Geisler’s Liquor Store

Worst liquor store ever. Overpriced, mean staff, and the stores in horrible condition both outside and in. The counter guy has to put on his glasses just to make sure my id isn’t a fake. I’d pass this place up, go to gs liquor gallery which is a couple minutes from here, better prices and better people.

In a world full of super stores and liquor chains, Geisler’s Liquor Store is a refreshing break.
The store isn’t huge but I think they make up for it in quality over quantity.
I was really impressed by the selection of local Jersey wines, and think it’s really great that they support the local economy. They had a good deal of Tomasello Winery wines. Perhaps almost half of what I recently saw at one of their tasting rooms. Way to represent! The wines overall ranged from under $ 10 a bottle to some nicer reserve stuff. They have my personal favorite The Starborough Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc has at a reasonable price so I was ecstatic.
I’m a craft beer fan and while the selection wasn’t huge in comparison to some of the area chains, the staple crafts were represented. The seasonality of the beers was totally on point. Pumpkin beer lovers rejoice! Evil Genius Trick or Treat and Traveler’s Jack-O…yes, please! I thought it was really cool that they have a cooler of craft beer singles. You can sample one without committing to a six-​pack.
What really stood out to me though was the service. The associate took the time to walk me through the store and make sure I found everything I was looking for. With beer, wine and liquor available, I’m like a kid in a candy store in a Jersey liquor store so I appreciate her patience.
I had a great experience at a local business, and found a great bottle of wine to BYOB for dinner with a friend.

We used to shop here frequently. It’s a small store with a surprisingly nice selection of port considering the size of store. Go figure.
The space is cramped yet cozy. They have cold beer & wine to go. Nothing super fancy in the cold section though. The wines, sherry etc on shelf are decent. I’ve found some eclectic bottles of liqueurs too.
It’s not a destination in and of itself, but they have a very convenient location. Nice enough staff. Small parking lot.