I have had the opportunity to nom. They have every delicious flavor alive and are the perfectly baked, frosted warm gooey deliciousness I could ever hope for.

Their cookies are fire!
The old fashioned sugar cookie
The peanut butter chocolate chip was sesh

Tried the cute little minis, sugar cookie and cherry chocolate. The cookie was bland in flavor but of course the icing was tasty.

I almost feel bad giving this rating as the store was cute and clean. The prices were not terrible either. 20 mini’s were $ 9 or $ 10. But at roughly 50 cents for a cookie that were the size of a dime is a bit over priced.
The cookies did have a light feeling to them and I did enjoy that element. The frosting was well flavored.
I, however, didn’t really find the cookies to taste at all like a typical sugar cookie should. Meaning that they weren’t really very sweet. The cookie itself tasted more of a puffed up flour based cookie then a sweetened version of the cookie-​alas a sugar cookie. While the frosting did have enough of (presumably artificial) flavoring the frosting itself wasn’t fabulous either.
Between I and my 2 kids we only ate probably 9 out of the 20 minis that we bought and that was mostly to try the different flavors that we got.

I used to live in St George and now I live in California but every time I come to town, I stop in to buy some cookies. My favorite is the original and the red velvet. They’re so good! The only reason I’m giving 3 stars is for there service. All they sell is cookies but every time I’ve gone in they act like I’m bugging them or it’s a privilege for me to be helped by them. I know who the owner is too and she acts and looks that way too. I’ve worked in restaurants for a long time and bakeries and I know it gets exhausting but for a small place that just sells cookies you would think they’d be giving it their all to make it. Hopefully things get better before they open their Vegas location. I only come back for the cookies :)

If I’m ever back in the area this will certainly be a place I stop for. Its a cute boutique type store with tthe most amazing cookies inside. They’re not only pretty to look at, they taste amazing as well!!!
If you like fluffy, soft, and fresh cookies with the best frosting ever, look no further!
Plus, Im pretty sure they are a small local business and Im always about supporting that!!!

Great spot to feed the cookie cravings. A bit to find if you don’t know where it is. Just think right behind Applebee’s. Their cookies are so light and fluffy and the icing is incredible. Much better than the dense, stale sugar cookies others sell. Each time we go there, we try something new and are never disappointed.

When a friend told me about this place I was very uninterested at first. My friend however, was committed herself to converting me. So I thought, what the heck, give it a go. I’m so happy I did! :)
The cookies were to die for! It is a must try if you find yourself in St. George Ut. with a sweet tooth! I was very impressed that you can truly taste the love they put into each cookie.
Flavor, amazing!
Texture, to die for!
Mouth, tummy, and wallet, happy!

This is the place to go if you want an amazing cookie experience. The cookies are soft and the frosting is creamy with a hint of almond extract. Every season, new festive colorful sprinkles are chosen to adorn the cookies and seasonal specials are available for a limited time to the menu such as peanut butter blossoms and s’more cookies. All very delicious and worth looking forward to. The prices are great, especially if you purchase larger amounts. I always like to pick up a box of their mini sugar cookies, which are bite size and come in all sorts of flavors and bring them to share with co-​workers or classmates at school. The also have a punch card for frequent customers which comes in handy, after so many cookies, you can enjoy a free one on the house.

Cute and clean store, cosmetically nice product, niche market, good prices.
Unfortunately I didn’t really like my purchases: large regular peanut butter, two mini frosted in chocolate cherry and chocolate peanut butter (~$ 3). Large cookie had very light flavor, and I mostly enjoyed it but BF considered it bland. Also had weird hint of cinnamon to it? Frosted minis had excellent frosting but cookies themselves were almost too moist, and nearly had a guminess to them that we did not enjoy.

Sugar and Cookie in the name. You can’t go wrong. Great variety of small and large cookies. Get the original cookie. These cookies are perfect.

The *BEST* sugar cookie I have ever had the pleasure of scarfing down. I will be making a stop here whenever in town from now on, without question. We tried a few different varieties but the coconut and the old fashioned were our favorite. Delicious!

This is a GREAT little find!!! The best Sugar Cookie that I think I have ever tasted!!! They have different flavors of frosting. They have a chocolate cookie that is really good but when compared against the white sugar cookie it falls short, but still very good. I highly recommend this place!!! You won’t be disappointed unless they have closed for the night.

O M G … omg omg omg … the cookies were so awesome — we stopped in and picked up for two different invites over the weekend. Without question — some of the best cookies/​flavors ever. Don’t miss it!

Was staying in town for a few days for work. Came here everyday of our stay. The rolled sugar cookie were delicious, I tried the peanut butter and sugar. The girls I was with tried the old fashioned and they kept raving about it. I also really enjoyed the chocolate coconut! Just go and try them all :)

We love The Sugar Cookie! They have something for everyone. Creamy, fruity, chocolaty! My favorite is the double chocolate.
The owners are super cool and willing to make sure your next party or celebration is fully stocked with delicious sugar cookies.

On a day trip to St. George from Las Vegas I looked up yummy places to get some treats and I saw the newly opened «The Sugar Cookie» — Pictures looked yummy so I knew I had to experience this new delicious storefront for myself…
Right when we walked in the lady at the cash register was helping someone, there was one person ahead of us and then soon after that 2 more girls walked in after us. So, I would call the traffic flow steady but not by any means crazy… I saw 3 employees and not one of them welcomed anyone of us: No– Hello, No– We’ll be right with you, No– we will have more cookies coming out soon (the display case looked rather empty). We got a little smirk from the lady at the counter but no other smiles from anyone else– I kinda felt like we were bothering them.
Maybe it was too busy and they felt overwhelmed– IDK — but for a new buisness (or any buisness) they need/​should be more welcoming…
I have been to many places where the line of customers are always out the door and we still get a H E L L O ! ! !
On to the cookies– they were sure yummy– soft and chewy. They had 3 flavored basic sugar cookies — butter, chocolate and red velvet. Those cookies are then topped with all kinds of their frostings– flavors include: Vanilla (which had a strong almond extract flavor– YUM!!), Cherry (with real Cherry bits), Lemon, Peanut Butter, Coconut, Chocolate, & Cream Cheese for the red velvet cookie.
Prices were fair and I liked that smaller cookie bites were an option.
I have no complaints about any of the cookies — I would love to see more fruity frostings like Mango, Pineapple, Orange, Strawberry or even Marshmallow or Pistacio but I’m sure in time other flavors will be added or featured for a bit depending on the season.
***Please Mr./Mrs. Sugar Cookie put seat covers in your restrooms***
The cinammon roll looked yummers as well– I wouldn’t hesitate to visit The Sugar Cookie again when in St. George. Could the cupcake revolution be over? The Sugar Cookie is sure giving cupcake shops a run for their money…