Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

The frozen yogurt was pretty good, I got three flavors, cookies and cream, brownie batter, and wedding cake. They were all good, all low fat, my favorite was wedding cake. They had a pretty good selection of fruity and sweeter flavors but they could have had a few more flavors. The topping bar was pretty standard, it was at least pretty neat and not sticky like they tend to be. You put your whole concoction on a scale and pay by weight. I filled my cup most of the way and had a few toppings and it was 6 dollars and change which I found reasonable. Worth a trip if you want some frozen yogurt.

Go there all the time, I really like it but what’s with the tip jar since you’re making your own yogurt?

Great fro yo but very expensive. I had some cups that cost $ 9, thats a lot considering its next to mcdonalds and they have sundaes for just $ 1. There flavors are good and have recently added smoothies in self serve style.

Great frozen yogurt place on this side of the island. They have a cute setup inside with bar-​like tables. There are fresh fruits to pick from and they aren’t overly priced either. The summer time here can get pretty busy. Especially at night. However, don’t fall in love with a flavor they have new ones coming in all the time. The staff is super friendly and the place is really clean.

Since its been getting cold out for some reason I always want some good yogurt with lots of different types of toppings, I never been to this place before so I decided to try it out with the boyfriend and its a small place. Very plain inside too theres like nothing on the walls or even like tables or chairs, it was kind of depressing. Nothing like popped out making it just look enjoyable honestly, which I didn’t like cause I usually would go to the RED MANGO when it was in New Dorp and it was just colorful tables and just nice setting and ready to enjoy yogurt.
I was also disappointed they had NO FALL/​HALLOWEEN flavors like PUMPKIN! HELLOOOO PUMPKIN IS EVERYTHINGGGGG people.
The worker was not friendly she was on her phone most of the time too so didn’t like that and when asked bout the toppings she had one word answers, so whatever!
Anyways I love yogurt and it was pretty good and I will come back here if its the last place I gotta go too!

I always have a good experience when I go here. Many great flavors of yogurt to choose from and so many toppings. A healthy alternative to ice cream is always a plus. I like the self serve option because you can get exactly what you want.

Cheap, has a pretty great rewards card, and new flavors rotated regularly. I’m all about the red velvet though, always! My only gripe (and it’s a tiny tiny gripe) is that they don’t label what the toppings are and some of them are really just ambiguous looking. Also, I believe it’s the only frozen yogurt spot in the tottenville area, & it’s comparable to my beloved red mango. It ain’t got nothing on 16handles though… but hey now, we are in Staten Island… standards are different here.
Also, open pretty late. Great for munchies.

I like the frozen custard like yogurt here. The chocolate brownie, wedding cake, and red velvet are so delicious.
It’s worth every penny however they give u a giant cup to fill and its so hard not to overindulge… but don’t miss the point of why your there-​to save some calories.

I’m a frozen yogurt fan! I’ve been to my fair share of frozen yogurt eateries. Orange Leaf is the only frozen yogurt self serve location in the southern part of Staten Island, unless you go to the SI mall; And from what I can remember, the one in the mall is NOT self serve.
My likes:
I enjoy the self serve perk of this location!
I can mix and match different frozen yogurt flavors!
I can choose to fill my cup as little or as much as I like!
I can choose to put as little or as many different toppings on my fy.
I love that they have chocolate and caramel syrups! AND FLUFF!!!
My dislikes:
The toppings do not taste fresh. The gummy worms/​gummy bears/​gummy anything are hard as rocks, the fruit taste like they’ve been sitting out for days, the marshmallows are so stale and hard they can probably chip my teeth.
I’m not crazy about the fy flavors. I think it’d be better if they added more fruity flavors to their frozen yogurt selections such as raspberry, strawberry, mango, etc.
Keep in mind, you’re paying by weight. So the more you pile into that cup, the heavier it gets, and the heavier it gets, the deeper in your pockets you’ll have to dig.
All in all, I feel that if they kept their toppings fresh, and spruced up their frozen yogurt flavors, I’d be giving more stars! I hope Orange Leaf management are taking this as productive criticism, and makes the necessary changes to not only better their business, but to keep their current customers coming back for more!

I was brought here by my mother-​in-​law and step-​father-​in-​law when they were taking care of me following a surgical procedure.
This is self serve low fat frozen yogurt with unlimited toppings.
Usually, I can tell when something is fat-​free or low-​fat. The two flavors I had were brownie batter and wedding cake. Both were delicious. Just Delicious.