Anthony Pizza & Restaurant

This is a tough review to write. There is so much potential, but it just isn’t there yet. The food is excellent, no doubt, but there are pieces missing. I just ordered 3 items for delivery, there was a problem with all 3. (Wrong dressing on salad, no corn in corn chowder, no fries with sandwich). It’s very disappointing because everything did genuinely taste good, but if I can’t rely on what I’m ordering making it to me, I can’t rely on the restaurant. I will try again and hope for a better outcome, but I will be hesitant.

This is one of those times I would disagree with my fellow Unilocalers and say this is not a place for good eats. I thought the portions were small and the prices were high. I took pictures of my food so you be the judge.
The pizza is super small and thin. Not quality cheese and probably made in a regular over. There was no slight char from a pizza oven and looked like something you buy in your grocery’s food aisle for $ 1 on sale. The cheese wasn’t even melted all the way. For $ 7, I expect a bigger and better pie because I got my own regular oven at home.
I also got the chicken sandwich and that was okay. But I paid $ 1.50 extra for bacon and didn’t taste it on the first half of the sandwich. When I opened up the sandwich, all I see is a couple flakes of bacon. They use bacon bits (bacos). There were 4 waffles fries included in it which was a nice surprise.
It’s also really expensive– a small personal pie that costs $ 1 at the store and chicken sandwich with bacos came to $ 23 delivered. Not worth it.

Fried chicken sandwich is flat out the best I’ve ever had north of the mason-​dixon line. Highly recommend. Fries were good, and thin crust pizza was also excellent. Most delivery takes around an hour for us, and this got in under 30 minutes. Best carryout in our area.

Ordered Pear & Gorgonzola salad w/​chicken & a rib eye steak for delivery. Everything was delicious and the steak was cooked perfectly med rare like I asked. Delivery was reasonable (30 min). I will definitely order here again.

The first time I ordered here it took a while to deliver to the heights but the food was awesome and you get so much for your money. But the next two times (a sunday dinner and a thursday dinner) they were out of everything I ordered and I had to cancel and get my money refunded from seamless… If things are popular maybe they should have more of it? I’d really love to try more of their food but it’s never there.

Brand Italian restaurant for Weehawken and Union City. This is my second visit and I have to admit it is incredible! Fresh ingredients great food, BYOB. Owner has been on site both times I have been here, very friendly and attentive, really wants to make every customer feel special. Only had the meatball sub and pizza so far, meatball sub is amazing! Pizza is thin tortilla type crust, great sauce and cheese, not traditional pizza. Owner says pizza oven is on the way, so let’s wait to review that.
Very happy to see good Italian back in Weehawken!