Jimmy’s Seaside Ice Cream & Gelato

Super helpful with questions about allergies. The kids enjoyed their sweet treat! We lucked out and walked in right before a big crowd. Visiting the area or we would definitely be back!

What an adorable dessert spot in Tybee! Was visiting Tybee Island for the first time since moving to GA and we stopped by after dinner to check out their gelato selection.
It’s a «cozy» dessert shop but it has everything from candies by the pound to delicious ice cream and gelato! Of course we headed straight to the gelato section of the store and was very happy with our choices. I lucked out and was able to try a fresh batch of turtle cheesecake gelato. Typically, I don’t crave chocolate flavored desserts but it was too hard to resist a fresh batch. If you love chocolate and the «creaminess» of any frozen treat, then I’d highly recommend the turtle cheesecake gelato (see attached image.)
Definitely a great location for dessert and we had fantastic service during our visit! We’ll definitely return on our next visit to Tybee!

Small shop with a couple of benches outside for seating.
There’s a decent selection. I enjoyed a cookies and crème scoop on a waffle cone.
Their milkshakes are pretty good and I saw iced coffee as an option, but didn’t have a chance to try it.
Very standard sort of shop, but the product is good so no complaints.

I can’t even remember the flavor I had but they only serve gelato not ice cream or maybe this is their version of ice cream mixed gelato?
It’s the only decent dairy stop I found so I went, had it and already forgot it.

Really cute little shop. The girls behind the counter were very patient and had helpful recommendations. I had the banana caramel praline gelato– it was great!

*Very* limited flavor selection. Ice cream was good but not fabulous. The service was efficient though not very friendly. There is no seating outside and just a few seats outside. The pier is very close though, so you can get ice cream or gelato and stroll down there to walk or find a seat. I wouldn’t go back again.

Freezer broken — there were only ½ the flavors they usually have. The Pistachio was yummy, but a little gritty and I don’t care for soggy nuts in smooth ice cream, but I know that’s expected with a nut cream. I would not recommend unless its HOT and you NEED to cool down.

Seasonal Business! Not open this Season! So the Guy working here told me two days ago when we were here!
I LOVE Great Ice Cream and I go Crazy for Fantastic Gelato — Unfortuantely the Dude (older Asian Man) said they were Closed for the Season! IT was a Hot Day and many people were disappointed AND Everyone needs time off so I do NOT expect everyone to work all the time! Maybe he could post a Sign!
Note to the Owner: : Post Seasonal Hours — Include Months or Days or Dates — Thanks!

This place is right down from the Tybee Island Pier and was awesome. Best Gelato we’ve had in awhile. The wife and I were there for a week we stopped in everyday.