A & S Pizzeria

It’s pretty convenient that Flagship brewery has their menus, since they serve no food of their own. I’m pretty happy with the pepperoni and would recommend it to a passerby.

We are at this pizza place on a whim a few days ago and I’m glad we did. We really enjoyed their cheese and pepperoni pizza, my husband liked the slice of buffalo chicken pizza that he got. I also tried the Caesar salad slice and wasn’t as fond of it, but my husband really liked it. It doesn’t say anything about this on the menu but they also serve Italian ice and it was delicious and refreshing! The staff were all very friendly and helpful. When my family picked their pizza slices and got our drinks the owner (I assume) had us go and sit and enjoy our meal before paying at the counter, he said «you might want something else.» It was a small thing but very appreciated as we were all so tired from walking around all day and my kids were hungry. My favorite part was being able to feed my family, drinks and dessert included, for $ 22!

They are kind of average. Sometimes they have good flavor, and sometimes they are bland. Quick delivery though, and inexpensive. I seek more flavor so I seek out other pizza places often.

This is the pizzeria that my parents used to go on dates when they were teenagers. I remember coming here as a little boy many times for that authentic NY pizza experience whenever my family came to Staten Island to visit family. It’s still my parents pizzeria of choice on the Island to this day.
I must say that their regular cheese and pepperoni slices are the bomb. I highly recommend that’s what you get when you come here. My most recent experience I ventured out and bought a slice of chicken parmesan and bbq chicken ranch and the taste left me disappointed; personally I wasn’t a fan of the consistency of the chicken. Moreover, I should have just stuck with what I knew what was good, because you can never go wrong with a standard slice of cheese and/​or pepperoni in New York.
Service here was very friendly, they were more than happy to answer the questions and accommodate the needs of my family and I, and they all really seemed to enjoy their food, which is important, if we go out to eat you gotta treat my family right. All in all this place it «A-​OK» with me, stop by for a quick lunch if you ever find yourself in Staten Island.

I live near Clove Road and cannot get consistently good pizza, or they have bad ratings from DOH. I saw a recommendation here on Unilocal for A & S, so I gave them a try. I have been ordering from them for about 6 months now, and the food (no matter what I order) has been consistently good-​to-​great. I would highly recommend this place, fast delivery, nice people. I order online never had a problem.

Worst food on Staten Island, by far. I’d rather chow down on the diarrhea of a diseased gutter rat than eat at A&S Pizzeria again. I live a very short block from this place but ordered delivery because the weather was bad, that and they love to shove menus under my door non stop, so I figured they wanted my business. Anyway, my bf and I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a spaghetti with Italian sausage. First off, it took them nearly 2 hours to deliver these things one freaking block down the street. Outrageous. And when we do get the food, the pizza is as cold as ice, no exaggeration, it felt like they just took it out of the fridge. We didn’t even take a bite after touching it, I called them and demanded they fix it. they sent a new pizza a short while later and it still wasn’t hot. Either way, it tasted awful. It tasted like they got the recipe from a 5 year old. No flavor, no seasoning, tasted like dough and nothing else. Needless to say it went in the trash, where it belonged.
Even worse was the «spaghetti» we ordered. It was warm enough, but that didn’t matter, it was atrocious beyond words. The noodles were WAY overcooked and felt like Jell-​O pudding. The sauce was non-​existent, it was so damn dried out, like it had been sitting in an open bucket for days and had partially evaporated. And this Italian sausage… omg, it had the consistency of burnt rubber, and tasted like it was reheated in the microwave 30 different times, then left under a heat lamp for 15 years. I’m not even trying to be funny, it was really that bad. It was inedible so it also went in the trash. I pretty much starved that night, and that was a freaking $ 30 order. I don’t know how this place is in business. Either people on this island have no taste buds, or they get all their business from the crackheads around St. George. It ought to be a crime to serve food of such a poor quality. To anyone out there who says they like their food… remind me never to go over to your house for dinner.

Sent me zepolis with no powder on them. If you don’t know what zepolis are they’re like a pastry drenched in powdered sugar. But there was no sugar on mine. We tried calling and they argued with us calling me a liar and cursed at us and then hung up. They’re food is stale and isn’t worth the rude service.

It was very good pizza I will deffintletly get it again when I go bavk to staten island

1^st of all — great service. Second of all the price is riiiiight! I got a Modelo and a buffalo chicken slice for $ 5. Best. Deal. Ever. Not to mention that every time I order a buffalo chicken pizza it’s never as good as it is in my imagination. This slice is what dreams are made of.

