Great American Cookie Company

Every rare visit to this dismal glass counter introduces me to a new employee of the week who could care less. This place is consistently unsanitary and sad looking. So most recently I walked up to an empty station and a blonde girl emerged from the shoe store directly across from it. She put down the sneakers she was fondling and came over to unenthusiastically assist me. She used her BARE hands to grab my cookies like a golden-​haired Hulk. No handwashing, no gloves. I said «Hey, do you guys use gloves??» She said yes then proceeded to hulk my cookies around while she struggled to find gloves. She put on old gloves then started to use her filthy shoe-​hand cookies to create my snack. I asked for new cookies and she rolled her eyes. I said «you were just over there in the store holding a pair of sneakers.» Later she just sat at her station and texted. So you know she is touching, digging, and picking at everything and those are the hands she’s making your cookies with.

Delicious cookies!!! So fattening though so I usually skip :(
I used to LOVE the ‘double doozies’ from here! They are two soft chocolate chip (usually) cookies with SWEET cream in the middle.
I’ve only bought a cookie cake once from here and it was sooo good (and very sweet).
They’re a bit high priced though so I stick to my little local Shoprite.
Cash only.

The cookies here are always fresh. We got a cookie cake for my husband’s birthday. He loved it & the kids loved it. Customer service was great. They were very helpful & made the selection process easy. The decoration was cool.

Cookie and cakes are tasty, but customer service is bad. I arrived to pick up a cake I ordered 10 days in advance to discover they hadn’t made the cake. They told me they don’t bake without calling to confirm when I arrived to get the cake – yet I never received a call. Don’t order anything from them if you ever want to receive it.