4 f’n bottles of ketchup for the whole dine in area? Gimme a break. 9 out of 10 items on the menu require it(sides notwithstanding). I wasn’t gonna beg someone else to ‘borrow theirs’. I simply pitched my remnants and left.
Ashley Y.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Valparaiso, IN
Peteys is one of my go to places! It is always not and fresh and has a pretty big selection on their menu for anyone in your family. I have never ordered anything I didn’t like and have always had it made fresh and hot.
Paula S.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Valparaiso, IN
Called at 5PM for delivery order. Was told one hour for delivery. Placed order and waited. And waited. After one hour and twenty minutes, called to find out what happened to our food and was told the delivery person had a problem with his car. Why didn’t we get a phone call? No communication from Petey’s and girl who answered the phone was rude. Needless to say, canceled our order and went elsewhere. This will no longer be an option for us.
Lacee M.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Cape Coral, FL
Overpriced for the quality of food, paid $ 23 for 2 meals(a chicken sandwich and a philly steak sandwich). Food was just«ok». In order for me to go back there the food would have to be a lot better or the prices would have to go down. I ate until I was full and threw the rest in the trash. I had no desire to keep eating. My 15 year old said the frozen Philly’s I buy at sams taste better than the one he ate there. I was hoping that this would of been a nice lunch spot to take my kids too that wouldn’t break the bank but if I’m going to spend $ 50-$ 60 on a meal for the family it sure as heck won’t be here. If they dropped their prices 30% I bet they would be way busier(no one else was in there and it was lunch time) and make a lot more money in the long run. Or, rework your recipes to make your food worthy of the price you’re asking. I was so disappointed by this place.
Cyn L.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Merrillville, IN
I had a gyros meal from there to feed 2 people. It was pretty good. Pitas were kinda small and the sauce that came with was pretty disappointing. The gyros meat was good though, I’d give it another chance maybe have a constructed gyros.
Stu H.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Valparaiso, IN
This is one of those places I can go with my wife and 4 kids and everyone gets something they like. Petey’s has good quality fast food. Some items go over $ 10/person, but most are just under $ 10. They have some cool special items. The current one is the Avocado Bacon Cheeseburger. They have recently remodeled and have added new items to the menu since I was here last.
Paula S.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Valparaiso, IN
We have had some great food from Petey’s…BUT…tonight we were greatly disappointed with our order. Ordered an Italian Beef Sandwich with fries. The price was $ 13.21 for delivery. Opened the order and there was no way my husband and I could share this sandwich … it was puny! Live and learn! Next time we will order a 12 «Italian Beef w/fries from JJ’s.
Gary X.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Chicago, IL
The gyro meat was decent. Some places have it too salty, yet Petey’s was decent. The gyro: I’ve definitely had better. It had some gyro meat, three ½ moon slices of tomato and some sauce on pita bread. The sauce– industrial made, not home made as one would get at a true Greek restaurant. The french fries– ok taste. $ 9 for the gyro/fries/drink combination: too expensive. I can get the same special, and better taste, in Chicago for $ 7. We can say we tried Petey’s and won’t be back.
Tricia W.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Valparaiso, IN
The food is pretty good although a bit over-priced. The fries are great! I’ve definitely had better gyros though.
Lisa H.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Valparaiso, IN
Love their Philly’s! and they are the ONLY ones who are willing to deliver to us in the country! My parents when they come to visit have to eat Petey’s gyro’s for lunch before heading back home.
Eri G.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Paducah, KY
This place has good food. It’s not the best Greek food around, but I’m surprised at other reviews on here giving it less than 3 stars. I think that’s not a fair representation, so I’m going to give it 5 for fairness. I would otherwise give it a 4 star. It’s quick service and atmosphere is relaxing and clean. The amount of food you get for the price is more than reasonable. If they have more tomatoes and other veggies, it would definitely be a deserving 5 star place.
Dan H.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Valparaiso, IN
I used to eat here pretty regularly in college, and have been a fan. What makes this place better than other Gyro joints is that their burgers and dogs are better. Seriously, their double is my favorite fast food burger probably ever.
Daniel E.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Fort Wayne, IN
Think of a fast food, high quality gyro joint. A co-worker turned me on to this place once when heading back from Chicago. I’ve stopped many times since. I even sent my wife directions as she’s heading back from Chicago tonight… I think I’ll have her pick up lunch for tomorrow.