I frequent this place because the service is fast, friendly & the prices are fair. With that said, there are certain things I prefer here & certain things I avoid. The plain original pizza is lackluster & leaves a lot to be desired. The square/​grandma/​specialty pizzas are much better. Some of the special pies they make are interesting, whereas some have quite a bit going on (ie chicken ceaser salad pie) when you just want a simple lunch. The salads are good & made to order. In short, if you know the menu, this isn’t a bad spot at all & has a good lunch crowd.

I love these guys, they always make the best food on any day of the week. the food is always made as good as the last time, I have been going to A&S for 30 years now & they are still the best. I have never had a problem with them & if I didnt like something about my food they simply fixed it, such amazing service. I have been to pretty much all the pizza places on Staten island & the worst in service is napoli on victory blvd, the best is A&S. the only guys that are not sicilian or italian and make great sicilian & italian food, the only other pizza place that came neck & neck with these A&S guys was rays near cebra but he shut down and I think moved away. I believe they even knew the guys from a&s. well anyway A&S is still the best pizza place in Staten Island NO CONTEST. I would not have anyplace to eat if A&S pizza wasnt around. KEEP UP THE GOOD FOOD MAKING A&S YOU ARE GREAT.

Have been ordering pizza from here religiously since I can remember, literally. Any time I’m hungry, we order from here. Pretty sure they know me and my entire family by now. I don’t order much else except the pizza but I absolutely love it and rarely order from someplace else. Despite others reviews, i know for a fact that i’m not the only one who feels this way and most people in the area order from them. Delivery is always fast and the prices are perfect.

The pizza was edible, barely. The price was right but I would not go back. The pizza tasted old and stale.

Not bad grandma slice, but regular slices are too chewy. I only came because I was in the area and forgot my wallet and needed to eat something cheap. I am a big fan of grape fountain drink and to my surprise they actually have a grape drink by snapple that’s only 79cents! Score! So, I had two slice and my drink which was 16oz. Total was $ 5.05, not bad at all. Since I will be in the area again next time I will stick with the grandma slice which I enjoyed more.

Nice, clean, polite, reasonably priced. The pizza was great. We also had the Philly roll which was really good. Enjoyed!

If you are starving and this is your only option, then I guess this pizza would do. If not, then going somewhere else is your best bet. I got a pepperoni slice and it was average at best.
My sister and I were getting pizza. We were hungry and wanted to eat it right then and there so we asked the guy to not make it too hot. There is nothing worse than trying to bite into pizza and burning your tongue. Sure I could just wait until the pizza cools off a bit but I’m hungry and I don’t wanna wait! So the guy puts it in the oven and walks away. After a few minutes we remind another lady working there about our pizza. She takes it out and it’s scorching. Too hot to eat without burning your tongue. Then we hear the lady saying to another customer about the same pie our slice came from, «This is pretty hot already do you want me to put it in the oven?»
So mediocre pizza and extra hot because the guy working there doesn’t pay attention.

Sorry to say worst buffalo chicken roll I’ve ever had. Maybe because its Sunday night maybe because they were closing in a half hour. Both ends were so hard as rock the cheese on the inside looked like it was reheated twice. I order pizza from almost every pizzeria in the area and this by far had to have been the worst. This is what I get for trying something new. Oh yea I feed it to my dog and he just looked at me.

We’ve been coming here for 6+ years. 5 stars for great customer service, reasonable price, a great selection of pizzas & pastas! Get a white slice… sprinkle some crushed peppers and ask no questions!

I LOVE New York pizza! Thin crust, and for me, just a plain slice or two. No need for pepperoni or sausage or anything else. I want the perfect cheese to sauce balance… and a hint of oregano and garlic. The bottom of the crust needs to be dry and maybe the teeny-​tiniest bit charred. This place came pretty close. The slices were possibly a bit on the small side, but what can you expect these days for two bucks? Service was quick, although not overly friendly. All in all not a bad little place to stop for a quick lunch before stopping at the Staten Island Museum on a rainy Tuesday afternoon (p.s. The museum is FREE on Tuesdays from noon until 2 during the summer. Cute little place).

The meatball hogie was great and it was a good, healthy portion. Each time I’ve come for a slice I’ve always liked the pizza.
The front-​end girl is always smiling, which is a rare thing to find in New York, even rarer in Staten Island.
Yay! I’m a fan.