Bakers Square

Perfect place 2 eat and enjoy the company with friends good food at good prices I love how they set a coffee pot right at your table 2 help yourself and very friendly service.

Slighted.
Stopped in Thanksgiving eve to pickup a pie and was told that all whole pies were spoken for, even though there were other walk-​ins who took one just before us and more non-​boxed pie in the case. I then asked if we could get slices of pie for carryout, cuz really, while a whole pie is a «deal», do I really need pie all weekend?! The guy at the register said sure and went to go grab some but was blocked by a manager who apparently didn’t want them to leave the premises. It seemed as though they wanted to keep the pie for folks who were dining in to get their «free pie» Wednesday. Now needing that elusive pie, we ended up at PNS and got a similar pie for less $.
One star for crappy customer service. Four stars for pie.

Food is good, service is EXTREMELY lacking on multiple visits, servers are too busy chatting with people they know coming in or hiding in the back, waited again today for refills and waited about 20 min for someone to notice I was flagging them down for a box. I go occasionally because its close and the food is good but please work on your service its been getting worse.

Good is good. Service could have been better at front counter

A 3.5 would be closer but because they are so accommodating and consistent, I’ll go to a 4. Been there and ordered takeout many times. For the type of place-​nothing fancy, generic food– they do it well. Their veggie burger is yummy but order it well done or it will be mushy.
The soft brioche buns they have recently switched to are tasty. Fries are okay, but not out of this world. If you have a sweet tooth, try their crepes with crème and strawberries. The crepes are thin and they used fresh berries. One complaint is the pie slices are getting smaller and more whipped crème than substance. Cutting back?

FPO: In graphic design we have a term called «For Position Only» or FPO for short. It means we’re using a photo that we haven’t purchased yet that is temporary in our layout. Bakers Square food is FPO. It looks good on the menu, it fills your stomach and leaves you feeling like you’ve eaten something, but will hold you over until you get the real thing.
ORDERED: My wife can out foodie a large percentage of the population but she likes strange things such as breakfast from places like Perkins and Bakers Square. I played it safe with a hamburger and fries. The fries were heavily seasoned with salt and black pepper — lots of black pepper.
The burger was super soaked with grease and toppings horrid. The tomato had locular jelly (look it up) that tasted like a shoe box silica gel packet, tough and tasteless. Pickles and lettuce were also limp and gross. FPO food. The service was friendly and fast.
PIE: I ordered a slice of «Pumpkin Supreme». Supremely good. The flip chart of pies that’s on your table tempts you to finish the garbage you happened to order just so you can order dessert.
BATHROOM: I’ve never been so tempted to ask a stranger pooping if they needed me to call an ambulance. Some things can’t be unheard. The bathroom was also filthy.

I have always had a very positive experience here. The staff is always friendly and the food is always above my expectations.

Pretty standard café food. The pie is spectacular — their French Silk is my favorite pie anywhere.

TIP: Pie Wednesday! Get your free slice of pie!
A friend and I went there Wednesday and it just so happened to be PIE DAY. Apparently every Wednesday is pie day, rather, you get a free slice of pie with every meal — except the meal that comes with a slice of pie, you don’t get two slices of pie (believe me, I asked).
So yea, looks like I’ll only go there Wednesdays, but otherwise it’s a decent place, all day breakfast menu, other decent lunch and dinner options from what I saw, the prices were average, about $ 10 per person.
I’d consider this a step up from a Denny’s… OK, a half step. It’s like Coco’s if anyone knows what that is.

I truly enjoy this chain, as described in the other review I’d done for the 76^th St. location. But, this particular location deserves some serious recognition. I’d been going here a long time and can honestly say this is the best location I’ve ever been to (I’ve also been to the Bluemound Rd. Square). I had placed a phone-​in order once and upon picking it up, realized to my dissatisfaction that the order had never been placed (even though I’d called 15 minutes prior). I was upset and later talked to the supervisor on duty. I was given an apology and got in communication later with the manager. She had given me free dinner tickets and a gift card for the errors. This is EXACTLY the level of service customers should receive these days. I felt appreciated and respected. I was given her business card in case I ever needed to contact her again (and it included another apology on the back). Generally-​speaking, the service here is really good, consistent and friendly. I enjoy having friendly waitresses and I know how hard it can be to keep that friendliness up in the service industry. So, it’s most appreciated. A recent waitress, I later discovered, was feeling under the weather but I never would have known that given the level of service she offered. The food, of course, is so delicious. The only thing I would not recommend is the flavored lemonades. Waitstaff reminds you of the Free Pie Wednesdays and as other reviewers have stated, it can get pricey here so coupons are great if you can find them.

If you want a fast food meal with many choices on their menu, Bakers Square is a good place. I like the one in West Allis better than the one on 76 Street. Food has always been tasty and sometimes they have coupons or deals to get pie with your meal. Servers are usually great about refilling your beverage and they even help decide which coupon is a better deal. Very customer friendly. Price can add up quickly with sandwich, beverage and pie but it is still better than grabing a burger someplace.

The service was very good. The restaurant was clean and well kept. I am only giving the restaurant 3 stars though because I feel the food and the prices do not add up. The quality and taste of the food was average with a price tacked on that would make you think you were going to receive a quantity of food that would be enough to take home for lunch the next day, but this was not the case. I would go back though for another slice of key lime pie alone.

Love the club! Used to work across the street for many years and we would come to BSquare at least 3 times a week. Great place for breakfast, lunch or dinner and a great place to sit and catch up with an old friend an chat. They always have fresh food and good sized portions. A few of the servers have been there for so long they have watched my son grow up and that’s pretty cool. Louise is so nice! Though I do not go for the pie, they do have good pies and cheesecakes. Menu has a large selection and there are always new selections and features.

We came in around 10:00 and was quickly seated we had Basic breakfast, with good friendly service. Not too busy. Lots of pies. Wednesday they offer free slice of pie after 9:30 with a purchase of any meal.
hint scoot into the booth 1 foot more in and seats are not cracked and worn out.

Breakfast was hot and fresh. Service was great. Waffles, eggs, sausage all recommended.

It’s a chain and when you go inside it definitely feels like one.
The food is like a Perkins, or similar. It’s not bad, but not amazing either. I would say that it’s just good.
The one thing that does set them apart a little is the insane amount of pies they have. Have fun paging through their flip book of mouth watering pies. It’s almost overwhelming.
If you go on a Wednesday you get a free slice of your choice with your meal.
Sadly, for Baker’s Square, an excessive pie collection does not grant you a pass to the elite 4 and 5 star eateries. Better luck next time.