Lorenzo’s Pizza

The pizza was bland, tasted like a defrosted frozen pie and had some of the worst cheese I have ever eaten on a Long Island pie. After eating the pizza, it gave me horrible bloating and gas pains, as well as constant gas bubbles (burping) for hours after.
My mother got a horrible stomachache from 2 slices of Sicilian and my father debated simply throwing the entire order out. He commented how they had eaten at Lorenzo’s before, so I am surprised just how BAD the pizza was. Both a plain pie and a Sicilian pie… plus no wonder the pizza is so cheap, it was more like a medium pie than a large pie and there was so much dough I could have eaten a few slices of bread for less carbs… Honestly, I don’t think I could ever eat their pizza again knowing just how bad it was…

Pizza is HORRIBLE! I should have went to supermarket & bought a box of Ellios instead. What a waste of $ 9.75. My dog didnt even like it. Very unfriendly worker or owner as well. Just because you have a crappy job dont take it out on the customers. I will NEVER go back there again & will tell my 100 coworkers in smithtown not to go there.

BRICK OVEN PIZZA!
I am for one never crave for pizza. If it was served at events, I would eat it, but never would I ever suggest getting pizza until I tried this location. First time I went here is during after practice and one of my teammate mentioned to get pizza there… good prices and it’s good. She wasn’t lying. They have many toppings to choose from and if you want to get per slice it’s $ 1.25. My teammates and I decided to get the all meat toppings and of course I said please add mushroom. The mushroom made it complete and my teammate agreed. They had wings/​boneless wings with a list full of toppings. If you love spicy you have to get the ghost pepper sauce. It’s not on the list but you can still get it. The owner will give you a warning because coming out of my own mouth, this sauce is spicy and I love it. After trying this place few weeks ago I end up craving for pizza and especially their wings. Oh so the wings, we got spicy bbq which wasn’t spicy but very favorable. I enjoyed it and usually I don’t tend to like bbq flavor sauce. And also got garlic which was also tasty but I enjoyed the spicy bbq better. Annnnnnd I got ghost pepper sauce on the side because my teammates couldn’t handle the spice.
So today I finally had a chance to pick this up. I originally was planning to get wings only but couldn’t help but purchase a slice of bbq chicken and asked them to extra toast it. The pizza once again turned out very good. I like how he asked me if I wanted more toasted or not and pleased how toasty my pizza was. For wings I always get the one with bones… taste so much better that way. Boneless ugh dry! Lol this time we got it without the sauce and have the sauce on the side to dip. I got the ghost pepper again because hubby wanted the most spicest which I would as well and I got the mango haberno. I asked for it last time but they forgot to give it to me. Is it worth minus a star? I think not. But I am glad I got to try it now. Sweet with a kick. Very favorable. I definitely need to come back because there’s a lot more sauce to try.
Note: they also have fried desserts.

Incredible pizza at most likely the best price on Long Island. Huge pizza lover here and the thin crust pizza that this place has is the best. Very nice and accommodating owner and yes the place is really small, but it is your typical New York City style pizzeria and pizza. Price can’t be beat and service is also very quick. Definitely recommend this place.

Tiny pizzas and not a nice owner. With so much St. James competition you should make sure to be nice to customers. If your food is mediocre but you aren’t nice — no one will come back.