Tally Thai and Sushi

Best sushi ever. My boyfriend and I go every Friday for date night and have never been disappointed. I always get the Trust Me roll, and without fail, always have people ask me what my work of fishy art is. Small place but great staff and AMAZING food.

Good food, I ordered a pad see ew w/​shrimp take-​out, it was delish. 3 stars for such a small place. When I dine — in we’ll see

I can’t believe good sushi and Thai exist in tally! Stopped by here on a drive home and surprisingly it was packed full of college students on a Sunday evening. The staff were really busy but still managed to get our food to us quickly. We ordered a beef salad and it was very refreshing and the beef was tender. Did the $ 18 roll to let the chef make whatever he wanted and that roll was so huge it toppled over after leaning so much from the weight. Too bad this place is 2.5 hours away from where I’m at or I would always come here. I’ll be sure to stop by again next time I’m driving through. It was a nice atmosphere and lots of smiley faces from the customers. People were coming in and getting take out as well. Definitely have some good business. Would recommend this place to anyone in tally.

Solid if unspectacular Thai food. I ordered the tom kha soup and pad see ew. I got both items medium spicy, but the flavor tasted closer to mild for me. I will order hot next time. For what it’s worth, the parking lot is a hell hole, and I had to park across the street and dart through traffic. Still, it was worth the trek, and I will come back.

I love this place. There are plenty of Thai places in the area, but this restaurant tops my list. Although they have all kinds of Asian food, their Thai food are fantastic. The papaya salad (hidden menu item, and a Thai local favorite), pad Thai, couple other pads are my favorite.
The Thai ice tea and fried ice cream are nice too. Plus the location and price point makes it an amazing choice. Parking can be a mess during busy hours, but be patient as the spaces churn quickly.

It just started out with a «trust me». Wow! Every single time since it’s a party in your mouth! I think my fave was when they brought out a soft shell, shrimp, something something (might have been avocado) with mango and wrapped in sweet black rice made into a heart. Strawberry on top too. The Thai is also wonderful and of course, had to try the duck. It’s a little out of the way for me, but the drive is worth it. I’m wondering if they have relocated yet? It is very small. I’ve also wondered if the increased volume by the move would eventually lead to inconsistency in these truly artistic dishes. Don’t be fooled by the campus location either. It’s a gem.

Horrible service. Waited over an hour and when the food came out it was the wrong order! Just cancelled the order and left. Never going back.

Seriously??? 4 ½ overall stars for this place??? Sushi was just ok (I had the Garden State Roll). Spring rolls were tasteless. On the plus side, service was attentive, Hubby liked his chicken curry dish & Thai tea was yummy. The place is a bit dingy. But it was late, we were traveling and our first two choices were closed. Tallahassee, you’ve got to have better sushi joints than this?

Pretty good for both the Thai and the sushi. Possibly my favorite Thai in Tallahassee. Usually there is a long wait but if you’re not starving or in a hurry it’s worth it.
Most places-​in my opinion-can’t pull off multi ethnic menus but this place figured it out.

Tally Thai and Sushi is one of the premier sushi restaurants in Tallahassee with their famous ‘Trust Me’ that never seems to disappoint. Located on W Pensacola Street just west of Ocala, Tally Thai is a small yet cozy restaurant that delivers on all levels. With a wonderful staff and a seasoned Chef, Tally Thai provides their customers with neat perfect service. They often have long wait times for pick up due to their popularity, but other than that they are great. My go-​to roll is the Gator Roll (Sorry, Noles) — Spicy Tuna and Salmon, Avocado, and cilantro topped off with Yellowtail, Jalapeños, and special sauce. Unless I’m feeling adventurous, I’ll usually stick to the Gator. Other great rolls are the Miami Heat Roll and, of course, the Trust Me roll. Now with the Trust Me roll, you’re essentially allowing the chef to create a unique roll made just for you with whatever he has at his disposal. While this is always a good idea, it comes with an $ 18 price tag. I definitely recommend Tally Thai to anyone with a hankering for Sushi. Chiyo!

I came here a couple weeks ago looking forward to trying it out. I came with a friend and we both ordered pad Thai, and I ordered crab Rangoon and she ordered a California roll. The crab Rangoon came out first and it was great. Our pad Thai came out next and it was above average. It had a nice flavor. My friend asked about her sushi, and the waitress said it would be out shortly. We ended up finishing our pad Thai and the sushi still never came out. She asked again and they said the chef was about to make it. It appeared as though they were short on staff, but I felt as though it took entirely too long for a simple sushi roll to be brought out to our table. The food was great as well as the service, so maybe it was just an off day. I would give it a try again, and hopefully I can update my review!

Service: Very Slowwwwwwwww
Order: Veggie roll was made with crab meat.
Food quality: below average.
I wouldn’t recommend.

Came here once when I flew to Tally for apartment hunting.
I wasn’t particularly impressed with either the sushi or the Thai offerings. I actually tried both and thought they were just OK. Service was on point. Nothing to complaint there. The restaurant is located in an area where lots of college kids live. So I can see why it’s popular.
Overall, nothing stood out to me. I’m not sure if/​when I’ll be back because there are definitely better places to get Thai and sushi in this town!

Tally Thai has my heart and lunchtime love. Restaurant is small but you can get in and out on your lunch hour with a deeeeelicious meal.
I usually go for sushi. Lunch special gets you soup or salad with two rolls for $ 10. The rolls are on the skinny side, but tasty and fresh. Miso isn’t overly salty.
If you’re coming with an appetite, you HAVE to start with the Tom Ka soup. Seriously life changing and so delicious.
Their dishes are a much heftier meal than sushi. The pad Thai could definitely be two meals and they offer the option of mild, medium or hot when you order. It’s not uncommon to see two people splitting a dish and a sushi roll, or a dish and soup to start.
Parking can be a bit annoying, but I’ve never had an issue parking at the gas station and walking.
Your best bet for sushi near FSU and always delicious.

I really like this place! Their plates are large and taste fresh and their thai tea is my favorite in town. It is in proximity to two other sushi places, BUT the sushi here is not too expensive and is a MUCH better quality!
Their service is nice and attentive, without being invasive. Our waitress really knew the plates and answered our menu questions.
I love their thai places. I’ve had their Panang Curry and their Pad See Ew, Pad Woon Sen… are very good and you will be fully satisfied. I usually end up sharing it with someone because I cannot finish it even though I want to because it is delicious.
I ordered a Trust Me Roll, they are $ 18 for 10 pieces and the roll can be literally ANYTHING. The waitress did ask me what I did not like and did not want on it and we specifically requested for it to have nothing spicy at all. We were delivered a beautiful roll, but unfortunately it HAD tons of spicy stuff on it. We finished it, but it is hard for me to ‘trust you’ again (lol) Tally Thai!
All in all, is usually a reliable experience that will leave you full.

I thought this place was just okay. I love trying different curries from restaurants around town and came here to try their take on green curry out.
The place was popping and full of people when I walked in, but fortunately there was a table open and I was able to grab a seat right away.
The service was pretty quick though not overly friendly.
I ordered the green curry and it was alright. I still think Thai Place has the best curry in town, but Tally Thai’s wasn’t bad — it’s better than Siam’s. I ordered my curry with extra vegetables and they were plentiful.
Not my first choice for Thai around town, but it is a viable option if you’re looking to try some sushi or Thai around town.

Tonight we were looking for a good place to eat. A group of us from the job site. We ended up choosing Tally Thai n Sushi. now this is a small place kind of cool the way they decorated the place with sheet metal siding stuff. They menu was all over the place with some Thai and some sushi and some kind of American gone Asian dishes. I went with a hangout roll which had some salmon, habenaro, Avacado spicy tuna. The main course was a glass noodles with shrimp and a mixture of vegetables. It all was quite yummy but I would have liked to have more heat. When you order it hot I would like some spice. Another table mate ordered the native way which was supposed to be Thai hot. This should have been fire hot but it was just spicy he said. In all I do see why this place is one of two 5 star restaurants in Tally. Pretty darn good and with some great service. We will be back soon enough.

Four of us went for lunch and it was an instant hit! The Tom Ka Gai soup was very good for starters and enough to share. I had the Panang Curry (my regular for any Thai place) and it was very flavorful with nice fresh veggies. Hubby had his regular for Thai — pad Thai chicken. Very good stuff. Probably the best anywhere in town! The Volcano Roll was a-frikin’-maZing! And the Thai Steak Salad was very flavorful. For lunch this was great!
I can’t wait to go back!

I’ve been to Tally Thai and Sushi a plethora of times, but now it’s time to document my most recent experience.
Last Friday night, my friends and I indulged like kings. I felt obligated to impress the out-​of-​towners, because they are sushi aficionados. And yet again, Tally Thai and Sushi, Tallahassee’s sushi emporium, delivered a knockout meal.
For starters we ordered veggie rolls and ginger salads, staple dishes in Asian cuisine, but the bar is elevated at Tally Thai and Sushi. The rolls were crisp, a perfect balance of veggie filling, with an incredible sweet Thai chili sauce that I could plainly dip my finger in and would still taste amazing. The salads were refreshing, but the kicker (of course) was the ginger dressing; tart and tangy with a hint of garlic made for a tasty compliment on crunchy romaine.
And now for the star of the show. There were six of us in total and I believe there were at least 10 rolls spread across the table… For your sake I’ll just describe mine, the Gator Roll. Filled with spicy tuna, spicy crab and avocado, while topped with white tuna, JALEPENOS, and an array of beautifully crafted sauces. My mouth was hit with fire, succulence and sweetness. It was the most perfectly complex bite and I’m foaming at the mouth as I type.
On previous occasions, I’ve ordered Pad Thai, Curry dishes and even hot sake. Every dish is made with an undeniable attention to detail, a creative sense of direction, and the uniqueness to keep customers lining up out the door. At Tally Thai, you get the highest quality cuisine without breaking the bank. I might start a petition to change their name to «Tally Thai and Probably the Best Damn Sushi in Town.»

We came with skepticism today after seeing a full five-​star average given 25 Unilocal reviews to date. I figured that was unusual, since there’s usually one or two hater reviews that manage to sneak in and pull the plug on the five-​star party.
This is absolutely a five-​stars in class experience. Service was perfect — presentation was perfect — high quality ingredients were skillfully prepared.
I ordered the duck curry and was very pleased. Also, I ordered The Tom Kha Gai which was rich and flavorful.
In advance of it all was a great Uni & quail egg nigiri. Just having uni in stock sets this place apart — in a smaller subset of sushi outlets. (Kiku is the only other place in town that always has it when I’ve ordered it).
Wife had what she characterized as an A+ veg pad Thai. It looked very good!
One peculiarity stood out (peculiar, to us, that is) which was the pop R&B that was seeping out of the audio system. The music was a smidge loud (and, no, I’m not THAT old) and didn’t line up with the fare.